![]() |
|
The Japanese all look the same racial slur - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The Japanese all look the same racial slur (/showthread.php?tid=41854) Pages:
1
2
|
The Japanese all look the same racial slur - BertieTheBaggie - 06-19-2026 Van Der Vaart the Dutch ex international had to apologise for saying that after commentary on their match. I’m slightly uncomfortable about it being framed as a racial slur if I’m honest. The reason it’s not a stereotype but an honestly held view explaining what he thought.If you have many people who are same hair colour and same height, and the same age, there will be a case of mistaken identity. It’s not like a 5ft 7 Japanese player is standing besides a 6ft 3 Japanese guy. I’ve seen some of our white players in the past who might be similar build and say have the same hairstyles where I’ve mistaken them. Does this make me racist regarding white players? I think he’s made a comment honestly held and in our modern society a journalist has seized on the comment and gone to the anti racism movement Kick It Out to create a story out of nothing that just isn’t helpful to anyone whoever they are in society. Maybe, being in my 50s, I’m missing something as we all have our opinions but honestly if this is racism now I don’t know what to do other than shake my head. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - Ted Maul - 06-19-2026 It's a bit lazy, he's paid to tell the players apart, they do have numbers and their names on their shirts. It's a phrase that has been used in the past as a piss take. There are lots of 6ft+ white men on the England team, are Japanese TV saying they all look the same? It doesn't have to be an explicit slur to be insensitive or hurtful. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - BertieTheBaggie - 06-19-2026 (06-19-2026, 05:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It's a bit lazy, he's paid to tell the players apart. It's a phrase that has been used in the past as a piss take. There are lots of 6ft+ white men on the England team, are Japanese TV saying they all look the same? It doesn't have to be an explicit slur to be insensitive or hurtful. Certainly a bit lazy. Beyond that I think it’s nothing more. I was at an engagement party last week where there was about 5 guys around 5ft 11 with brown beards. I said something about them looking the same to a couple of my friends. We seem to be living in an era where everyone everywhere is just waiting to hijack someone for the slightest comment that can trigger someone. It’s exhausting. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - Ted Maul - 06-19-2026 (06-19-2026, 05:48 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:(06-19-2026, 05:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It's a bit lazy, he's paid to tell the players apart. It's a phrase that has been used in the past as a piss take. There are lots of 6ft+ white men on the England team, are Japanese TV saying they all look the same? It doesn't have to be an explicit slur to be insensitive or hurtful. I did say it was probably a lazy, throw away comment than part of a wider VdV hate campaign however over years such phrases have been used to strip away at individual identities, reduce people to stereotypes and ultimately dehumanise them. Is VdV thinking about this when he said it? Hope not, probably no. Is it something that should be said on prime time coverage of the world's biggest sporting event in 2026? Also no. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke - 06-19-2026 I used to work for a Japanese company. As I was learning the names of some of their chaps I enquired to my boss who Mr Iwata-san was. "Short guy, brown hair." There's a kernel of truth to it so far as Westerners go as a lot of the variety we use for cues are reduced, as I'm sure there is to the Asian view that we all smell of stale milk. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - MrBater - 06-19-2026 It's the sort of thing a so called professional shouldn't be saying. Especially if it's your job. I just wonder what the reaction would be if it was a Brit commentator saying it, we all know it would be the most racist thing ever then RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - PatelsPlatoon - 06-19-2026 Interesting that VDV said it was a joke straight away. He’s adding a bit of light heartedness to the commentary, and I think most Japanese people would have not been too bothered by the comment, but don’t let that get in the way of the media whipping up a stupid story that can upset a tiny minority. Incidentally, I just googled an image of the squad. I’m a bit tech unfriendly otherwise would have shared the link. There’s several of them about 5ft 8/9 with exactly the same curtains hairstyle. They also haven’t facial hair as they don’t have the same genetics. To most people in their living rooms they’d all say they are a lot of them that look the same. However, working for the media Van Der Vaart should be wiser to how to avoid this media pitfall. We live in an era where we are all subjected to scrutiny in a way that wasn’t the case 20 years ago. It’s a good thing in most ways but when used like this not so good. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - MrBater - 06-19-2026 Slightly different, but an exasperated Naga Munchetty just moaned that the Post Office scandal feels like it's been going on for a long time... The guy covering the story replied, that's because it has. So etimes people on the media say the wrong thing. I just looked up the Japanese squad, they're pretty different looking to me. Sure 1 or 2 look similar, but that goes with most groups of 11 blokes from the same place.
RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - PatelsPlatoon - 06-19-2026 There’s a lot of them look like they could be in a Japanese Oasis tribute band. I can see if they were swarming around the pitch, especially being all within an inch or two of the same height they’d be mistaken, but that’s just subjective opinion rather than some other sinister interpretation. Regardless they are a decent side and I expect they’ll go fairly far in the competition. RE: The Japanese all look the same racial slur - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-19-2026 "Short guy. Awful hair" |