WBAUnofficial
Public sector internships - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Public sector internships (/showthread.php?tid=42651)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


Public sector internships - Fido - 09-04-2026

My daughter is about to start her final year of uni studying International Development and Geography at Sussex and is currently applying for various internships  post-graduation. She's mainly concentrating on those aligned to sustainability or similar but obviously is casting her net somewhat wider just to gain experience or get her foot in the door somewhere to kick things off. However, a few of the public sector schemes she is unable to even apply for as they are for lads and lasses of either certain ethnic backgrounds or from lower income backgrounds. 

I won't deny that growing up where she has she's had certain advantages that others won't have had so I'm not pleading poverty here and could accept the application process may take backgrounds into account to diversify the working population in those institutions the but think it's a little unfair that the door is completely closed to her from day one. Just thought it might be worth seeing what people's opinions are on this hoping it doesn't escalate too quickly!


RE: Public sector internships - PatelsPlatoon - 09-04-2026

Unfortunately the whole diversity thing as it currently is has created a hot potato. It's what led to Jason Arday and it, in my opinion, just stokes up more them and us and creates more racism.
I'm not denying disadvantaged need a helping hand, but at the moment its just helping stoke up culture wars.


RE: Public sector internships - Fido - 09-04-2026

I tend to agree, PP. I'm fully aware it is benefical for people from different backgrounds than a white girl from Berkshire to see they have a chance of gaining positions they may not have previously considered but it's the blocked path approach that I'm not comfortable with.

The other thing it can tend to do is push people to seek out special treatment where it's not merited. By brother-in-law and his family are your archetypal Fakebooker/LinkedIn avatars. Their son was refusing to go to school for a time so they invoked all kids of disability "allowances" which got him into UCL on lower grades than he would have usually required. I'm sure we all know of people trying to get certain diagnoses certified to get special treatment when it not needed or it's not merited.


RE: Public sector internships - tHEgLASSdOORS - 09-04-2026

(09-04-2026, 08:17 AM)Fido Wrote: My daughter is about to start her final year of uni studying International Development and Geography at Sussex and is currently applying for various internships  post-graduation. She's mainly concentrating on those aligned to sustainability or similar but obviously is casting her net somewhat wider just to gain experience or get her foot in the door somewhere to kick things off. However, a few of the public sector schemes she is unable to even apply for as they are for lads and lasses of either certain ethnic backgrounds or from lower income backgrounds. 

I won't deny that growing up where she has she's had certain advantages that others won't have had so I'm not pleading poverty here and could accept the application process may take backgrounds into account to diversify the working population in those institutions the but think it's a little unfair that the door is completely closed to her from day one. Just thought it might be worth seeing what people's opinions are on this hoping it doesn't escalate too quickly!

I sit on the other side of this sometimes, supporting access to some of the opportunities you mention. It is certainly a valid question. My solution would be a pretty simple one - that YP from less advantaged backgrounds are given access to interviews but at that stage everyone present is treated on the same merit. This does sometimes happen, but you are right that in some cases, opportunity is tilted beyond what is reasonable and fair


RE: Public sector internships - Fido - 09-04-2026

(09-04-2026, 08:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(09-04-2026, 08:17 AM)Fido Wrote: My daughter is about to start her final year of uni studying International Development and Geography at Sussex and is currently applying for various internships  post-graduation. She's mainly concentrating on those aligned to sustainability or similar but obviously is casting her net somewhat wider just to gain experience or get her foot in the door somewhere to kick things off. However, a few of the public sector schemes she is unable to even apply for as they are for lads and lasses of either certain ethnic backgrounds or from lower income backgrounds. 

I won't deny that growing up where she has she's had certain advantages that others won't have had so I'm not pleading poverty here and could accept the application process may take backgrounds into account to diversify the working population in those institutions the but think it's a little unfair that the door is completely closed to her from day one. Just thought it might be worth seeing what people's opinions are on this hoping it doesn't escalate too quickly!

I sit on the other side of this sometimes, supporting access to some of the opportunities you mention. It is certainly a valid question. My solution would be a pretty simple one - that YP from less advantaged backgrounds are given access to interviews but at that stage everyone present is treated on the same merit. This does sometimes happen, but you are right that in some cases, opportunity is tilted beyond what is reasonable and fair

There has to be a tilt to the unlevel playing field, I completely accept that, and tapping into talent that usually wouldn't see the light of day. But by the same token you don't want to create another pool of potentially wasted resource.


RE: Public sector internships - Borin' Baggie - 09-04-2026

Serious question, why is she applying for internships and not graduate roles if she's about to graduate? Presumably she's in her final year?


RE: Public sector internships - Fido - 09-04-2026

(09-04-2026, 09:11 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Serious question, why is she applying for internships and not graduate roles if she's about to graduate? Presumably she's in her final year?

She's applying for both but just wanting to cast the net wider so she might gain experience or get a foothold in somewhere that may offer an opportunity thereafter.


RE: Public sector internships - petty sniper - 09-04-2026

It may be the case that the roles that are restricted only exist because an external body is part or total funding them in order to create access. When I worked in local authorities this was quite common so in relaity she is probably not missing out becasue the opportunity was funded by an NGO amd otherwise wouldnt exist


RE: Public sector internships - Protheroe - 09-04-2026

You and your daughter have my sympathy. Public sector schemes in particular, are absolutely crackpot.


RE: Public sector internships - Fido - 09-04-2026

(09-04-2026, 09:55 AM)petty sniper Wrote: It may be the case that the roles that are restricted only exist because an external body is part or total funding them in order to create access.  When I worked in local authorities this was quite common so in relaity she is probably not missing out becasue the opportunity was funded by an NGO amd otherwise wouldnt exist

Possibly. 

One of them was for GCHQ, an organization where you'd want a large pool to be shrunk down to a very small number of talented individuals (for some roles at least) given the various threats that will continue to come our way. Not saying my daughter is necessarily one of those great minds, of course, but it seems a little short-sighted.