| Welcome, Guest |
You have to register before you can post on our site.
|
| Online Users |
There are currently 4888 online users. » 24 Member(s) | 4859 Guest(s) Applebot, Bing, Facebook, Google, Twitter, ABBaggie, Ally's Balls, Ant74, baggy1, BasingBaggie, Borin' Baggie, Bristolbion, BurleyBaggie, Cheshire East Baggie, Derek Hardballs, Dial M for Mick, DoublebarrelBaggie, Dumbo, HugeHons, JeezArseChrist, Lurker#3, man in the corner shop, MikesDad, pindgill, Supamart1, Superhans, TadleyBaggie, waffle, Øssian
|
|
|
| Phillips and Mepham |
|
Posted by: Cheshire East Baggie - 12-28-2025, 04:46 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (12)
|
 |
I, like many on here, was initially impressed with these two. They looked as though they knew how to defend, which frankly was never the case with Semi, while Barts was prone to a meltdown now and then.
OK the coaching is obviously flawed, but why do experienced players somehow forget the very basics of the job? Phillips has been badly rattled by a series of errors in some games, seemingly unable to get his composure back once it's gone. Mepham seems lazy or complacent, always ready to try a flick or a touch too far when a simple clearance would be better. Then he glides on his way, seemingly untroubled by the outcome of his error. I'm not used to seeing this behaviour from Albion defenders, at least not until the last of McAuley, Olsson, Evans, Dawson moved on.
I don't think it's just the coaching, these guys have come here with an attitude that isn't helping us in our present plight. Compare and contrast with the effort put in by long-term spacegoats such as Molumby, Wallace and Grant, new candidates like Campbell and Price. They give the impression that they care. Phillips and Mepham have played relatively few games in their respective careers and have arrived here expecting to be the elder statesmen and settle in for a 5 year spell of success. I expected far more from them.
Worth noting also that it took Mason far too long to realise that Bielik needs to play. From what I've seen so far, he's a level above the other two.
|
|
|
| The Way forward |
|
Posted by: Baggiedownunder - 12-28-2025, 12:17 AM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (28)
|
 |
We can’t afford to sack Ryan Mason but something needs to be done.
Do we bring in an old head Megson O’Neil to work alongside him to offer support?
He might not like it but the ball is then in his court whether he stays or goes.
Constructive dismissal maybe but something that could be dragged out until the financial situation is sorted.
|
|
|
| Advice you would give Mason… |
|
Posted by: Bartley_baggie - 12-27-2025, 11:35 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (22)
|
 |
If you came face to face with him?
I would say force yourself to get more animated even if it’s not in your nature, you’re the boss, tell em what you want them to do, if it’s not working change it, keep it tight away from home for a while like teams do to us then go for it!
Does anyone tell him these things?
|
|
|
| Do coaches actually come back from this situation? |
|
Posted by: HeggebøsBarnDoor - 12-27-2025, 08:01 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (30)
|
 |
Not wishing to labour the point around staying or going as that's been done to death.
But just wondering what the statistics look like in terms of coaches who manage to make a come back from:-
14 points in the last 15 games
Lost 8 away games in a row
Any ideas? can anyone recall managers who have stunk a place up so bad and managed to turn it around? odds must be very small surely.
Not limited to WBA as I appreciate this is a very "special" situation Ryan is in.
Fergie is the obvious one but I don't think Mason is quite of that calibre.
|
|
|
| A couple of (possibly dumb-ass) questions re the Mason situation |
|
Posted by: Cheshire East Baggie - 12-27-2025, 04:59 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (5)
|
 |
The first one picks up his comments about the refereeing performance. He said "Then we'll get a 10th E mail saying that there were a couple of massive errors again". Does this really happen, does the EFL really say "Oops, sorry, got it wrong there"? And have we really had 9 of these already? Why are they not made more public? Or is Mason reaching the point where he's scattering excuses around as a smokescreen?
And secondly, if we accept that there is no chance of firing him, due to the financial situation and Nestor's reluctance to admit to an error, what alternatives are there? If I were Patel or Nestor, I'd be desperate to take him on one side and spell out the obvious shortfalls in his coaching methods and outcomes, ask him what he needs by way of support (be it changes in backroom staff or whatever) to turn things around. That's what has to happen in the real world of work - you can't fire someone for being a bit shit, you have to spell out your expectations and try to help them shape up. But football "professionals" have always kicked off big time when club hierarchies try to "interfere in the playing side". So short of immediate sacking, what would you do?
|
|
|
|