![]() |
|
Genuine quality of the team - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Genuine quality of the team (/showthread.php?tid=39597) Pages:
1
2
|
Genuine quality of the team - Russbaggie03 - 12-06-2025 Had an evening with my old man, who was born and bred in West Brom and was signed on for Albion in his youth. We have watched all our teams over the last 40 years and we have agreed that the reality is that our team right now is just fairly average. What manager would bring a miracle cure outside of a short term bounce I doubt many. Our main conclusion was that our “engine room” in Central midfield and overall pace is seriously lacking. We just don’t have consistent energy or intensity. Despite Mowatt being a generally ok player as a captain and driving force he cannot do that job and him and molumby are just limited. I like them both and they are both ok but let’s face facts we are a mid table side at best with the current squad. We all now expect to lose on Tuesday at saints and prob lucky to get 15,000 on Friday against the leagues new in form team who have now got back to winning under wilder and likely get back into top 4-5 come the next of season. Oh and let’s not start re wildsmith. My 12 year old must have a chance. RE: Genuine quality of the team - CIM - 12-06-2025 Despite weaknesses I fail to be convinced that this Albion squad is weaker than 3rd placed Millwall or 5th placed PNE. A better manager than Mason could get more out of this squad. Corberán had Mowatt and Molumby in central midfield and we were 5th (in a much stronger league) RE: Genuine quality of the team - Sliced - 12-06-2025 Correct. In the Champ the manager has more of an impact on finishing position than the playing squads quality on paper, particularly this year RE: Genuine quality of the team - Peachofacross - 12-06-2025 (12-06-2025, 08:39 PM)CIM Wrote: Despite weaknesses I fail to be convinced that this Albion squad is weaker than 3rd placed Millwall or 5th placed PNE. A better manager than Mason could get more out of this squad. This. Said the same last week. For everyone banging on about our poor squad it's a squad which is as good as, if not better than, 10 sides above us. People need to stop making excuses for our shite manager. We have a decent squad in what is a bang average Championship season. Plain and simply Mason just isn't getting enough out of them. He's not making players better and he's not motivating them. Couple that with bizarre subs and team selections. Our squad is perfectly fine for a top 6 push. End of. RE: Genuine quality of the team - Bob Fossil - 12-06-2025 They are slightly above average and underperforming IMO. They lack cohesion, intent and structure. Add to that the rabbit in the headlights approach to subs and it won’t take much to see an improvement. Granted, not top 6 improvement but few expected that anyway. What we should be is more solid and more competitive. This squad should: a) Not be conceding the goals we are b) Creating better chances A semi-competent coach could improve both. We would likely still finish mid table, but, at present we look bottom 6. RE: Genuine quality of the team - Duffers - 12-06-2025 Breaking the squad down: Keepers - Griffiths is still young and learning at this level, jury is still out on whether he’ll push on. Wildsmith we all know is shit. Centre halves - Phillips and Mepham have both been part of promotion winning sides and should be performing better than they are. Bielek is a proven Champ level CB. Full backs - Gilchrist is still young and might come good in the future, Campbell not so sure, Styles is a midfielder filling in and Taylor is old and useless. Central midfield - Mowatt and Molumby are the definition of “mid-table Championship”, Diakite is probably never going to improve beyond his current level, Collyer is highly rated but not ours and injury prone. Wingers/Attacking midfield - Price started well but is going backwards at a rate of knots, Grant’s another “mid-table” player, Johnstone could be playing higher up the league and SIJ is just Somen Tchoyi with even fewer good parts. Strikers - Heggebo is starting to look like he can really cut it at this level, Maja is good when on form but is either unfit or not arsed and Dike would be an asset if he wasn’t made of breadsticks. We have a mixture of players who should be doing better who are underperforming and players who are just playing to their level right now. RE: Genuine quality of the team - SW4Baggie - 12-06-2025 (12-06-2025, 09:43 PM)Duffers Wrote: Breaking the squad down: I think a lot of this is fair, but you’re undervaluing a few players… Gilchrist was part of a team that accrued 90 points last year, and Taylor was playing in the PL… Styles is a proven Championship fullback and Campbell is a USA international. Price, Grant, Mikey are good enough for most sides in this division, and Mowatt is absolutely not a midtable Chanpionship player, he’s an excellent central midfielder for this level. This squad is comfortably good enough to be making a fist of a playoff place, yes it has weaknesses but it has a very good defence and enough talent going forward to cause problems. The issue is its being managed by a moron. RE: Genuine quality of the team - Lurker#3 - 12-06-2025 Griffiths is more than capable and will exceed palmers levels when he reaches that age. Infact griffiths is better now that when Palmer was first seen I am Albion too. Fullbacks - Been an issue since Townsend left and since Furlong. Gilchrist will be okay, but he's not a wingback type, and styles is defensively good and in transition, but not good enough going forward as of yet. But he could well develop into a good all round full back. CBs - As good as owt in the league, being let down by a lack of structure in recent times. CM - Mowatt is fine, as good as any holding player in the league. But the rest of the choices leave a lot to be desired. Price would be an ideal partner for him, but hes not been played there. Wingers - We struggle, MJ aside. We lack pace and real threat. AM - Bany in the dungeon so we don't know. Price is fine, should play with another AM. CF - On paper we are absolutely fine. But Maja isn't 'at it' and Dike is in the dungeon. Manager - I don't need to go over my thoughts. He's letting the team and squad down. RE: Genuine quality of the team - Dumbo - 12-06-2025 (12-06-2025, 09:57 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(12-06-2025, 09:43 PM)Duffers Wrote: Breaking the squad down: Grant good enough for most sides in the division? Mowatt an excellent midfielder? Hmm… RE: Genuine quality of the team - Lurker#3 - 12-06-2025 (12-06-2025, 09:59 PM)Dumbo Wrote:(12-06-2025, 09:57 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(12-06-2025, 09:43 PM)Duffers Wrote: Breaking the squad down: https://fbref.com/en/players/361b8b6c/scout/12751/Alex-Mowatt-Scouting-Report Not sure what else you expect from a deep lying playmaker in the championship, Dumbo, but I reckon it doesn't exist. |