![]() |
|
British Managers - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: British Managers (/showthread.php?tid=4935) |
British Managers - Bruntsleftpeg - 06-07-2019 As we all know, we are without a manager and have been for some time. There are multiple managers who lets face it are dreadful, we have had a few but I'm glad to see we have not been linked with some of the ones I consider the lowest of the low. Some of these managers have had many clubs and have failed at all of them, people such as Mark Hughes, Alan Pardew and Tim Sherwood for example.
People have been quick to blame the influx of foreign managers coming to the English leagues for the demise in successful British managers which I do not understand. The best managers in the division are foreign, people such as Guardiola, Klopp and Pochettino are amongst if not the best managers in the world, and this only raises the standard of managers in our leagues. This makes it easier for young English coaches to learn from them, to see new ways of playing, which can only be good things for the English game. We can all agree pressing is a key part of the modern game and each one of those 3 managers have a unique pressing system which I'm sure young English coaches can learn from. Im sure, the 'Best' British managers such as Brendan Rogers and Eddie Howe did not learn to play attractive football by watching Sam Allardyce week in week out, it was more than likely by learning from those top types of coaches that tend to be foreign.
These types of managers are not holding British managers back if anything they are brining English coaching standards forwards. The types of managers who hold them back are people such as Mark Hughes and Alan Pardew people that have failed everywhere and shouldn't be let near a club again. But let's say if Hull for example have a poor season and in February sack Nigel Adkins you can guarantee the names mentioned will be one of these if not another similar type of manager.
English Managers who we all agree should be given a chance to prove themselves are restricted by people such as these managers who keep getting jobs just because its the 'old pals act' again and it happens too much in football. It's known Pardew was appointed by us because he was friends with our chief executive at the time and Hughes keeps getting jobs because of his links to Man United. People should not blame foreign managers who if anything are a breath of fresh air to the leagues and look more towards the types of managers who are linked with every job, at the end of the day there is a reason they keep getting sacked, they are no good!
RE: British Managers - Dreamkiller - 06-07-2019 That's a bit unfair on Hughes. He didn't fail everywhere. He did well for Wales, Blackburn, Fulham and at Stoke for the first three years - at one point while at Stoke he was the 2nd longest serving manager at one Premier League club which suggests he was doing something right. If anything, we got relegated because our board were too slow to react to the downturn in form. That happened because Hughes had so much credit in the bank due to how well he'd previously done for us. He'll now struggle to get those jobs because of our relegation and his unsuccessful spell at Southampton. I've not seen his name seriously mentioned in connection with any job since then. I actually think that the old guard of Moyes, Big Sam, Pardew, Hughes and maybe even Pulis are now at the end of the road. There's a new breed of both British and foreign managers coming through with fresh ideas. Managers like Hughton and Bilic will start to become the new old guard. RE: British Managers - Big Daddy Cool - 06-07-2019 A lot of British managers simply aren't as intelligent as their foreign counterparts. They rely on motivation skills and getting the players "up for it" and giving 100% but fall down on the tactical side of things. For me managers like Howe and Potter are leading the way for how British managers should be. I know Potter is still unproven at Premier League level but he is very impressive and I think will do an excellent job at Brighton. RE: British Managers - Cheshire East Baggie - 06-07-2019 (06-07-2019, 08:26 PM)Dreamkiller Wrote: That's a bit unfair on Hughes. He didn't fail everywhere. He did well for Wales, Blackburn, Fulham and at Stoke for the first three years - at one point while at Stoke he was the 2nd longest serving manager at one Premier League club which suggests he was doing something right. I truly hope you are right about the demise of the old guard you listed above. And I don't cut Mark Hughes quite as much slack as you do. There was a generation of top players who seemed to believe that they had a divine right to succeed in coaching, and who have been underwhelming at best. Bruce, Robson and Hughes are three of these. I'm sure Ryan Giggs will also achieve little at club level if he ever returns to it. I prefer to see coaches judged by what they do as coaches, not what they were as players. Gerrard and Lampard are the two legends who seem to be cutting the mustard at the moment. Good luck to them - but success in coaching is not a given. RE: British Managers - ColliersWoodBaggie - 06-07-2019 Gerrard and Lampard played for quite a few non -British managers, let's not forget. They must have rubbed off. RE: British Managers - Dreamkiller - 06-07-2019 I’m not sure that Gerrard has done any more or any less than you’d expect a manager of Rangers to do. Lampard could go either way as well. He’s used his name and influence to get a number of decent loans in, which is fair enough, you use whatever advantages you have at your disposal. But ultimately, he didn’t really achieve much more than Rowett did, and Rowett’s now in the pot marked ‘derided’. |