WBAUnofficial
Silwood - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Silwood (/showthread.php?tid=21743)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Silwood - Derek Hardballs - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 06:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
74bus Wrote:
Squid Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Squid Wrote:But at what point should it draw legal consequences? Look at the case of the Nottingham airport tweets, or the Harry Miller case in which the high court ruled police actions had a "chilling effect on freedom of speech". It should be possible to discuss this without the floods of invective SOTV has faced. You might say those cases don't involve racism, but the concept of what it is offensive has spread very widely and police advice often isn't very helpful:

https://youtu.be/f4JYHEzb0S8

I don’t know those cases but my opinion has been consistent throughout the thread. There has to be a line where the law steps in otherwise you will empower people to glibly use racist, homophobic and derogatory terms for the disabled. The government and those within the law set what boundaries they are. If don’t have that deterrent then it’s a free for all and some will not be in a position to argue back and the question should be why they should have to. I do see the dangers of shutting down debate around religion, culture etc but that is not the same as using offensive terms that are solely about someone’s race, ability and sexuality. 

I am all for the right to offend and be offended with regards to choices people make. I think Brexit is an awful idea for example and may have said so on occasion ;). That is criticising a choice. There is a difference. Whether the law has the balance right is open to debate but I’d rather defend those on the receiving end of mindless racism, homophobia etc than those who went out their way to offend.

Which is what SOTV was trying to do, but has instead received a ton of insulting invective in response. It should be possible to debate and discuss these matters. 

My perspective is that I am strongly in favour of prison reform and generally oppose custodial sentences for non-violent crime, so I feel torn here. I'm pleased to see a court take a strong stance, but I don't usually favour such punishments. 

I do also think the line at which offensive speech becomes criminal speech is quite blurred and we should question what powers we are giving  authorities. It's fine to say, "Well it's to fight racism, disablism and homophobia", but those powers may be stretched to broader and unforseen purposes. Again, it should be possible to discuss this.
Not on this dump mate, where 'you're a cunt' is regarded as the epitome of reasoned debate. It should be clear to anyone that SOTV wasn't in any way supporting the actions of the odious Silwood.
He was asking whether the sentence was disproportionate and questioning the long term effect that such actions might have in the future, regarding people's right to speak out without being silenced by the powers that be.
Derek H and one or two others have put forward valid arguments that in this case, the threat to civil liberties was outweighed by the nature of the crime, but most of the posts aren't worth bothering with.

Good post 74Bus. It's clear to see we all agree the guy is a moron and good to hear the different viewpoints around that reasoning. I don't think the abuse is warranted and I've always been suspicious of the motive for it. As said back up the thread, there is currently a massive difference in opinion between the Women's Movement and the trans community. It is a regular argument on Radio 4 and it is somehow always the same side which finds the need to get abusive. Discussion of sensitive matters is a necessity.

Libertarian attitudes to allowing freedom of speech no matter how extreme as long as they are not inciting violence only serves to protect the rights of those saying those things not those on the end of those views. If the law is not an option for those people what is?! 

It’s true no one condoned what the WBA fan said but likewise arguing in the second paragraph that people should have the right to say anything they want under the law is simply wrong in a civilised society. Extreme points of view do not go away by holding them up to the light. There are numerous examples where to do nothing about extreme points of view simply enables them to become more popular rather than less as belief is more persuasive than fact.


RE: Silwood - Spandaubaggie - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 07:12 PM)Korenavirus Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 06:50 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 06:20 PM)74bus Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 01:48 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I don’t know those cases but my opinion has been consistent throughout the thread. There has to be a line where the law steps in otherwise you will empower people to glibly use racist, homophobic and derogatory terms for the disabled. The government and those within the law set what boundaries they are. If don’t have that deterrent then it’s a free for all and some will not be in a position to argue back and the question should be why they should have to. I do see the dangers of shutting down debate around religion, culture etc but that is not the same as using offensive terms that are solely about someone’s race, ability and sexuality. 

I am all for the right to offend and be offended with regards to choices people make. I think Brexit is an awful idea for example and may have said so on occasion Wink. That is criticising a choice. There is a difference. Whether the law has the balance right is open to debate but I’d rather defend those on the receiving end of mindless racism, homophobia etc than those who went out their way to offend.

Which is what SOTV was trying to do, but has instead received a ton of insulting invective in response. It should be possible to debate and discuss these matters. 

