WBAUnofficial
This Palace v Brighton.... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This Palace v Brighton.... (/showthread.php?tid=43086)



This Palace v Brighton.... - Tom Joad 25 - 10-19-2026

derby  nonsense? When did this happen, and Why? I spent nearly 3 years living geographically smack in the middle of them and genuinely never met a fan of either. Plenty of Spurs fans (the Hoddle/Ardiles era) and some Man U, but never any of those 2. These days if I'm visiting I find it's mainly Chelsea fans. I've actually never met a Palace fan outside the Croydon area and every Brighton fan I spoke to last time we played them (we lost 3 0), actually said they supported someone else but Brighton was cheap and you get free travel.


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 10-19-2026

Something to do with a tackle in an FA cup game, small time from both of them IMO.


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - Duffers - 10-19-2026

Drove down the M23 earlier and could feel the hatred eminating from one end to the other.


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - BertieTheBaggie - 10-19-2026

Yes. It’s truly bewildering. Seems to be something dating to the late 70s when they were going for promotion together.
You have clubs without any real local competition so invent a rival. Cov try to pretend that Villa are rivals leaving puzzlement for the average Villa fan.


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - Man from delmonte - 10-19-2026

I remember watching a documentary about the Venables Palace Team Of The 80s a few years ago and it mentioned it. I seem to recall there was some issue to do with the kit along with various other tenuous issues.

It seemed to me to be two clubs that no-one could care less about creating a rivalry for themselves as they had no proper rivalries.

Edit: it was to do with the nicknames, not the kit. It's such a load of bollocks that the official Palace website needed to explain why they were rivals which sums up how tinpot the whole thing is: https://www.cpfc.co.uk/news/club/crystal-palace-brighton-rivalry-explained/


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - TR 675 - 10-19-2026

Have fake Albion now started singing
"Shit on the Palace..."

https://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/may/18/gus-poyet-fuming-excrement-crystal-palace


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - CIM - 10-19-2026

(10-19-2026, 04:54 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: derby  nonsense? When did this happen, and Why? I spent nearly 3 years living geographically smack in the middle of them and genuinely never met a fan of either. Plenty of Spurs fans (the Hoddle/Ardiles era) and some Man U, but never any of those 2. These days if I'm visiting I find it's mainly Chelsea fans. I've actually never met a Palace fan outside the Croydon area and every Brighton fan I spoke to last time we played them (we lost 3 0), actually said they supported someone else but Brighton was cheap and you get free travel.

Brighton like Reading 10+ years ago. Liverpool  Arsenal etc fans suddenly supporting their local club as their 2nd team as they are in the Premier League. I went out with a Brighton supporting lass in the days when Brighton couldn't always sell out the 7k Withdean in Brighton.
Feels like one of those manufactured rivalries like Coventry vs Leicester


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - SW4Baggie - 10-19-2026

(10-19-2026, 06:00 PM)CIM Wrote:
(10-19-2026, 04:54 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: derby  nonsense? When did this happen, and Why? I spent nearly 3 years living geographically smack in the middle of them and genuinely never met a fan of either. Plenty of Spurs fans (the Hoddle/Ardiles era) and some Man U, but never any of those 2. These days if I'm visiting I find it's mainly Chelsea fans. I've actually never met a Palace fan outside the Croydon area and every Brighton fan I spoke to last time we played them (we lost 3 0), actually said they supported someone else but Brighton was cheap and you get free travel.

Brighton like Reading 10+ years ago. Liverpool  Arsenal etc fans suddenly supporting their local club as their 2nd team as they are in the Premier League. I went out with a Brighton supporting lass in the days when Brighton couldn't always sell out the 7k Withdean in Brighton.
Feels like one of those manufactured rivalries like Coventry vs Leicester

Absolutely CIM. I don’t begrudge Brighton’s genuine fans some success as they went absolutely through the ringer for a decade but it’s a fallacy to consider them anything other than a 10k followed club that’s bought some serious success and converted another 20k people who can’t get a ticket in London but fancy a nice, safe day trip to watch the footy. The initial deal to include match day trains from Brighton and the surrounding areas as part of the ticket was a genius move to be fair to them.

A close friend from uni who lives down that way was always a Liverpool fan until about 10 years ago when   He and his dad magically got a Brighton ST and started saying “we have a great team these days…” - to be fair to them, they do have an excellent team this season.


RE: This Palace v Brighton.... - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-19-2026

(10-19-2026, 04:54 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: derby  nonsense? When did this happen, and Why? I spent nearly 3 years living geographically smack in the middle of them and genuinely never met a fan of either. Plenty of Spurs fans (the Hoddle/Ardiles era) and some Man U, but never any of those 2. These days if I'm visiting I find it's mainly Chelsea fans. I've actually never met a Palace fan outside the Croydon area and every Brighton fan I spoke to last time we played them (we lost 3 0), actually said they supported someone else but Brighton was cheap and you get free travel.

The Wiki testimony of it isn’t all that convincing:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brighton_%26_Hove_Albion_F.C.–Crystal_Palace_F.C._rivalry

But the testimony of the fans to whom it means - when I watched such a feature in the build-up to one of the recent derbies that meant something - lent far more weight to it. As always, personal feeling and testimony often outweighs what is often written down. 

What surprised me most was the changing of an entire nickname over it all! Just goes to show it must count for something. 

Perhaps Brighton are the slightly ‘posher’ club Sarf London option who’s fans should by rights support Palace but don’t. All I know is one of my best mates at uni was an Eagle, and he fucking hated the other Albion.