WBAUnofficial
The best player who was as good as a manager - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The best player who was as good as a manager (/showthread.php?tid=6714)

Pages: 1 2


The best player who was as good as a manager - Spandaubaggie - 09-27-2019

Seeing the thread about the hope that Brunt may be an Albion boss of the future got me thinking the best player we have seen who was top drawer as a manager.
For me, I can't think beyond Johnny Giles and the fact he combined both at the same time makes me think this.
He was clearly one of the finest players of his generation, he'd be worth £50m today in his prime, and even at 35 he was a superstar for us and got us from a mediocre second tier team to 7th in the first division.
I think if he'd stayed we would have been even better than we were under Big Ron. After all, he signed Cunningham.
Only Batson of the 79 team was signed by Big Ron. 
Bryan Robson is probably the only other superstar player we have had who did both jobs for us. Brilliant player, but a bit meh as a manager- despite the Great Escape being something we'll never forget.


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Poppy’s dad - 09-27-2019

(09-27-2019, 03:32 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Seeing the thread about the hope that Brunt may be an Albion boss of the future got me thinking the best player we have seen who was top drawer as a manager.
For me, I can't think beyond Johnny Giles and the fact he combined both at the same time makes me think this.
He was clearly one of the finest players of his generation, he'd be worth £50m today in his prime, and even at 35 he was a superstar for us and got us from a mediocre second tier team to 7th in the first division.
I think if he'd stayed we would have been even better than we were under Big Ron. After all, he signed Cunningham.
Only Batson of the 79 team was signed by Big Ron. 
Bryan Robson is probably the only other superstar player we have had who did both jobs for us. Brilliant player, but a bit meh as a manager- despite the Great Escape being something we'll never forget.
Bobby Robson ?


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Remi_Moses - 09-27-2019

Can only be one and that's Brian Clough


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - WWHO - 09-27-2019

May i be the first (and last) to say Brian Talbot ...


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Beachboysbaggie - 09-27-2019

Away from the Brom I’d say Cruyff. Sublime player and is credited with starting the whole Barcelona ethos we see today.


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Birdman1811 - 09-27-2019

Guardiola?

Unless you mean just players for us.


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Ampadu's Left Boot - 09-27-2019

(09-27-2019, 04:20 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: Away from the Brom I’d say Cruyff. Sublime player and is credited with starting the whole Barcelona ethos we see today.

Hard to argue against Cruyff.

Beckenbauer would be another possibility, but I think Cruyff would be my choice too.


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Tom Joad - 09-27-2019

(09-27-2019, 03:36 PM)Poppy’s dad Wrote:
(09-27-2019, 03:32 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Seeing the thread about the hope that Brunt may be an Albion boss of the future got me thinking the best player we have seen who was top drawer as a manager.
For me, I can't think beyond Johnny Giles and the fact he combined both at the same time makes me think this.
He was clearly one of the finest players of his generation, he'd be worth £50m today in his prime, and even at 35 he was a superstar for us and got us from a mediocre second tier team to 7th in the first division.
I think if he'd stayed we would have been even better than we were under Big Ron. After all, he signed Cunningham.
Only Batson of the 79 team was signed by Big Ron. 
Bryan Robson is probably the only other superstar player we have had who did both jobs for us. Brilliant player, but a bit meh as a manager- despite the Great Escape being something we'll never forget.
Bobby Robson ?

Agree with Robson. Ronnie Allen too from that era, he did a fair job managing us 1st time around, and the Dings too.


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Swanage Baggie - 09-27-2019

(09-27-2019, 04:10 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Can only be one and that's Brian Clough

+10000000


RE: The best player who was as good as a manager - Tom Joad - 09-27-2019

(09-27-2019, 05:50 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2019, 04:10 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Can only be one and that's Brian Clough

+10000000

Never played in the top division though.