WBAUnofficial
England v India Test Series!!.. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: England v India Test Series!!.. (/showthread.php?tid=37884)



RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Josh1873 - 06-24-2025

(06-24-2025, 07:54 PM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: An excellent all round performance by us. Especially as we are missing 2 or 3 of our better seamers,and the pressure on both Crawley and Pope must have been immense. Kudos to both for contributing in a big way. Would still like them to hopefully get Bethel into the team sometime this series. That kid is going to be some player.

Bethell chucked his wicket away for the Bears today, poor shot right before lunch. He's some talent and will no doubt forge a successful England career in all formats, but he still has a lot to learn.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Tom Joad - 06-24-2025

Fantastic test match. Well done England for such a controlled final day.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Wednesburybaggie - 06-24-2025

(06-24-2025, 08:02 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 07:54 PM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: An excellent all round performance by us. Especially as we are missing 2 or 3 of our better seamers,and the pressure on both Crawley and Pope must have been immense. Kudos to both for contributing in a big way. Would still like them to hopefully get Bethel into the team sometime this series. That kid is going to be some player.

Bethell chucked his wicket away for the Bears today, poor shot right before lunch. He's some talent and will no doubt forge a successful England career in all formats, but he still has a lot to learn.

He's still a babby, but I reckon he's one of these young breed of players, like Smith, like Brook, who will flourish on the big stage. A must for down under.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Ted Maul - 06-25-2025

Bit of weird one, lots of chat about what a brilliant test match it was but maybe I'm missing something.

Both teams had moments in the game where they could have really stamped home an advantage and didn't, India dropped a lot of catches, England dropped slightly less.

Bumrah aside India looked really average with the ball, Siraj perhaps unlucky not to grab a few more wickets and even Jadeja - who is brilliant - took 1-170. England arguably didn't have the standout bowler that India have in Bumrah but were more consistent across the team. Likewise with the batting, outside of three big hundreds the Indian lineup looked poor. England at least looked to share the runs around a bit more.

Maybe test cricket is changing but the chasing of 370 across those 82 overs seemed fairly mundane. The pitch I thought didn't help, flat as a pancake as we've been serving up here for the last couple of summers, it's really not helping us on our travels and given what the Australian pitches of the last few years have been like, will not in anyway prepare us for the Ashes. 

With the prospect of Wood returning for the final test, Tongue, Carse, Atkinson and maybe even Archer to return for England and with the likes of Rana and Deep waiting in the Indian reserves I really hope pitches improve for the remainder of this series otherwise we might as well stick a bowling machine at one end and just pick eleven batsmen.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - MrBater - 06-25-2025

I'm not a cricketing type, but reading this Fred was at time comedy gold. So many jump on the smallest thing from England and hail whoever the opponents are as the greatest team ever with at least double the good players England have.

It looked like an evenly fought battle to me, with us edging it, why can't that just be enjoyed?

I think it was only the 3rd or 4th test ever where each innings went over 350, that alone suggests a pretty special match.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Tom Joad - 06-25-2025

(06-25-2025, 08:08 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Bit of weird one, lots of chat about what a brilliant test match it was but maybe I'm missing something.

Both teams had moments in the game where they could have really stamped home an advantage and didn't, India dropped a lot of catches, England dropped slightly less.

Bumrah aside India looked really average with the ball, Siraj perhaps unlucky not to grab a few more wickets and even Jadeja - who is brilliant - took 1-170. England arguably didn't have the standout bowler that India have in Bumrah but were more consistent across the team. Likewise with the batting, outside of three big hundreds the Indian lineup looked poor. England at least looked to share the runs around a bit more.

Maybe test cricket is changing but the chasing of 370 across those 82 overs seemed fairly mundane. The pitch I thought didn't help, flat as a pancake as we've been serving up here for the last couple of summers, it's really not helping us on our travels and given what the Australian pitches of the last few years have been like, will not in anyway prepare us for the Ashes. 

With the prospect of Wood returning for the final test, Tongue, Carse, Atkinson and maybe even Archer to return for England and with the likes of Rana and Deep waiting in the Indian reserves I really hope pitches improve for the remainder of this series otherwise we might as well stick a bowling machine at one end and just pick eleven batsmen.

Points noted but what is a great test match? For me it's an evenly matched game that hangs in the balance over 5 days with moments of brilliance. So I personally enjoyed Pant's eccentric batting, Duckett reverse sweeping his way to (almost) 150 and I liked to see  (unusually for England), the efficient way they mopped up the tail. Don't underestimate the conditions on that last day, or the pressure. I'll be happy with the same again next week.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Ted Maul - 06-25-2025

(06-25-2025, 08:13 AM)MrBater Wrote: I'm not a cricketing type, but reading this Fred was at time comedy gold. So many jump on the smallest thing from England and hail whoever the opponents are as the greatest team ever with at least double the good players England have.

