WBAUnofficial
Fine margins - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Fine margins (/showthread.php?tid=4343)



Fine margins - baggy1 - 05-15-2019

4.30 and I’m lying here thinking of what might have been. Jay Rod’s shot at Villa Park and the finger tip save, Gayle’s ridiculous 1st yellow, the width of Johnstone’s boot from saving their last pen. Being 1 player short for half a season, that being Harvey Barnes. 

We held Villa over the 2 legs whilst playing nearly an hour of that with 10 men. And all of that against the new Messi. They won’t go up.

We start again next season and hopefully the club can sort out a new manager that has a plan and some money.

I’m physically knackered after last night and will be holding my head up high in a few hours. 

COYB


RE: Fine margins - boingingbaggie - 05-15-2019

A real lack of experince from the manager (certainly not his fault) is key for me.
Gayle should have been hooked Saturday. He was a ticking bomb and the way the twat reffed the game it was clear to see he was only looking for a second opportunity to book him.
I felt we were far too negative Saturday. We were 1-0 up, at Villa Park, the crowd were quiet and we seemed hellbent on time wasting our way through the second half instead of trying to get that second goal which could have made a huge difference.

Last night, he made the Murphy change too early. He was fucking woeful first half but at the start of that second half at least offered something of an outlet. It was obvious J-Rod was struggling, and Phillips is useless unless you want 60 mins from him, he shouldn't have hooked Murphy as quickly as he did. We lost him and Phillips and with it any pace or attacking intent.

There's an argument to say Brunt could have been taken off too but the loss of Johansen was massive. He was excellent last night and we didn't have anyone with the energy he offers to bring on his place.


RE: Fine margins - MGalea - 05-15-2019

Can I just add the two pens we should’ve had. One in each leg.


RE: Fine margins - Noibla - 05-15-2019

(05-15-2019, 07:18 AM)boingingbaggie Wrote: A real lack of experince from the manager (certainly not his fault) is key for me.
Gayle should have been hooked Saturday. He was a ticking bomb and the way the twat reffed the game it was clear to see he was only looking for a second opportunity to book him.
I felt we were far too negative Saturday. We were 1-0 up, at Villa Park, the crowd were quiet and we seemed hellbent on time wasting our way through the second half instead of trying to get that second goal which could have made a huge difference.

Last night, he made the Murphy change too early. He was fucking woeful first half but at the start of that second half at least offered something of an outlet. It was obvious J-Rod was struggling, and Phillips is useless unless you want 60 mins from him, he shouldn't have hooked Murphy as quickly as he did. We lost him and Phillips and with it any pace or attacking intent.

There's an argument to say Brunt could have been taken off too but the loss of Johansen was massive. He was excellent last night and we didn't have anyone with the energy he offers to bring on his place.
Spot on, Murphy started coming into the game second half, J-rod looked fucked. Losing Stefan was a blow, bench really was light last night and showed the weakness we have in depth


RE: Fine margins - Duffers - 05-15-2019

Three red cards in three matches.

That’s ultimately what cost us.


RE: Fine margins - Squid - 05-15-2019

(05-15-2019, 07:45 AM)Duffers Wrote: Three red cards in three matches.

That’s ultimately what cost us.

It's weird, because aside from Livermore, we've generally been ok on the discipline front this season.

Gayle's was dodgy though. No doubt about that.


RE: Fine margins - Duffers - 05-15-2019

(05-15-2019, 07:51 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-15-2019, 07:45 AM)Duffers Wrote: Three red cards in three matches.

That’s ultimately what cost us.

It's weird, because aside from Livermore, we've generally been ok on the discipline front this season.

Gayle's was dodgy though. No doubt about that.

The challenge he went for was definitely innocuous, but he had been walking a tightrope for about 20 minutes prior to that, much like Brunt last night he should have realised he was on his last chance and not given the ref a chance to make a decision. (A different ref might have carded Brunt for that challenge on McGinn right on half time). Neither of them are teenagers, they’re both experienced enough to know better. Just like Gibbs who lost his head in the build up to their penalty.

HRK can just fuck off.

This is what pisses me off, it wasn’t the kids who lost their discipline. It was the experienced pros, four players with over 1000 matches between them and who have played in the Premier League, Champions League and internationally who let us down. The ones who should have known better.


RE: Fine margins - boingingjim - 05-15-2019

Finally braved the highlights this morning (after shouting myself hoarse at the game).

That last Villa penalty is the absolute finest of margins. An inch more of Johnstones boot hits that he saves it.

I cannot fault any of the players for last night, there have been plenty of times to rightly criticise them this season but not one player could walk off that pitch last night thinking I could have done more. Brunt was trying to win the ball, he's just too slow to get there, that happens as you enter the twilight of your career the mind knows what to do but the legs can't quite manage it. If he had of backed off and their player waltzed through and scored everyone would be moaning saying why didn't he close down / make a tackle.

But the width of a boot stud and we could have done them in the shoot out. As this thread says it's fine margins.


RE: Fine margins - clem4england - 05-15-2019

(05-15-2019, 08:09 AM)boingingjim Wrote: Finally braved the highlights this morning (after shouting myself hoarse at the game).

That last Villa penalty is the absolute finest of margins.  An inch more of Johnstones boot hits that he saves it.

I cannot fault any of the players for last night, there have been plenty of times to rightly criticise them this season but not one player could walk off that pitch last night thinking I could have done more.  Brunt was trying to win the ball, he's just too slow to get there, that happens as you enter the twilight of your career the mind knows what to do but the legs can't quite manage it.  If he had of backed off and their player waltzed through and scored everyone would be moaning saying why didn't he close down / make a tackle.

But the width of a boot stud and we could have done them in the shoot out.  As this thread says it's fine margins.
Really good post.

I hate moaning about luck and I had little sympathy on Saturday for Gayle / Gibbs on the penalty but luck really conspired against us with the (midfield) injuries and everything ran for Villa down to winning the toss for penalties.