WBAUnofficial
Signings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Signings (/showthread.php?tid=42771)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


Signings - ericlegrisly too - 09-12-2026

Based on Lurkio's earlier post on Tunde and whether him saying he is shit will age well, I thought I'd pontificate on our summer signings.

I also understand that it is preposterously early to make these judgements but I am anyway.

Do I rate them / have they improved us:

Morgan - Yes

Myhre - No

Tunde - No

Townsend - Yes

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - No

Stewart - No

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - No.

looks like we're close to the mythical 50% being OK figure that is bandied about.

Apologies if that's a bit gloomy, just down after what I thought was a crap home performance today.


RE: Signings - MancBaggie - 09-12-2026

I’m a bit flat after that too tbh

But it’s 7 games in 21 days and we were the 1230 today after 10 men Wednesday 

Guess we have to look at the big picture and enjoy that


RE: Signings - Lurker#3 - 09-12-2026

Arf... Good post... Mine are whether I think they will be (viewed as) good signings when they settle and eventually leave.

Morgan - Yes

Myhre - No

Tunde - No

Townsend - Yes

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - Yes

Stewart - Yes

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - Yes


RE: Signings - Jacko - 09-12-2026

Morgan - Yes

Myhre - Yes

Tunde - No

Townsend - No

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - Yes

Stewart - Yes

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - Yes


RE: Signings - Hudds2 - 09-12-2026

(09-12-2026, 01:42 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote: Based on Lurkio's earlier post on Tunde and whether him saying he is shit will age well, I thought I'd pontificate on our summer signings.

I also understand that it is preposterously early to make these judgements but I am anyway.

Do I rate them / have they improved us:

Morgan - Yes

Myhre - No

Tunde - No

Townsend - Yes

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - No

Stewart - No

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - No.

looks like we're close to the mythical 50% being OK figure that is bandied about.

Apologies if that's a bit gloomy, just down after what I thought was a crap home performance today.
Cheer up Ericle. Look what yppu sed about Diakite....


RE: Signings - ericlegrisly too - 09-12-2026

(09-12-2026, 02:13 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(09-12-2026, 01:42 PM)ericlegrisly too Wrote: Based on Lurkio's earlier post on Tunde and whether him saying he is shit will age well, I thought I'd pontificate on our summer signings.

I also understand that it is preposterously early to make these judgements but I am anyway.

Do I rate them / have they improved us:

Morgan - Yes

Myhre - No

Tunde - No

Townsend - Yes

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - No

Stewart - No

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - No.

looks like we're close to the mythical 50% being OK figure that is bandied about.

Apologies if that's a bit gloomy, just down after what I thought was a crap home performance today.
Cheer up Ericle. Look what yppu sed about Diakite....

That's what I am basing my deconstruction of Tunde upon.


RE: Signings - SW4Baggie - 09-12-2026

Think it's a bit early... many of these have one start.

Which players were brought in as first team starters?

FHM, Morgan, Collyer, Nzingoula, Galvez -> Id say all 5 have shown they can play at this level... FHM the biggest disappointment but he's been used as such a utility player it's hard to judge. He has shown moments of real quality, intelligence and maturity.

Squad players:
Townsend, Stewart, Tunde, Pereira -> all have made contributions... Stewart leaves us a bit exposed as he really isn't ready IMO, Tunde the jury is definitely out, but again, hes 20, and Pereira we've not seen enough.


RE: Signings - oldun - 09-12-2026

(09-12-2026, 02:12 PM)Jacko Wrote: Morgan - Yes

Myhre - Yes

Tunde - No

Townsend - No

Nzingoula - Yes

Pereira - Yes

Stewart - Yes

Collyer - Yes

Galvez - Yes

Agree, except Townsend adequate and Tunde I think may become yes, happy clapper I supposr


RE: Signings - Fido - 09-12-2026

Townsend is just about decent enough as a fill-in but not a clever player at all. Didn’t look too bad today but had practically no defending to do.


RE: Signings - SW4Baggie - 09-12-2026

(09-12-2026, 02:33 PM)Fido Wrote: Townsend is just about decent enough as a fill-in but not a clever player at all. Didn’t look too bad today but had practically no defending to do.

Think that's harsh - I think Townsend is an experienced player who showed his nous today.

Had concerns given his age and injury lay off that we'd be signing another Charlie Taylor but he rolled back the years today. Thought he got up and down the flank well and still had an eye for a forward pass and a decent cross.

Very capable back up.