WBAUnofficial
Whitwell - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Whitwell (/showthread.php?tid=38342)

Pages: 1 2 3


Whitwell - Man from delmonte - 08-15-2025

https://www.wba.co.uk/news/harry-whitwell-joins-forest-green-rovers-loan

Season long loan to Forest Green. Hopefully he has a good spell there.


RE: Whitwell - Jacko - 08-15-2025

He's only 19, but dropping 3 divisions, I'd venture to say this loan spell needs to produce exceptional numbers.


RE: Whitwell - WorcsWBA - 08-15-2025

He's been well regarded by quite a few, so this loan is well down the ladder really. He ought to be playing in League One if we have high hopes for him.

Obviously I wish him well at FGR regardless.


RE: Whitwell - Birdman1811 - 08-15-2025

He could do with learning more of the physical side of the game, so a non league season may be great for him, by a few accounts he's already there technically but very weak and needs to be stronger


RE: Whitwell - Josh1873 - 08-15-2025

Is there a general timeline with academy players, as in a cut off 'you're 21, and haven't looked like doing it at the level below, let alone us, so bye', kinda mentality?


RE: Whitwell - baggie_ray - 08-15-2025

I would have hoped he'd have been at a higher level in the pyramid.

Has any player who has gone on loan to a non-League club gone on to have a career at Prem or Champ level?

The only plus point for me is that he is likely to be guaranteed game time in grown-up football.


RE: Whitwell - Josh1873 - 08-15-2025

(08-15-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I would have hoped he'd have been at a higher level in the pyramid.

Has any player who has gone on loan to a non-League club gone on to have a career at Prem or Champ level?

The only plus point for me is that he is likely to be guaranteed game time in grown-up football.

Not sure about loans, but plenty have played non-league and worked their way through the leagues to have excellent careers. Jamie Vardy the obvious example.

Troy Deeney was with Walsall when they were Championship (I think?) and he was loaned to Halesowen. He day have a bad career.


RE: Whitwell - baggie_ray - 08-15-2025

(08-15-2025, 05:58 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-15-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I would have hoped he'd have been at a higher level in the pyramid.

Has any player who has gone on loan to a non-League club gone on to have a career at Prem or Champ level?

The only plus point for me is that he is likely to be guaranteed game time in grown-up football.

Not sure about loans, but plenty have played non-league and worked their way through the leagues to have excellent careers. Jamie Vardy the obvious example.

Troy Deeney was with Walsall when they were Championship (I think?) and he was loaned to Halesowen. He day have a bad career.

I knew there'd be some and someone would know the answer  Smile

I see it pretty much a sign that the club doesn't think you're going to make it, based on those we have loaned out in recent seasons. With Whitwell being our great white hope, it seems a bit of a drop for me.


RE: Whitwell - wba13 - 08-15-2025

As good a player that Whitwell might become I think that both Deeming and Bostock are rated higher in midfield forward positions and after Williams display against Derby who could also go to the top.
There young things change but they all have a chance . Just like Fellows and Griffiths. Both of these will have decent careers.


RE: Whitwell - Shabby Russian - 08-15-2025

Everyone wrote off Cleary when he went to Hartlepool, but that move paid off for him.

And Fellows went to Crawley, who were in the bottom 4 of league 2, came back to us and made the first team.

Whitewell could be loaned to a league 1 side and then struggle to get game time.