Ratings v Oxford - Lurker#3 - 11-08-2025
Griffiths - 7 - A couple of really smart saves
Gilchrist - 6 - Solid and unspectacular
Phillips - 6 - Okay defensively, poor in possession
Taylor - 7 - Good
Styles - 7 - Good
Mowatt - 7 - kept trying to get us playing.
Diakite - 6 - Does what he does.
Grant - 6 - grafted as usual. Flat footed for the cross first half.
Price - 7 - What a shift he put in off the ball. Played well in the last 15 on the ball too.
MJ - 8 - Single handedly attacked for us throughout.
Maja - 5 - for turning up.
Subs:
Molumby - 6 - Ran about and carried us up the pitch a couple of times.
Heggebo - 7 - Good goal grafted.
SIJ - 6 - Offered us a threat in the break and worked hard enough. Really unpredictable.
Bielik/Collyer - Not enough time to judge. One good pass from TC.
Mason - 7 - Starting line up wrong, still too risky adverse with his subs, but we won so that's that. Biggest concern is how he genuinely thinks our performances have been good and we have somehow not got what we deserve. We have actually got more points than the majority of our performances have deserved.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - MancBaggie - 11-08-2025
(11-08-2025, 07:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Griffiths - 7 - A couple of really smart saves
Gilchrist - 6 - Solid and unspectacular
Phillips - 6 - Okay defensively, poor in possession
Taylor - 7 - Good
Styles - 7 - Good
Mowatt - 7 - kept trying to get us playing.
Diakite - 6 - Does what he does.
Grant - 6 - grafted as usual. Flat footed for the cross first half.
Price - 7 - What a shift he put in off the ball. Played well in the last 15 on the ball too.
MJ - 8 - Single handedly attacked for us throughout.
Maja - 5 - for turning up.
Subs:
Molumby - 6 - Ran about and carried us up the pitch a couple of times.
Heggebo - 7 - Good goal grafted.
SIJ - 6 - Offered us a threat in the break and worked hard enough. Really unpredictable.
Bielik/Collyer - Not enough time to judge. One good pass from TC.
Mason - 7 - Starting line up wrong, still too risky adverse with his subs, but we won so that's that. Biggest concern is how he genuinely thinks our performances have been good and we have somehow not got what we deserve. We have actually got more points than the majority of our performances have deserved.
Spot on. We have got marginally more points than the performances have merited
RE: Ratings v Oxford - Josh1873 - 11-08-2025
I actually think that's pretty much spot on.
I'd like to simultaneously give ILJ a 2 and 6. Is that possible?
RE: Ratings v Oxford - Ted Maul - 11-08-2025
I'm finding it really difficult to properly lay into the players. I think they're really grafting and they showed good character when they could have folded. They're just so limited.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-08-2025
Decent marks. Would probably give Gilly a 7 also because not a lot at all came down their left.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - Tiptonmon - 11-08-2025
(11-08-2025, 07:08 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (11-08-2025, 07:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Griffiths - 7 - A couple of really smart saves
Gilchrist - 6 - Solid and unspectacular
Phillips - 6 - Okay defensively, poor in possession
Taylor - 7 - Good
Styles - 7 - Good
Mowatt - 7 - kept trying to get us playing.
Diakite - 6 - Does what he does.
Grant - 6 - grafted as usual. Flat footed for the cross first half.
Price - 7 - What a shift he put in off the ball. Played well in the last 15 on the ball too.
MJ - 8 - Single handedly attacked for us throughout.
Maja - 5 - for turning up.
Subs:
Molumby - 6 - Ran about and carried us up the pitch a couple of times.
Heggebo - 7 - Good goal grafted.
SIJ - 6 - Offered us a threat in the break and worked hard enough. Really unpredictable.
Bielik/Collyer - Not enough time to judge. One good pass from TC.
Mason - 7 - Starting line up wrong, still too risky adverse with his subs, but we won so that's that. Biggest concern is how he genuinely thinks our performances have been good and we have somehow not got what we deserve. We have actually got more points than the majority of our performances have deserved.
Spot on. We have got marginally more points than the performances have merited Obviously difficult to evaluate, but I give you:
Portsmouth - robbed by a ref so totally incompetent that they were laughing at his performance on 'Ref Watch'.
Derby - beaten by their only (scuffed) shot on target in the whole game.
Leicester - denied a win as the result of a hopeful cross in the last few minutes of injury time, which deflected off Philips' leg into the corner of the net.
Charlton - OK, you have to take your chances, but beaten by a deflected shot in the last minute of injury time in a game where we deserved at least a draw.