My perspective is that I am strongly in favour of prison reform and generally oppose custodial sentences for non-violent crime, so I feel torn here. I'm pleased to see a court take a strong stance, but I don't usually favour such punishments. 

I do also think the line at which offensive speech becomes criminal speech is quite blurred and we should question what powers we are giving  authorities. It's fine to say, "Well it's to fight racism, disablism and homophobia", but those powers may be stretched to broader and unforseen purposes. Again, it should be possible to discuss this.
Not on this dump mate, where 'you're a cunt' is regarded as the epitome of reasoned debate. It should be clear to anyone that SOTV wasn't in any way supporting the actions of the odious Silwood.
He was asking whether the sentence was disproportionate and questioning the long term effect that such actions might have in the future, regarding people's right to speak out without being silenced by the powers that be.
Derek H and one or two others have put forward valid arguments that in this case, the threat to civil liberties was outweighed by the nature of the crime, but most of the posts aren't worth bothering with.

I imagine politically I disagree vehemently with SOTV on many things. I called him a Little Englander the other day and he came back with a reasoned explanation of his opinions. 
However, I’m leaving this thread with a far far higher opinion of him than korenavirus who has dragged this discussion to the utter bowels of the worst of social media. 
Just constantly calling someone a ‘cunt’ to show how anti-racist he is makes him look an utter moron. 
If Korenavirus can’t explain views without this level of abuse he should just throw away his phone or laptop.

Who the fuck are you to call me a moron?

Several times I made it clear that what he is advocating is for the likes of Silwood, Griffiths (the leper of parliament) and those racists who abused the 3 degrees is who  he is saying must never be jailed!!!

He said what he said  and continued to say it.

I don't know him or his other political views and I don't fuck about them.

But, on this one you can say what you want to eho you want without penal penalty is bollox and shows him up got the agenda he is peddling.

Essentially, anyone can call anyone a racist term and as long as they don't continue with by saying I'm going to kill you it's ok.

I've read on here many times racist comments that minorities should have thicker skins and sticks and stones bollox, and I've shook  my head and just posted less.

So don't come with faux bollox with me because you don't know me.

And read my posts again, you'll see what I said that he wouldn't have got a prison sentence and what mostly likely happened for him to get it.
Wow three words in for your first expletive explosion. You are an utter imbecile. I’m really glad I don’t know you.


RE: Silwood - baggiebloke - 10-02-2021

Come on chaps.

Let's not let what that Silwood character did divide us on this board.


RE: Silwood - Tom Joad - 10-02-2021

I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense. Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?


RE: Silwood - Derek Hardballs - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 07:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense.  Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?

The state has to have a part to play or you leave people powerless to fight back against racism, ableism and homophobia. Education takes time to make an impact but whilst that happens it doesn’t help the poor person on the receiving end of constant verbal abuse. That’s where the law has to step in. 

Debate is not the same as being allowed to say anything you like. Some subjects are more complicated than others but there has to be some parameters to protect people.


RE: Silwood - 74bus - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 07:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense.  Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?

During World War Two, Ghandi was listening to a chap on Speakers Corner denouncing the war and the politicians who'd brought it about, whilst a couple of policemen looked on, unperturbed. He said, in admiration, that this was probably only the country in the world that this could take place.
Nowadays, we have the situation where certain universities will only allow inside speakers with whom they agree. Anyone with a vaguely right wing agenda (and I speak as a lifelong socialist), will not be allowed to put forward their views.
JK Rowling only has to comment upon aspects of the transgender debate and she receives death threats. 
We need to be careful.


RE: Silwood - baggiebloke - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 08:41 PM)74bus Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense.  Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?

During World War Two, Ghandi was listening to a chap on Speakers Corner denouncing the war and the politicians who'd brought it about, whilst a couple of policemen looked on, unperturbed. He said, in admiration, that this was probably only the country in the world that this could take place.
Nowadays, we have the situation where certain universities will only allow inside speakers with whom they agree. Anyone with a vaguely right wing agenda (and I speak as a lifelong socialist), will not be allowed to put forward their views.
JK Rowling only has to comment upon aspects of the transgender debate and she receives death threats. 
We need to be careful.

Re. WW2..

I think that Hitler chap was an absolute cunt.


