WBAUnofficial
"Industrial Strategy" and Labour's approach to addressing non-academic education - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: "Industrial Strategy" and Labour's approach to addressing non-academic education (/showthread.php?tid=42432)



"Industrial Strategy" and Labour's approach to addressing non-academic education - Borin' Baggie - 08-17-2026

I doubt it's gonna unnoticed that Labour want more "regional trades" (whatever that means, why would you pigeonhole kids into specific trades and not focus on transferable trade skills if you want to go down that route?) in secondary education. As you can probably tell I think this is stupid, a desperate attempt to undermine labour mobility that won't work as it doesn't capture value that can be uplifted and exported at scale, there's a reason why Birmingham got rich off services in the late 19th and early 20th century while the Black Country stagnated as European, Japanese and American industry caught up post-indusrial revolution. You're not going to stop the productive going to cities, and especially the most productive city (London), unless you kneecap London in which case you're screwing the whole economy.

The UK's problem isn't that we've not got people going into glassblowing, it's that we don't have enough post-secondary vocational opportunities and our academia-aligned vocational subjects (like engineering) don't produce domestic engineers but people who go into finance, law, management consultancies or people who go abroad (my bank account wishes I bothered to apply to the myriad of grad schemes involved in engineering paperwork instead of a certain large energy company with operations based near Southampton).

It's been shown time and time again that it isn't small businesses that create the bulk of apprenticeships both at post-16 and post-18 education, it's nationals and multinationals both directly and through their supply and consultancy chains and they do this through large infrastructure projects. Those infrastructure projects require regional distribution if they're invested in across the country. 

We're currently in a labour crunch where lots of experience in utilities and other key industries (transport) are retiring and that information is getting lost as there isn't the people to transferable that knowledge to. A lot of it is already lost (nuclear) and is going to take decades to build back up.

So basically, fucking hurry up and fix planning, incentivise infrastructure projects (housing, transport, water, rail, aviation), incentivise innovation, disincentivise unproductive paperwork and create companies with knowledge we can export instead of relying on Yankee and French firms to do it. Otherwise we'll have lost all the knowledge of the people retiring and we'll be relying on importing that knowledge instead of being able to export it, both through foreign services (expensive) and immigration (politically impossible).

Oh, and also when it comes to research, fucking bother to ensure domestic people and businesses are incentivised to capture and invest in innovation in the UK instead of letting it go abroad like with ARM and Deepmind, or with BR innovation, or like nuclear, or rocket and jet aviation before that. You don't create industrial knowledge through innovation by ignoring your innovations and letting someone else buy and that export that knowledge!

Train rant over.


RE: "Industrial Strategy" and Labour's approach to addressing non-academic education - man in the corner shop - 08-17-2026

Great post

I was thinking that Labour were trying some kind of modern day indentured servitude, where they send you to the local sausage factory school, on to the local actual sausage factory (or equivalent) without council/social housing provided or decent transport available. Thus making sure that kids stay in their lanes for the next generation.

The paucity of any actual thinking in this Zombie PLP and their government advisors is fucking demoralising.

Can you give Burnham a ring pronto and offer him some advice.


RE: "Industrial Strategy" and Labour's approach to addressing non-academic education - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-21-2026

(08-17-2026, 10:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I doubt it's gonna unnoticed that Labour want more "regional trades" (whatever that means, why would you pigeonhole kids into specific trades and not focus on transferable trade skills if you want to go down that route?) in secondary education. As you can probably tell I think this is stupid, a desperate attempt to undermine labour mobility that won't work as it doesn't capture value that can be uplifted and exported at scale, there's a reason why Birmingham got rich off services in the late 19th and early 20th century while the Black Country stagnated as European, Japanese and American industry caught up post-indusrial revolution. You're not going to stop the productive going to cities, and especially the most productive city (London), unless you kneecap London in which case you're screwing the whole economy.

The UK's problem isn't that we've not got people going into glassblowing, it's that we don't have enough post-secondary vocational opportunities and our academia-aligned vocational subjects (like engineering) don't produce domestic engineers but people who go into finance, law, management consultancies or people who go abroad (my bank account wishes I bothered to apply to the myriad of grad schemes involved in engineering paperwork instead of a certain large energy company with operations based near Southampton).

It's been shown time and time again that it isn't small businesses that create the bulk of apprenticeships both at post-16 and post-18 education, it's nationals and multinationals both directly and through their supply and consultancy chains and they do this through large infrastructure projects. Those infrastructure projects require regional distribution if they're invested in across the country. 

We're currently in a labour crunch where lots of experience in utilities and other key industries (transport) are retiring and that information is getting lost as there isn't the people to transferable that knowledge to. A lot of it is already lost (nuclear) and is going to take decades to build back up.

So basically, fucking hurry up and fix planning, incentivise infrastructure projects (housing, transport, water, rail, aviation), incentivise innovation, disincentivise unproductive paperwork and create companies with knowledge we can export instead of relying on Yankee and French firms to do it. Otherwise we'll have lost all the knowledge of the people retiring and we'll be relying on importing that knowledge instead of being able to export it, both through foreign services (expensive) and immigration (politically impossible).

Oh, and also when it comes to research, fucking bother to ensure domestic people and businesses are incentivised to capture and invest in innovation in the UK instead of letting it go abroad like with ARM and Deepmind, or with BR innovation, or like nuclear, or rocket and jet aviation before that. You don't create industrial knowledge through innovation by ignoring your innovations and letting someone else buy and that export that knowledge!

Train rant over.

There are an absolute stack-load of vacancies connected to all on Indeed/Glassdoor (same thing now) and LI. 

Problem is, so seldom do any of these industries consider cross-transferrable industry skills, in favour of ‘recruiting from within’.  Which is why some candidates with that expertise are in so much demand they’re commanding (and very often getting) six-figures when for the in the context of everyone else that’s overpaying. There really are some brilliant ex-O&G engineers out there, reliant on the state yet with so much value to add, who can’t and often don’t get a look-in.

It’s nothing new. Same in the past when lawyers, then IT consultants, and then accountants ruled the world.