I'm sure you can come up with counter arguments, but I don't think we're being flattered by our points total.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - UCEbaggie - 11-08-2025
(11-08-2025, 08:33 PM)Tiptonmon Wrote: (11-08-2025, 07:08 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (11-08-2025, 07:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Griffiths - 7 - A couple of really smart saves
Gilchrist - 6 - Solid and unspectacular
Phillips - 6 - Okay defensively, poor in possession
Taylor - 7 - Good
Styles - 7 - Good
Mowatt - 7 - kept trying to get us playing.
Diakite - 6 - Does what he does.
Grant - 6 - grafted as usual. Flat footed for the cross first half.
Price - 7 - What a shift he put in off the ball. Played well in the last 15 on the ball too.
MJ - 8 - Single handedly attacked for us throughout.
Maja - 5 - for turning up.
Subs:
Molumby - 6 - Ran about and carried us up the pitch a couple of times.
Heggebo - 7 - Good goal grafted.
SIJ - 6 - Offered us a threat in the break and worked hard enough. Really unpredictable.
Bielik/Collyer - Not enough time to judge. One good pass from TC.
Mason - 7 - Starting line up wrong, still too risky adverse with his subs, but we won so that's that. Biggest concern is how he genuinely thinks our performances have been good and we have somehow not got what we deserve. We have actually got more points than the majority of our performances have deserved.
Spot on. We have got marginally more points than the performances have merited Obviously difficult to evaluate, but I give you:
Portsmouth - robbed by a ref so totally incompetent that they were laughing at his performance on 'Ref Watch'.
Derby - beaten by their only (scuffed) shot on target in the whole game.
Leicester - denied a win as the result of a hopeful cross in the last few minutes of injury time, which deflected off Philips' leg into the corner of the net.
Charlton - OK, you have to take your chances, but beaten by a deflected shot in the last minute of injury time in a game where we deserved at least a draw.
I'm sure you can come up with counter arguments, but I don't think we're being flattered by our points total.
I kind of get your argument but I think what you describe is what happens to poor sides or poorly coached sides. They have opportunities to get draws and wins that somehow become losses and draws. That’s football. Good sides, or well coached sides don’t often suffer the same thing.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - Jacko - 11-08-2025
Gifts from the Stoke and Wrexham goalkeepers also come to mind.
RE: Ratings v Oxford - MancBaggie - 11-08-2025
(11-08-2025, 08:37 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: (11-08-2025, 08:33 PM)Tiptonmon Wrote: (11-08-2025, 07:08 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (11-08-2025, 07:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Griffiths - 7 - A couple of really smart saves
Gilchrist - 6 - Solid and unspectacular
Phillips - 6 - Okay defensively, poor in possession
Taylor - 7 - Good
Styles - 7 - Good
Mowatt - 7 - kept trying to get us playing.
Diakite - 6 - Does what he does.
Grant - 6 - grafted as usual. Flat footed for the cross first half.
Price - 7 - What a shift he put in off the ball. Played well in the last 15 on the ball too.
MJ - 8 - Single handedly attacked for us throughout.
Maja - 5 - for turning up.
Subs:
Molumby - 6 - Ran about and carried us up the pitch a couple of times.
Heggebo - 7 - Good goal grafted.
SIJ - 6 - Offered us a threat in the break and worked hard enough. Really unpredictable.
Bielik/Collyer - Not enough time to judge. One good pass from TC.
Mason - 7 - Starting line up wrong, still too risky adverse with his subs, but we won so that's that. Biggest concern is how he genuinely thinks our performances have been good and we have somehow not got what we deserve. We have actually got more points than the majority of our performances have deserved.
Spot on. We have got marginally more points than the performances have merited Obviously difficult to evaluate, but I give you:
Portsmouth - robbed by a ref so totally incompetent that they were laughing at his performance on 'Ref Watch'.
Derby - beaten by their only (scuffed) shot on target in the whole game.
Leicester - denied a win as the result of a hopeful cross in the last few minutes of injury time, which deflected off Philips' leg into the corner of the net.
Charlton - OK, you have to take your chances, but beaten by a deflected shot in the last minute of injury time in a game where we deserved at least a draw.
I'm sure you can come up with counter arguments, but I don't think we're being flattered by our points total.
I kind of get your argument but I think what you describe is what happens to poor sides or poorly coached sides. They have opportunities to get draws and wins that somehow become losses and draws. That’s football. Good sides, or well coached sides don’t often suffer the same thing.
Fido made a similar point after Charlton. Again - we go back to Corberan….
RE: Ratings v Oxford - Tiptonmon - 11-08-2025
(11-08-2025, 08:39 PM)Jacko Wrote: Gifts from the Stoke and Wrexham goalkeepers also come to mind.
Obviously there will be matches where we get the breaks, but I don't think that we've had more than our fair share. We're a half decent Championship team who are about where we should be in the table at the moment. We won't go down and it's highly unlikely that we'll go up.
|