RE: Silwood - Spandaubaggie - 10-02-2021

(10-02-2021, 09:20 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 08:41 PM)74bus Wrote:
(10-02-2021, 07:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I can't argue with that, Derek. What you say makes sense.  Silwood's remark was clearly offensive, the jail sentence warranted, but IMO, that wasn't the issue. The broader argument concerns the power of the state to determine what is offensive. The instance I quoted by way of example was where a member of the trans community was allegedly offended by Women's Movement supporters demanding women's only jails. Then the are the other arguments about athletes and gender. The Labour Party was this week splitting into factions over such matters. The world is shrinking and it's disparate communities are colliding, the only way to make sense of the unfamiliar is surely to listen?

During World War Two, Ghandi was listening to a chap on Speakers Corner denouncing the war and the politicians who'd brought it about, whilst a couple of policemen looked on, unperturbed. He said, in admiration, that this was probably only the country in the world that this could take place.
Nowadays, we have the situation where certain universities will only allow inside speakers with whom they agree. Anyone with a vaguely right wing agenda (and I speak as a lifelong socialist), will not be allowed to put forward their views.
JK Rowling only has to comment upon aspects of the transgender debate and she receives death threats. 
We need to be careful.

Re. WW2..

I think that Hitler chap was an absolute cunt.

It’s social media and the way we have triggers that push us back into a corner.

The Social Dilemma on Netflix explains it perfectly. Black or white, pardon the pun with no shades of grey. 
Well worth watching.

Unquestionably, I’m much more aligned with Korenavirus than SOTV politically. I’m liberal but hate the minutiae of pointless debate on stuff that doesn’t matter in the big scheme like identity politics.

I’ve been a union leader and when there’s been shit at work I’ve led the workers in and articulated the grievances.

I’ve mates and relations who are not white. However, through it all I want to convince people who are intolerant why they should listen to those they disagree with.

I see an utterly useless government led by an utter ‘buffoon’ and yet there’s no electable alternative as there’s a Labour Party navel gazing and ready to launch into a tirade over ill chosen words. It’s a woke bollocks of a party now.

So we are left with a mop headed clown of poor values with no idea and no vision beyond basking in the limelight. 

It’s a mess.


RE: Silwood - JOK - 10-03-2021

(10-02-2021, 08:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The state has to have a part to play or you leave people powerless to fight back against racism, ableism and homophobia. Education takes time to make an impact but whilst that happens it doesn’t help the poor person on the receiving end of constant verbal abuse. That’s where the law has to step in. 

Debate is not the same as being allowed to say anything you like. Some subjects are more complicated than others but there has to be some parameters to protect people.

Sadly  I’m not sure education will ever work. I’m an old bloke born and brought up in a time when attitudes were universally far worse and accepted than, thankfully, they are today. Despite my influences, I have come to understand how wrong those attitudes and actions were but it seems some who have grown up in, supposedly, more enlightened times are still able to hold obnoxious views.
 
I despair that the human race will ever attain Blue Minks vision of the World being  "a Great Big Melting Pot."

The debates on the severity of sentences (compared to other crimes) is one argument and where the line is drawn for freedom of speech, particularly, is, for me, an unanswerable conundrum. Freedoms come with responsibility but as we have seen, many people can not be trusted to be responsible.


RE: Silwood - Korenavirus - 10-03-2021

If education was going to work, it would have worked by now. Most go to have been to school and everyone has the opportunity to go to school. Most have worked with minorities but the problem persists and we have accept some don't like or want integration.

Fair play, it's a free country. Knock yourself out with your closed mind in your own combat 19.

My problem is when that hatred is aimed at someone and therefore impinges on their rights and freedoms for a peaceful existence.

We have a growing far right movement emboldened by the likes of Trump and what he says and does, calling foreign lands shit holes, Mexicans' rapists and mocking the disabled whilst being cheered by his adoring crowds.

Our own arsehole has form for similar offensive remarks.

Nobody on here has said we must imprison all people for their racist posts.

Youngsters, should get a caution and their parents made aware of what they are doing and if it persists then maybe put their address on a home and mobile internet ban.

The older generations also get a caution for a first offence if they accept what they did and apologise.

Then you get the pisstakers like silwood who tries to lie his way through the courts and comes a cropper.

I have no issue in him being fined heavily and if the fine isn't heavy then imprisonment.