WBAUnofficial
Still confused - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Still confused (/showthread.php?tid=7825)



Still confused - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-13-2019

In the worst election of my (long) life, the one like Liverpool vs Aston Villa where you want them both to lose, there is no good outcome etc etc - - -

I still don't know what "the people" who "have spoken" (again) are expecting to get out of this result.

Can anyone explain to me what benefits will come from Brexit, or how they are worth the huge risks to our economy? Still waiting for an answer after 4 years of Brexit talk.

Does anyone really think Boris can get us out with a comprehensive free-trade deal and an open Irish border by December next year? Well, no one with any actual knowledge of the subject.

Will this fix the immigration issue, as the numbers of non-EU immigrants rises each year?

Do people believe that Boris will deliver the "New Golden Era" that he promised, when all the figures indicate that spending on services will be level at best and still well short of 2010 numbers by the end of this Parliament.

It's all very well Neil Parsley dancing a merry jig of delight all over Derek's carcase, but this election hasn't got us anywhere, has it? We're still in a colossal mess, created and sustained by the two main political parties who have both shown they aren't fit to govern.


RE: Still confused - Neil Parsley - 12-13-2019

Why are you seeking to have arguments you lost around 41 months ago?


RE: Still confused - Ossian - 12-13-2019

Chris Morris (BBC) did a very good short interview a couple of days ago, dealing mostly with the trade negotiations part of the withdrawal. The difficulties he could see arose from the fact that most trade negotiations are between parties whose objective is to get closer to each other; negotiations involving a controlled separation are a bit of an unknown quantity, certainly on the scale we and the EU will be attempting.

In layman's terms the message seemed to be that just cherry-picking bits we'd like to hang on to is a bit of a fantasy. Everything will come at a price: quid pro quo, so to speak. Good thing Boris and Rees-Mogg have kept their latin brushed up.


RE: Still confused - fuzzbox - 12-13-2019

(12-13-2019, 10:32 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote: Why are you seeking to have arguments you lost around 41 months ago?

I'm not sure the argument has been 'lost' but the decision has definitely been made.

Now bearing in mind that the decision has been made I can understand why people may want to take a close look at the ramifications now it's not a possibility, but actually a reality.

Bit late to do anything about it, of course, but I can see why people will start to moan. My unasked for advice to you is just to relax and let it blow over. You've got what you wanted., just let the last embers slowly burn out.

From my own point of view, I'm re-reading all the pro-leave editorial and hoping to find a silver lining that me and mine can take advantage of. I'm not happy, but I'm hoping we'll find a benefit that we might have missed.

(Neil - seems like I'm stalking you - I'm not, honest!)


RE: Still confused - ChamonixBaggie - 12-14-2019

Given that my job and home are now directly threatened in 2 months time I'd also quite like it if anyone could at least attempt to apportion a shred of positivity to a further 5 years of tory government if only to improve my currently foul mood.


RE: Still confused - Babel - 12-14-2019

(12-14-2019, 03:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Given that my job and home are now directly threatened in 2 months time I'd also quite like it if anyone could at least attempt to apportion a shred of positivity to a further 5 years of tory government if only to improve my currently foul mood.

I think (and hope) that your status will be regulated by French law, Cham. I know that reciprocal legislation has already been drawn up where I live. If you're a permanent resident you should be ok, but you might consider pensions etc. HMGOV have form at weaseling out of indexed pensions for those eligible.


RE: Still confused - ChamonixBaggie - 12-14-2019

Yeah, I'm fairly au fait with the residency process (although I had hoped not to have to use it) although it's going to cost me 120 euro a year.

Fortunately for me the French government aren't bastards.


RE: Still confused - Derek Hardballs - 12-14-2019

(12-13-2019, 10:11 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: In the worst election of my (long) life, the one like Liverpool vs Aston Villa where you want them both to lose, there is no good outcome etc etc - - -

I still don't know what "the people" who "have spoken" (again) are expecting to get out of this result.

Can anyone explain to me what benefits will come from Brexit, or how they are worth the huge risks to our economy? Still waiting for an answer after 4 years of Brexit talk.

Does anyone really think Boris can get us out with a comprehensive free-trade deal and an open Irish border by December next year? Well, no one with any actual knowledge of the subject.

Will this fix the immigration issue, as the numbers of non-EU immigrants rises each year?

Do people believe that Boris will deliver the "New Golden Era" that he promised, when all the figures indicate that spending on services will be level at best and still well short of 2010 numbers by the end of this Parliament.

It's all very well Neil Parsley dancing a merry jig of delight all over Derek's carcase, but this election hasn't got us anywhere, has it? We're still in a colossal mess, created and sustained by the two main political parties who have both shown they aren't fit to govern.

I’m far from dying in a ditch Chesh the rest I agree with. The question to all that voted Brexit and Conservative what have you actually won? What’s the prize? 

Still waiting three long years on for the benefits of Brexit. When someone offers something tangible please post it, I’d like to know what’s in the Union Jack clad box now the ribbon is to be pulled.

(12-14-2019, 03:56 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Given that my job and home are now directly threatened in 2 months time I'd also quite like it if anyone could at least attempt to apportion a shred of positivity to a further 5 years of tory government if only to improve my currently foul mood.

It’s ok you can have a blue passport... let the healing process begin


RE: Still confused - Derek Hardballs - 12-14-2019

(12-14-2019, 10:08 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: In fairness I have seen answers on here but the answers get rejected and the claim remains no one has answered the question and it is a circular argument. The benefits hoped for being out of the EU are as far as I understand to do with the UK having control of its trade deals and laws/regulations better to suit the UK rather than the EU as a block. The theory would be longterm the UK will benefit from this freedom to self negotiate economically and benefit in other ways by not having to apply EU laws seen as not suited to the UK. No one can answer whether this will bring more benefits longterm than being in the EU without a crystal ball or a time machine but most reports seem to be predicting in the initial period an economic hit at least. But then any big change can have a hit and isn't necessarily an argument for never changing. Anyhow I imagine there are other forums for a far better answer with more meat on the bone but I imagine it would still be speculative with future predictions that couled be way out. Same with staying in though - what future for the EU block - there are currently problems there and the central bank has had to hold interest rates incredibly low for a long time now with no sign this will change. I maintain we are all doomed either way.

Most if not all the benefits that were posted on here were rejected because when scrutinised properly they had little or no basis in fact. That’s not the same as people blindly rejecting them.

Even leading Brexiteers have said it’s going to take years / decades to see any real benefits to where we were before we started this nonsense. That’ll solve the problems those blue collar workers have been persuaded to blame the EU for in the next five years. 

Long term prospects through my crystal ball a low tax, low regulated, low workers rights giant warehouse and banking sector island just off the coast of Europe. Grey Britain!