WBAUnofficial
The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away (/showthread.php?tid=39255)



The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Squid - 11-05-2025

My poor, poor eyes. I have had to see AI versions of Nathan Jones as Jesus and Winston Churchill in the compiling of this thread, along with the frequent reminder that Charlton are 5th in the table. There really are no excuses for how poorly we have been performing.

Edited to add: I'm away this weekend, so there will be a delay to the Oxford thread. Also, if anyone has any requests for the international break, let me know.



Pre Match

Watched Ipswich v West Brom and West Brom were very poor .. but they have names that don’t seem to be performing at the moment .. don’t think they will be as good as Swansea tactic wise so I think we will get a little more room in midfield on Tuesday

Surprised to see Krystian Bielik hasn’t featured for West Brom more this season, would love him back in our squad one day.
- Until your post, I'd completely missed Bielik was now at West Brom! 

My Dad's team RIP. He never really left SE London, born in 37,  so I can only assume WBA were a bit of a Liverpool or Man Utd.
I would take a draw.
1-1

Would be typical for WBA to turn up against us at The Valley, but we should be able to bag a win here. 

Anyway, back to business, Charlton 3-0 WBA

Only 2 words to say about this match.
Karlan Grant.
- If he gets on the pitch.  Usually an impact sub now, which shows how far he has fallen from the premier league stars of the future. 

Ah West Brom. We do love a draw against them, I mostly expect another one tomorrow. 

Wasn’t it West Brom in the 2020 game whose away fans thought it’d be hilarious “football banter” to hang onto the ball after it went into their end after it was cleared for a corner? We scored from the subsequent corner. 


I am feeling fairly negative about this one. West Brom are obviously a decent side, and we've had our back line disturbed which is our biggest strength.
Charlton 0-2 West Brom. 

I hope Grant and Bielik stay on the bench but you just know they will raise their game. 

Charlton 3-1 West Brom 

West Brom have a fine history, having spent most of their time in the top flight, and, given that this is their fifth season in the Championship, their supporters are bound to be disgruntled if they're not challenging at the top. In recent years, they had terrible problems with their former Chinese owner, who took a £5 million loan from the club for one of his companies, which he then failed to repay by multiple deadlines. The new American owner sorted the financial mess out early last year but he is bound to want to see signs of progress and Ryan Mason appears to be under some pressure. Hopefully we'll be able to give him an uncomfortable evening, although no one will be underestimating the quality in their squad. Their attacking midfielder, Price, has already scored five times for them this season (as well as against Germany for Northern Ireland) and Maja also has a decent scoring record. Following his return from injury, Karlan Grant got 30 minutes off the bench on Saturday, so I expect we'll see him at some stage, if not from the start.

West Brom are coming into the game on the back of a disapointing nil nil at home to Sheffield Wednesday so may not be firing on all cylinders themselves. Hopefully they will suit us more.

2-1 to the Baggies - thing we'll struggle in defence. Can see Jones or Maca getting a red card tonight...

Due to injuries I think we'll lose this one. 1-2 WBA.

I think the best we can hope for tonight is a hard fought draw. we knew we would face a few crisis periods over the season injury wise and I think we are facing one now.

For me WBA are a bit of a bogey team! Going 1-0 to us - fans will be important tonight. Despite the injuries for us they are not in the best of form. Hoping their players dont fancy a long trip to the smoke

West Brom look like they are struggling at the moment and it's a good time to play them. However, I think we're in the same boat. I've not been impressed with us over the last 3-4 games (Ipswich aside).

Hadn't considered that West Brom will be looking to avenge the humiliation of letting Josh Davison score against them. We'll have to be at our best.

The two evening games at home against them that immediately spring to mind are a 2-1 win on a Friday night (pretty sure that was them) when they were at the top of the league and Killer appeared on the ITV lunchtime football preview the next day; and the other was when we bounced back to the PL at the first time of asking and beat them 5-0

WBA home was my first ever game. We lost 4-1 thanks to a Robbie Earnshaw hat trick. He did a front flip right in front of me. For some reason I kept coming back

Watched the Baggies v Ipswich and they did ok for so long without really threatening. Could be a good time to play them as Mason is under tge cosh right now. Tough game but due to those missing I am going 1-0 to West Brom.
WBA are a bit like Swansea for me. A decent side with a couple of players who can win a game if they fancy it. Their form coming into this is inconsistent so hopefully we can overwhelm them at the valley.
I think it’ll be a draw. 1-1.

West Brom looked good early part of season but have dropped off a bit but to me a top 6 six side all the same.

West Brom to win by at least 1 goal @6/1. All over that.

