WBAUnofficial
Jaffa cakes VAT is mad? Marshmallows madder and uses maths - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Jaffa cakes VAT is mad? Marshmallows madder and uses maths (/showthread.php?tid=41241)



Jaffa cakes VAT is mad? Marshmallows madder and uses maths - Hudds2 - 04-09-2026

The makers of the giant marshmallows win as Tax Tribunal (re-referred) ruled against HMRC, stating they should be zero rated (It's about making things called s'mores).

The company also produced a mathematical formula the tribunal used to finalise its decision on VAT status.

The judge stated: ‘We find that 1) Way A, eating direct from the skewer, is more frequently used than Way B, taking from skewer and eating with fingers; 2) Way C, s'more, is more frequently used than Way D, unroasted from the packet.

‘It therefore follows that in aggregate, we find as a fact that that the product is more frequently eaten by one of the non-finger ways than by one of the with-the-fingers ways. To put it in mathematical formulation, because A > B and C > D, (A + C) > (B + D).’


I tried to work that out.  I got a doughnut.


RE: Jaffa cakes VAT is mad? Marshmallows madder and uses maths - CarlosCorbewrong - 04-09-2026

You can’t skewer them and cook them on a Ninja Woodfire though.

How did they decide that shovelling them was less popular that smoring them!


RE: Jaffa cakes VAT is mad? Marshmallows madder and uses maths - HeggebøsBarnDoor - 04-09-2026

(04-09-2026, 03:49 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: The makers of the giant marshmallows win as Tax Tribunal (re-referred) ruled against HMRC, stating they should be zero rated (It's about making things called s'mores).

The company also produced a mathematical formula the tribunal used to finalise its decision on VAT status.

The judge stated: ‘We find that 1) Way A, eating direct from the skewer, is more frequently used than Way B, taking from skewer and eating with fingers; 2) Way C, s'more, is more frequently used than Way D, unroasted from the packet.

‘It therefore follows that in aggregate, we find as a fact that that the product is more frequently eaten by one of the non-finger ways than by one of the with-the-fingers ways. To put it in mathematical formulation, because A > B and C > D, (A + C) > (B + D).’


I tried to work that out.  I got a doughnut.

Great that the tax payer has funded this pioneering research. All hail HMRC,