WBAUnofficial
The stupid off side rules - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The stupid off side rules (/showthread.php?tid=7948)



The stupid off side rules - CA Baggie - 12-22-2019

Had Sawyers’ shot hit a defender and fallen at Austin’s feet he wouldn’t be deemed offside as it came off an opposition player, so why is it off side from the GK?  What law is this covered under?  Maybe Sheff (or whatever name he now posts under) can enlighten me...

He wasn’t interfering with the keepers sight etc.  

Don’t get me started on a pass to a player in an offside position and that not being called offside until he touches it.  If that’s not interfering with play then I don’t what is!  I’m aware it’s the law of the game, but sometimes the law is an ass.

Any player behind the defence on a forward ball should be called offside in my opinion.


RE: The stupid off side rules - Spandaubaggie - 12-22-2019

Good point, but bearing in mind they should have been 2-0 up at the break after Bartley played Gaelic football, think we should count our blessings on this occasion.


RE: The stupid off side rules - SW4Baggie - 12-22-2019

I believe Austin was offside when Periera took the shot, and due to his position he was considered to be interfering with play. When the ball then came back off the ‘keeper and Austin tapped in, he was still considered offside.

Had Periera’s initial shot gone in the linesman may well have flagged for offside on Austin.


RE: The stupid off side rules - Atomic - 12-22-2019

If Pereiras shot had gone in the goal would probably have stood. Austin, who was offside as Pereira shot, becomes active when the ball comes back off the keeper. I don't know what the moaning is about it was a correct offside decision.


RE: The stupid off side rules - Bloke who lives abroad - 12-22-2019

I'm sure Offside was originally brought in to stop "goal hanging". The law should be completely re-written to reflect that. At the moment it is far too fussy. A player should only be offside is he is hanging around in the penalty area with no defenders between him and the GK.

TBF I appreciate that there is about as much chance of FIFA making such a sensible change as their is of them ever admitting the (alleged) huge bribery and corruption over Qatar WC.


RE: The stupid off side rules - Tom Joad - 12-22-2019

(12-22-2019, 11:44 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Had Sawyers’ shot hit a defender and fallen at Austin’s feet he wouldn’t be deemed offside as it came off an opposition player, so why is it off side from the GK?  What law is this covered under?  Maybe Sheff (or whatever name he now posts under) can enlighten me...

He wasn’t interfering with the keepers sight etc.  

Don’t get me started on a pass to a player in an offside position and that not being called offside until he touches it.  If that’s not interfering with play then I don’t what is!  I’m aware it’s the law of the game, but sometimes the law is an ass.

Any player behind the defence on a forward ball should be called offside in my opinion.
Infuriating. Just stick the bloody flag up.


RE: The stupid off side rules - CA Baggie - 12-22-2019

(12-22-2019, 12:21 PM)Atomic Wrote: If Pereiras shot had gone in the goal would probably have stood. Austin, who was offside as Pereira shot, becomes active when the ball comes back off the keeper. I don't know what the moaning is about it was a correct offside decision.

who’s moaning?

I just don’t understand the difference in the law when a player makes a forward pass to a player in an off side position that if it flicks a defender he’s no longer deemed to be offside versus the ball coming back off the keeper.  Seems you don’t either.

IMO it’s actually worse in open play as defenders can be unsure about leaving the ball and in attempting to intercept end up touching the ball and now putting the player on-side.  Ridiculous. 

I believe the goal would have stood as he wasn’t in the keepers eye-line.