WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=6531)

Pages: 1 2


Ratings - SW4Baggie - 09-14-2019

Johnstone 8

Ferguson 8
Bartley 8
Ajayi 9 
Ferguson 7 (based on a couple misses!)

Livermore 5 
Sawyers 5

Phillips 6
Periera 7
Grady 7

Austin 6

HRK 7
Edwards 8
Krovinovic 8

Subs changed the game. 

Take the point, but Fulham very much like us last season... excellent players but no system. They should be running away with this division but think 4th


RE: Ratings - Birdman1811 - 09-14-2019

Ferguson so good he plays RB and LB.


RE: Ratings - Shabby Russian - 09-14-2019

(09-14-2019, 01:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Johnstone 8

Ferguson 8
Bartley 8
Ajayi 9 
Ferguson 7 (based on a couple misses!)

Livermore 5 
Sawyers 5

Phillips 6
Periera 7
Grady 7

Austin 6

HRK 7
Edwards 8
Krovinovic 8

Subs changed the game. 

Take the point, but Fulham very much like us last season... excellent players but no system. They should be running away with this division but think 4th

Not seeing the 7s for Diaganawa and Pereira. Nor the 6 for Phillips. Think collectively they were poor today.


RE: Ratings - Birdman1811 - 09-14-2019

Grady and Peirerea not 7's for me. 6's at best, couldn't get going, not helped by lack of midfield. Again, not for lack of trying.


RE: Ratings - SW4Baggie - 09-14-2019

Thought Grady and Periera both tracked back and won possession back. Phillips was completely anonymous but at least Grady and Periera we’re dropping deep and trying to get things moving.


RE: Ratings - chasetownbaggie - 09-14-2019

Ajayi and Bartley played well, but I'd have to give Sam the MotM today - but for him we'd have been well beaten. That reflex save from the header in the first half was outstanding.

P.S. I think Ferguson deserved more considering he played RB AND LB Big Grin


RE: Ratings - Penny Black Baggie - 09-14-2019

Ferguson was a 9


RE: Ratings - WorcBaggie - 09-14-2019

So difficult to mark players when watching on the tv as cannot see the work off the ball. Can understand where SW4 is coming from as when the camera panned round to where Fulham had moved to Diang and Perreria were seemingly well placed and had tracked back. Hate watching it on the box but for our last 20-25 alone I think the point seemed well deserved.

Have to endure this again for the game away at QPR as well   Angry


RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 09-14-2019

SJ 8 - kept us in it first half, distribution poor though

Furlong 7 - Great energy, had 3 attempts on goal and really should have won it at the end

Ferguson 8 - Doesnt give us the balance Gibbs or Townsend does but so quick over 5 yards and a proper old fashioned "rash" type of defender

Bartley 8 - Excellent today

Semi 8 - Looks a steal for the money

Livermore 5 - Poor today, done for the goal, just a yard too slow at times although up against the excellent Reed, be interesting to see if Bilic is brave and drops him for Filipe at home when sides sit back

Sawyers 5 - I've said previously he gives us nothing when we don't have the ball, was AWOL for the best part of 60 minutes but when we got a foothold in the game, was his usual composed and incisive self

Perera - 6 Best of the three for me, worked hard, so good in tight areas but below par from last game

Diangana - 5 Nothing worked for him today, one of those afternoons and Fulham closed him down very quickly

Phillips - 5 See above, seemed leggy and never got in the game but worked hard

Austin 6 - Put the yards in but fail to see how he would have been a better option than Kenneth when we were under the cosh so much early on

Subs

Edwards 8 - Thought he was excellent, very direct, just what we needed at the time

HRK - 7 Worked hard, found pockets off space which hurt Fulham, gets some stick but always been a useful player at this level and can play numerous roles

Filipe - 7 Composed, must be pushing JL hard for a starting spot alongside Sawyers


Decent point against a good side, will be a great point if we win next Sunday

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Shabby Russian - 09-14-2019

(09-14-2019, 02:32 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 8 - kept us in it first half, distribution poor though

Furlong 7 - Great energy, had 3 attempts on goal and really should have won it at the end

Ferguson 8 - Doesnt give us the balance Gibbs or Townsend does but so quick over 5 yards and a proper old fashioned "rash" type of defender

Bartley 8 - Excellent today

Semi 8 - Looks a steal for the money

Livermore 5 - Poor today, done for the goal, just a yard too slow at times although up against the excellent Reed, be interesting to see if Bilic is brave and drops him for Filipe at home when sides sit back

Sawyers 5 - I've said previously he gives us nothing when we don't have the ball, was AWOL for the best part of 60 minutes but when we got a foothold in the game, was his usual composed and incisive self

Perera - 6 Best of the three for me, worked hard, so good in tight areas but below par from last game

Diangana - 5 Nothing worked for him today, one of those afternoons and Fulham closed him down very quickly

Phillips - 5 See above, seemed leggy and never got in the game but worked hard

Austin 6 - Put the yards in but fail to see how he would have been a better option than Kenneth when we were under the cosh so much early on

Subs

Edwards 8 - Thought he was excellent, very direct, just what we needed at the time

HRK - 7 Worked hard, found pockets off space which hurt Fulham, gets some stick but always been a useful player at this level and can play numerous roles

Filipe - 7 Composed, must be pushing JL hard for a starting spot alongside Sawyers


Decent point against a good side, will be a great point if we win next Sunday

Cuzer

Don't disagree with this assessment. I might have given Sawyers an extra mark, thought defensively he did ok. I would like to have seen a heat map of where he was during the first half, because my impression in the first half was that he didn't get into their half of the pitch very often, whch is very different from previous games I have seen this season, ended  up wondering if this was a deliberate ploy by Bili if it was it didn't work. Thought when we had the ball there was too big a gap between the front 4 and the rest of the team.

Last half an hour I think we did reasonably well and could have nicked it n the end.