![]() |
|
Players and managers. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Players and managers. (/showthread.php?tid=41002) |
Players and managers. - Josh1873 - 03-12-2026 I don’t mean for this thread to come across as negative towards the squad. In fact, last night filled me with a lot of positivity, and I’m genuinely looking forward to Saturday’s match - especially if we see another performance full of desire and fight. What I do want is to spark a debate around the idea that it shouldn’t take a manager to drag that level of effort and desire out of the players. I understand that Ramsay wasn’t the right man for the job. He was out of his depth, and it’s clear the players didn’t respond well to him. But that still doesn’t excuse some of the inept, gutless, and heartless performances we saw during his time in charge. Why does one man make such a dramatic difference to your application? Tactics and coaching obviously affect the quality of play, but they shouldn’t determine how hard you work. People will point to real-world examples of how they don’t perform as well in their day jobs when they dislike their manager. But football isn’t exactly like everyday jobs, is it? Players should understand they’re not just playing for one man, they’re playing for thousands of paying fans, many of whom would give anything to have ten minutes on that pitch. It’s genuinely disrespectful and pretty disgusting that some players downed tools and put in abject performances, especially when we’ve now seen what they’re capable of over the last two games. This isn’t just about us either - it happens at clubs everywhere. It’s not unique to our situation, but it’s incredibly frustrating to watch. I'm not sticking up for, or defending Ramsay, here - he was awful, but surely if the players just turned up in, say, two performances with the attitude they displayed last night we'd have gotten wins v Charlton & Oxford. I've said for a while not one person or factor will be solely responsible for our pending relegation, it'll be a combination of many factors, one of which will be the pathetic performances, mentality, and attitude of the players over the last couple of months, where if they'd have shown an ounce of the correct application we'd have been in a healthier position, and it shouldn't need a manager, coach, or a specific person to cajole such fight and heart out of them. RE: Players and managers. - Tom Joad 25 - 03-12-2026 I haven't really seen any lack of effort this season. We actually saw them bust a gut and lose many times. In game management and defensive lapses (midfield as well) and a lack of belief/confidence has put us where we are. RE: Players and managers. - MrBater - 03-12-2026 I'll give you a little analogy on how 'one' man can make such a difference to the levels of effort people put in. This year where I work has decided to switch HR/payroll software (after we had spent most of last year getting another one set up)... It was announced by a new director who ignored all the lessons we had pointed out from the previous one... He ploughed ahead and gave us allegedly a 4 month deadline to get it up and running... We all felt demoralised. Especially when we found out he was going on his jollies to Portugal paid for by the new software vendor... Oh and then to compound things he bought in another new guy who tried telling us his was the only way to do anything... In january we planned out how we could make things happen in the tight schedule... This second new guy went oh no, no no you need to do it using this technology that nobody knew or had used... We wasted 2 weeks arguing with him and telling him it was the wrong approach... Luckily we found some evidence to prove his ideas wrong and were then allowed to crack on with a tried and tested way of doing things. We delivered on time, because eventually we were allowed to do what we knew worked... New guy 1 thankfully gave in and told new guy 2 to let us do it our way. Both new guys cost between them cost us 6 weeks out of 4 months. We were utterly demoralised and most of us updated our CVs and contacted agencies... That's exactly how a new manager who doesn't listen can affect a team that previously had done decent enough work. part of me wanted to not deliver on time so new guy 2 would be called out, my personal pride wouldn't let me do that... Had new guy 2 been in control we'd have all pretty much sat around and waited from him to tell us what to do...Which is similar I think to mason and then Ramsay. hey have the power and get the credit... You get to a point where you go i can't be arsed with this srtupidity anymore. RE: Players and managers. - HawkingsHalfpint - 03-12-2026 I’ll give you a more practical analogy. My son plays at a reasonable standard; in fact the seniors are punching well above their weight in the overall FA league system (the team is represented right from kiddies up to the seniors). He’s had to really fight for his place in that side (despite it being only U12s that makes it 9-a-side; they don’t go up to 11-a-side until U14 level) and he trained with them for nearly two years before even making the bench. It’s hard work - they train pretty hard and have three coaches, and quite often (due to fitness/availability of others etc.) he quite often has to either deputise in a position he’d preferably not play in, or cover for when the star-player they don’t want to lose goes all Lampard/Scholes (i.e. just floats about and does what he wants). In fact it’s that competitive they’ve only signed one more permanent player (they have to officially) since he signed two years ago; and that’s after the two years he spent training his arse off while unsigned, and sometimes he comes off the pitch quite grumpy; not only with himself but with the job he has do to. In fact one or two of his mates who trained with him had to drop to the seconds/thirds to get a game each weekend, and so I’m impressed with Hawks Junior for his perseverance over the years. As a parent I try and keep my opinions/vocality to a minimum but you just can’t help it sometimes when it’s your own kid. Yet often he says to me after ‘Dad, I would have hit the space/made the run/track the man etc. you said, but I’ve got three guys telling me to do the role they told me. I can’t listen to you and them’. It’s probably the same for our players. Even though we want to see player x, y or z doing more, running more, tracking back more etc. sometimes that’s just not how they’ve been instructed. And when they do the opposite of what they’re told, and either just ‘shoooot’ or make a certain pass or chose to go backwards when we all cheer the opposite, or don’t bust a gut when we expect it, it probably isn’t because they can’t/couldn’t be arsed. It was far more likely that that was what they were told to do - maybe even against their own better judgement as individual players. And you could see it - haven’t we looked much more organised in the two most recent draws, then perhaps, say, since October. Some of the players I admire much more than others. In fact at one point, I was giving Maja dogs abuse for not sprinting for a ball I’m sure Dike would have. But what the coach and the staff say matters around 95% compared to what we may yell, chant, support or abuse from the terraces. And if that guy in charge (and his underlings) happens to be confusing an international side of different ages, experiences, attributes etc. with whom he hasn’t even had time to familiarise himself, well… I can see exactly how they often seem to look disinterested, when I bet the exact opposite applies - they just didn’t/couldn’t work Ramsay’s ‘buzzword’ way. Oh that, and with no disrespect to the MLS, the EFL it most certainly is not. Despite my ire towards them on certain days I certainly don’t blame the majority of them for this mess. Much more the man who empowered the men who put us here. I’ve said it before but this side does have enough - we’re just seeing too little of it too late. RE: Players and managers. - Merkinagogo - 03-12-2026 I'm not sure that we have seen a lack of effort this season, though there were times when the players looked totally confused at what they were meant to be doing under both Mason and Ramsay. Under Mowbray last year, they totally downed tools, which I think Bartley confirmed in a podcast/interview and was obvious when Morrison came in to replace him for the last couple of games. |