West Brom currently sit in 12th spot, four places and two points adrift of us after a 0-0 home draw with Shef Weds Saturday, but we ain't looking in that direction tonight are we, no, we could potentially finish back in the top 6 with a win tonight, and why not, team selection could prove interesting, but sure Nathan will have them fired up tonight… We've gone toe-to-toe on 62 previous occasions, winning 21, the Baggies 21 and the remaining 20 encounters ending all square, our last meeting ended in a 2-2 draw at The Valley back in 2020, with Josh Davison and Tom Lockyer both on the scoresheet.

West Brom have lost their last three away matches in the Championship.

See they have Grant starting up top...?‍♂️
- When I said on the Preview thread "just 2 words.....Karlan Grant" I was told that he doesn't usually start & nowdays is just an impact sub. Bileik was also a sub in their last gamen & came on for a few minutes.

The lack of commentary is getting ridiculous now !!! Every game surely it can’t be that hard to sort out catv now broadcasting wba commentary

Forgot that Josh Griffiths was back at West Brom now
Very good Goalkeeper who kept Bristol Rovers (when he was on loan there) in the match at the Valley last season

West Brom Comms: "We're struggling to score, and asking our Defence to keep clean sheets, which isnt happening"

First Half

Extended bout of head tennis and eventually WBA go back to their keeper.

WBA send a looping cross into our box but Kaminski collects easily.

West Brom Comms mention a few boos towards Karlan Grant

Booing Grant, what is wrong with some of our fans? Absolute morons.

Grant has a shot into row Z of The Covered End

Am sure it isnt but sounds like Tony Pulis is on comms for West Brom

WBA down our left, but Hernandez uses his arse to lever his man off the ball to regain possession.

Campbell now loses the ball on half way, West Brom attack and narrowly shoot wide

Jeez, what on earth are we playing at at the back?!
Yet another Baggies shot, this time just wide.

Giggling at Campbell trying to drag Bielik off the ball.

West Brom comms are talking about their bright start, but there not even forcing us into these mistakes.

West Brom looking better than us so far.

Grant playing like a man possessed, shame he didn't do that for us a bit more often...

Should be 0-1, should at least have tested TK... Ball breaks to their man on the corner of the six yard box
Who hits it just wide... Very wasteful opportunity

They look bad. We look worse 

This ref is w*nk so far

Ref just gave WBA advantage after their players combined to take Leaburn out

Oof, WBA down our left, Hernandez misses his tackle, but the cross goes across the box and evades everyone.

West Brom Comms laughing at Nathan Jones, who they compared to a child wanting sweets in a Supermarket the way he was jumping up and down on the touchline a moment ago... Was just after the Carey run into the box

27 gone. They have us sussed. They’ve matched the formation and aren’t giving us any space out wide. We look tired and devoid of ideas

West brom commentators very confident of taking 3 points home.
They're talking about us like we're Wealdstone or something

What the fuck are we doing???
- Lulling West Brom into a false sense of security.....

WBA come forward, Ramsay and Grant on the chase, Kayne has to concede a corner.

West brom commentators very confident of taking 3 points home.
They're talking about us like we're Wealdstone or something
- The only way they're getting three points is if they're caught speeding on the way home. We may be shite tonight but the defence will stand firm (oo-er missus).

PENALTY!

Saved.
And the rebound.
- F**king hate Josh Griffiths... Bloody decent Goalkeeper
- To be fair, with how shit the penalty was, I think Richard Griffiths could have saved it

Good save but poor penalty.

I know we’re not playing very well, but people making out like West Brom are prime Real Madrid and we are about to concede any second.
Which is not the case. Calm down.

And West Brom just put another 1 on 1 wide ...

Wasted chance from West Brom, who was surely offside... Drags his shot wide, when clear on goal

For all West Brom's dominance and chances tonight, according to the stats there's been only one shot on target.
Docherty's.

Surprised how negative people are being. We're pretty low on energy granted but we're also pretty untroubled so far. We should be one up but we've had plenty of games where we've been far better and still gone in 0-0 at halftime. The key thing is to get to the last 10 without going behind and then we can do our traditional late show

Awful game being played out by two poor side's who have zero quality.

Both teams have been utterly shite

Well despite the "strong" West Brom start, and a lacklustre one from us
Its turned very even, not the most enjoyable viewing, but we've "improved" as the game has ticked by

Half Time

At the game, its very poor from both sides,for how shit we've been,west brom havent done anything to really trouble us.

Two shots in the whole half and one of those was a penalty. Somewhat embarrassingly, given we are at home, WBA have had eight shots by comparison.