It looked like an evenly fought battle to me, with us edging it, why can't that just be enjoyed?

I think it was only the 3rd or 4th test ever where each innings went over 350, that alone suggests a pretty special match.

I think you've nailed all sports fans with your first point. The two teams are very closely matched, in home conditions I would expect England to edge it over the five games.

Your final point to me suggests a crap pitch that doesn't create an equal battle between bat and ball. There are some great bowling talents across the two teams, including one in Bumrah who will go on to be one of the all time greats (not if pitches like this become the norm, mind) and they're being wasted bowling on roads delivered so teams can thrash 400 as quickly as possible. That's my only issue.

(06-25-2025, 08:19 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(06-25-2025, 08:08 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Bit of weird one, lots of chat about what a brilliant test match it was but maybe I'm missing something.

Both teams had moments in the game where they could have really stamped home an advantage and didn't, India dropped a lot of catches, England dropped slightly less.

Bumrah aside India looked really average with the ball, Siraj perhaps unlucky not to grab a few more wickets and even Jadeja - who is brilliant - took 1-170. England arguably didn't have the standout bowler that India have in Bumrah but were more consistent across the team. Likewise with the batting, outside of three big hundreds the Indian lineup looked poor. England at least looked to share the runs around a bit more.

Maybe test cricket is changing but the chasing of 370 across those 82 overs seemed fairly mundane. The pitch I thought didn't help, flat as a pancake as we've been serving up here for the last couple of summers, it's really not helping us on our travels and given what the Australian pitches of the last few years have been like, will not in anyway prepare us for the Ashes. 

With the prospect of Wood returning for the final test, Tongue, Carse, Atkinson and maybe even Archer to return for England and with the likes of Rana and Deep waiting in the Indian reserves I really hope pitches improve for the remainder of this series otherwise we might as well stick a bowling machine at one end and just pick eleven batsmen.

Points noted but what is a great test match? For me it's an evenly matched game that hangs in the balance over 5 days with moments of brilliance. So I personally enjoyed Pant's eccentric batting, Duckett reverse sweeping his way to (almost) 150 and I liked to see  (unusually for England), the efficient way they mopped up the tail. Don't underestimate the conditions on that last day, or the pressure. I'll be happy with the same again next week.

It was a decent match a run chase is always impressive and it's one thing to say that chasing 370 on day five isn't as hard as it once was, it's another thing to actually go and do it.

I just want to see a fairer battle between bat and ball. I make the point about Jadeja, a world class spin bowler and he took 1-170 having bowled a lot of overs on a fifth day pitch. I don't want to take too much away from the players on both sides who I thought played well throughout, but the pitch made it a bit of a non-event for me. You could see from the Indian bowlers once England got to 150-0 that there was nothing there for them and that isn't right. Who'd be a bowler, eh? 

There has to be some deterioration in conditions, I can count on one hand the number of balls that 'misbehaved' off the pitch in this test match and that's not right given that it went to almost 7pm on day five. On the other hand I thought the Lords pitch for the WTC final was an excellent example of a test match pitch.


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Josh1873 - 06-25-2025

Cricket is always the best when there's a fair contest between bat and ball. I've said plenty of times that I like T20, but it doesn't excite me too much because it's a slogathon and batter heavy - unless a minefield pitch or overhead conditions play a part.

International One Day games are heading that way. You regularly see 300 v 300 and there's little in the pitch for bowlers. I hope that doesn't translate to the domestic One Day competition which provides a better balanced contest.

I love cricket as a sport, but I think the authorities need to be careful. I get seeing sixes and the ball smashed out of the park is fun to some, many, in fact. But there will come a point where kids won't want to become a bowler, as it's no fun to be smashed around the park and take part in games where you struggle to take a wicket. What then?


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - MrBater - 06-25-2025

Again I'm no cricketer, but to me getting in 3.5 innings over 5 days and providing quite a close finish suggests (even if the final score sounds like an easy win) a pretty even bat and ball contest. 35 wickets is 7 a day, which sounds like the ball types did good, and then the scores suggest the hatters did too, on the surface, outside looking in, I can't see what more you'd want?


RE: England v India Test Series!!.. - Ted Maul - 06-25-2025

(06-25-2025, 09:01 AM)MrBater Wrote: Again I'm no cricketer, but to me getting in 3.5 innings over 5 days and providing quite a close finish suggests (even if the final score sounds like an easy win) a pretty even bat and ball contest. 35 wickets is 7 a day, which sounds like the ball types did good, and then the scores suggest the hatters did too, on the surface, outside looking in, I can't see what more you'd want?

Personal preference at the end of the day. It wasn't a shit match, I just think we need better pitches. If we've paid any attention to what they've been producing in Australia their last two summers then they'd know flat tracks that do very little past the new ball are not going to help up.

Like with football some folks would rather every game ends up 5-3, I'd much sooner watch Diego Simeone's Atletico or a prime-Mourinho side beat a team with patience and grit.