HT 0-0...for all their possession comes to sum total of naff all...

Looked lost this half. Thankfully West Brom don't look much better

Well that was 45 minutes of total dross. How we are level is down to them being nearly as bad as us.

Awful first half, only goalless due to West Brom's ineptitude in the final third and none of our players seemingly having big enough plums to take the penalty.

This is the issue. West Brom are happy to let us have the ball and they're dropping into a low block and looking to hit us on the counter. We're not used to that, and possession and patient build up are not our strengths. It's been a good tactic by WBA so far, and they've had a couple of good counters. 

Must be me then because they have been a lot more dangerous in the final third. Might bit have made Krasinski make a have but neither have we. WBA are more threatening when they attack. 

Should the pen have been retaken? Looked like their player that got to the rebound encroached a bit

I think this league is actually substantially weaker than previous championships. I know it's famous for the fact that anyone can beat anyone, but none of the teams at the top are anything special.

Second Half

It's like pulling teeth with nutcrackers, watching this.

West Brom player touches grass... FK

Erk, Macca gets dragged out of position, WBA take advantage, and they shoot just wide.

We're lucky their shooting is awful. 

WBA down our left, Hernandez beaten for pace but the cross is overhit.

Griffiths has to be one of my favourite opposition Goalkeepers!!
Bastard

For those who care about that sort of thing, that makes it 2-1 to Charlton regarding Shots on Target 

Sky commentator really annoyed me on that Leaburn "foul". We'll give the ref the benefit of doubt...
Can clearly see the WBA players fall over each other

These Albion commentators are rather tedious

West Brom comms are begging for a foul every time their players get challenged now
Can see their players getting stroppy if the referee starts ignoring them when they begin touching the grass now.

WBA with more of the ball now but not doing anything with it 

Unfortunately it’s looked like a goodish League One side at home to an uninspiring Championship side tonight.
- Yep would take 0-0 if you offered it to me know.

Fair play to West Brom, they've just not given us the time and space on the ball that we've needed on occasion

lol!... West Brom Comms are saying they cant see where their player caught Bree
He f**king didnt... It was Bree being pulled that helped him loose balance and got his foot stuck in the turf
- Andy Johnson a massive w⚓️

West Brom sub - Price off Johnston on

WBA do some nice passing but we manage to get it clear.

West Brom Comms see this as an excellent point so far... For all the negativity, having missed the penalty, we're still clearly holding our own against an established Championship side, who'll be happy to leave here with a draw.

That said, WBA getting a few chances now it’s more stretched and our midfield is more attacking

Lovely little run from the West Brom to jinx his way into the box, nice shot as well goes wide

"West Brom want to leave here with a point, Charlton want all three" from their comms

West Brom time wasting against us. Brilliant 

Another WBA sub

1 - 0

Sad for the keeper but lols

Keeper has absolutely fucked that

Ha ha ha
shitest corner ever and then their goalie ….

Shocking from their keeper. He’d played well up to then.

That's one way to lose man of the match by their keeper

I know that’s taken a deflection but that’s woeful keeping after having such a good game

Full Time

That West Brom keeper needs to walk home after that.

That poor bastard GK is in for one awkward coach trip home haha

@ForeverAddickted saying how much he rates Josh Griffiths as a keeper caused that

Ive got the West Brom commentary on my TV and losing in the last minute is the funniest thing to have happened to the pair of bellends commentating

Ryan Mason with a genius move to start Grant.

Rode our luck tonight. There were times it looked like they would score, but the red wall is immense. 

I know we won...but we were poor and if they had decent finishers would have been out of sight. 

Unexpected 3 points given the way the game had gone .. the keeper making a massive mistake after producing one of the best saves ever seen at the valley

We played badly, so did they. 0-0 would've been a fair result.

WBA,looked organised and well drilled and put us on the back foot for a large portion of the game. TC, was man marked and pretty much kept out of the game The less said about the penalty the better.

Poor quality game that neither side deserved to win. That we did shows some resilience and we certainly were on the front foot for the last five minutes...
Fortunate three points tonight but welcome nonetheless despite the performance - but WBA were not much better. 

And that is why you should never leave early.
Not a great performance, partly because WBA didn't allow us to be but in both halves they tired and we finished stronger.

Yeah I didn't think we controlled the game at all. Felt we were poor until the changes which seems the common consensus amongst fans but also the disconnect with what Jones saw....
Last night I felt both sides would be disappointed to drop points as both clubs probably thought the other was there for the taking. West Brom were bang average though and if we were playing to the levels we reached against Leicester, Millwall or Bristol, you'd really hope we'd have wiped the floor with them.

Cracking result - first 30 WBA showed they are a better footballing team than us, turning the ball over much quicker and comfortable in their movement.  I thought from the start of the second half we were the better team.

it’s the results that count.  This is where it all started to go wrong the last time we were in the Championship, coincidentally I think the 2-2 at WBA being our last decent result before we struggled well into Feb.

I thought that West Brom were better than us in the first half, dominating midfield and possession, but creating very little in the final third. The only time I felt remotely threatened was when Price got through on the right but screwed his shot wide.

West Brom have some really good players but what I live about football is the ways it can be equalised, narrow defending and desire to win the ball. Set pieces, physicality and they matched us for that most of the game 

A game that was difficult to watch for long periods, especially in the first half.  WBA looked a lot sharper than us early on, especially in the opening 20 minutes. 

90 mins of turgid footy - but it was worth it in the end.

WBA are another Championship team (like Swansea) that for much of the time look much better than us, but lack the cutting edge to threaten opponents enough.

Just watched this commentator's reaction to the goal on Youtube. [Albion Youtuber with their head in their hands]

He doesn't like their manager, didn't like the substitutions and kept muttering Charlton Athletic in a rather disparaging way ... oh and he absolutely hates Nathan Jones.

Not easy watching a fellow human breaking down, but I think I might watch it again. 

If a year ago you were to tell me that we would be picking up drawers against Swansea and then West Brom (who let’s not forget have been in the play offs/challenging for the play offs last two seasons) I wouldn’t have used the word underwhelming.

Thought we were outplayed in the first half, but the WBA strikers couldn’t hit the side of a barn and the defence and Jones were imperious.

Not going to read every post but only just realised it was Grant that headed the ball to Carey. Does he get the assist for that ?

Terrible viewing and if West Brom could finish they could have been walking away with the 3 points... BUT... we are so well organised and know how to play that despite the losses in defence we can still grind out a result, 0-0 would have been fair, despite having a couple of really good chances the baggies weren't exactly streets ahead of us in terms of quality. 

West Brom never looked like they were going to score, we should have gone one up with the penalty and then as it entered injury time there was always going to be a decent likelihood we would score.
- They missed two one on ones and a pretty presentable far-post chance.


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - baggiebloke - 11-05-2025

"WBA were a bit of a Liverpool or Man Utd"

:-)

Thank you again for this, Squid.

Enjoy your break..


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Duffers - 11-05-2025

West Brom to win by at least 1 goal @6/1. All over that.

Isn't that just West Brom to win?


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Bob Fossil - 11-05-2025

There’s a pattern emerging that we only show up for the first 20 mins, then die on our arse. Mason stands like a statue doing nothing so players get lost. He’s not a manager, not a motivator, not a tactician and I’m struggling to see a coach.
Get rid please, don’t eke it out because we scrape a draw with Oxford.

When Nathan Jones is better on every department, we have the wrong bloke.


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Tom Joad 25 - 11-05-2025

(11-05-2025, 02:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: There’s a pattern emerging that we only show up for the first 20 mins, then die on our arse. Mason stands like a statue doing nothing so players get lost. He’s not a manager, not a motivator, not a tactician and I’m struggling to see a coach.
Get rid please, don’t eke it out because we scrape a draw with Oxford.

When Nathan Jones is better on every department, we have the wrong bloke.

This is another concern. We actually do regularly start well. Then we miss a few chances and do a total no show 2nd 45.


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Vinebaggie - 11-05-2025

“Awful game being played out by two poor side's who have zero quality.

Both teams have been utterly shite”

Comment summed up the game


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Ted Maul - 11-05-2025

In recent weeks we've been spoken down to by fans of Watford and now Charlton Athletic. Squid, these threads might have to stop if this current trend continues.


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - MrBater - 11-05-2025

(11-05-2025, 03:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: In recent weeks we've been spoken down to by fans of Watford and now Charlton Athletic. Squid, these threads might have to stop if this current trend continues.

You mean by sides above us in the table who are on considerably better form?


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Squid - 11-05-2025

(11-05-2025, 03:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: In recent weeks we've been spoken down to by fans of Watford and now Charlton Athletic. Squid, these threads might have to stop if this current trend continues.

It's painful, I agree. All the more reason why things need to change.


RE: The View from the Opposition - Charlton Away - Tom Joad 25 - 11-05-2025

(11-05-2025, 03:23 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: “Awful game being played out by two poor side's who have zero quality.

Both teams have been utterly shite”

Comment summed up the game

TBF that's a given whoever we play, it's a football fan's default statement.