WBAUnofficial
Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs (/showthread.php?tid=37455)

Pages: 1 2


Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Old Fart - 04-24-2025

From our favourite journo Martin Samuel in yesterday's Times.


Putting punitive relegation clauses into players’ contracts makes going straight back down a self-fulfilling prophecy — that’s why Burnley are more likely to struggle next season than Leeds.

When Burnley were last promoted to the Premier League in 2023, they splashed out on Zeki Amdouni, an attacking midfielder from Basel priced at €18.6million. Going down, their big investment was making a loan deal for Mike Trésor, an attacking midfielder from Genk, permanent. He was priced at €18million. So two competitions, a world apart, and a price difference of only €600,000.

And it is unlikely to be that different this time, either. Without wishing to rain on Burnley’s promotion party, the fight against relegation starts now, or the day the transfer window opens, and much of it is to do with salaries. Amdouni — on loan at Benfica this season — and Trésor fit a certain profile. They are players from unexceptional leagues in Europe who would take a gamble on coming to the Premier League in the hope it could provide a career stepping stone. Amdouni is now a Champions League footballer with a good shot at becoming a Portuguese title winner. In his case, it worked.

It doesn’t always work for Burnley, though, as this yo-yoing indicates. With another three promoted clubs going straight down again this season, one of the main contributing factors is a policy widely agreed to be best practice and good housekeeping by devotees of football’s new financial religion: relegation clauses in players’ contracts. Essential, we are told. Smart, realistic and — amen — sustainable. Luton Town’s players dropped down to £15,000 a week when they were relegated last season; Burnley’s went to roughly £20,000. And that, it is argued, keeps the ship stable. Yet it also makes relegation close to a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Leeds can expect to sign better players than their promoted rivals this summer as the contracts will not have costly strings attached
Say you are a Premier League player at a mid to low-ranking club. Brentford, Crystal Palace, West Ham United, Everton. Not the star, not an outcast. Someone who gets in most weeks, on the bench for some. A steady Eddie. The sort of player a newly promoted club needs to compete: been around the block, bit of experience — chances are you’ll be earning in the region of £50,000 a week. Then a club such as Burnley or Sheffield United come in for you. And the money, with Premier League status, would be roughly the same. Yet there’s a catch. In the event of relegation, that £50,000 becomes £20,000 in the Championship. That’s a bad deal. That’s a £30,000-a-week bet — so £1.56million over the year — that a promoted club will stay up. And ten of the past 15 haven’t. So you stay where you are, or you move sideways, because there is less risk.

But, occasionally, there’s a third option. The odd Championship club, such as Nottingham Forest under Evangelos Marinakis, gamble. Forest did not insert punitive relegation clauses into the contracts when they built their squad for the Premier League. Marinakis went against all the conservative instincts of modern football management. He was criticised, hit with points deductions; his methods were held up as everything that is wrong with the worst wanton owners.

And now? Forest may well be playing Champions League football next season. One of the reasons they could attract players with reasonable first-team experience from Manchester United, Newcastle United and Chelsea on arriving in the Premier League was that relegation would have minimal impact on salaries. There would be a cut, but in the region of 10 per cent.

Marinakis thought good players would keep Forest up and if they did not, he reasoned he would be able to sell. We’ll never know if he was right. The Premier League did their best to discourage ambition and investment, but Forest appear to be having the last laugh now. Good for them, and no thanks to Richard Masters.
What Burnley have done under Parker is fantastic, but if they approach next season with the same financial caution they did in 2023 they will be facing a predictable fate
Leicester City also did not have severe relegation clauses but Profitability and Sustainability Rules did for them and now, with relegation, salaries will drop by a minimum of 35 per cent, and more if the club do not return immediately. It will be much harder to come back this time.

As for Leeds United, one of the reasons they could attract Jayden Bogle and Joe Rodon last summer was because, even in the Championship, they presented a better option than a promoted club with costly strings attached. Rodon could have gone to Southampton but, in the end, chose wisely. Leeds are not in the habit of inserting big relegation clauses into contracts, so expect that to be reflected in the business they can do this summer too. Of the promoted clubs, Leeds are most likely to be able to buck a depressing recent trend.
And some will be angered by this. They have bought into football as a form of sweaty accountancy in which clean balance sheets are the goal and men such as Marinakis the enemy; as if Leicester needed to be protected from owners who had helped deliver the greatest season in English football history; as if it does not matter if the three that go up go straight back down again in perpetuity, so long as nobody loses money.

But that’s not what football is about. What Burnley have done to here under Scott Parker is fantastic, but if they approach next season with the same financial caution it is going to be incredibly tough to avoid a predictable fate. It was Norwich City’s plan to be in the top 26 clubs in the country. Either in the Premier League, or in the play-offs, and contracts were adjusted accordingly. Norwich are now 14th in tier two; Luton may pass straight through to League One. There is more to the survival game than only the numbers; Marinakis’s instincts were right.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - UCEbaggie - 04-24-2025

Can’t stand Samuels. The very worst of the corpulent, lazy, London-football media mafia. Fat bearded twat.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - ChamonixBaggie - 04-24-2025

"owners should gamble the survival of their club to attract greedy players" isn't exactly Solomon-esque wisdom

Lots of survivorship bias with regards to Forest. Plenty who've gambled and lost.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Bob Fossil - 04-24-2025

Sounds fair enough to me. Too much of football is about money, rather than the game itself, and that has filtered right down to the terraces. We've all become risk averse.
It's the reason this bored is full of finance spurts, but very few football spurts!

Fuck it Shilen, throw your bollocks at the clock! Champions League here we come!!!


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - rsbaggy2 - 04-24-2025

Lauding the actions of Marinakis (reputed to be a man with criminal enterprises) is a new low for the bearded twat Samuels.
Is he blind to the speculation of how the guy made his money?


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Old Fart - 04-24-2025

(04-24-2025, 11:21 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Lauding the actions of Marinakis (reputed to be a man with criminal enterprises) is a new low for the bearded twat Samuels.
Is he blind to the speculation of how the guy made his money?

I suppose you could say the same about Citeh and Newcastle whose owners originate from oil-rich states with dubious human rights records.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - fuzzbox - 04-24-2025

He's giving examples of teams that literally broke the rules!  If he truly believes this, then it's the rules that are at fault - not clubs that play by the rules.

Leeds is a weird example as well. There attendance is way above all the clubs mentioned so of course they afford to offer more - if the other team pays according to the rule. 

Ironically, it was Leeds offering ridiculously over the top player wages with no flex down that saw them plummet down the leagues with players they couldn't get rid of.

Us, Stoke, Villa and Wolves have also to a lesser extent been victims of this. Financially draining players you can't get rid of and unable to buy any new ones. Notts F got away with it - just. They are in the minority.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Brentbaggie - 04-24-2025

(04-24-2025, 11:24 AM)Old Fart Wrote:
(04-24-2025, 11:21 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Lauding the actions of Marinakis (reputed to be a man with criminal enterprises) is a new low for the bearded twat Samuels.
Is he blind to the speculation of how the guy made his money?

I suppose you could say the same about Citeh and Newcastle whose owners originate from oil-rich states with dubious human rights records.

Add in Man United whose Chairman/CEO'd company INEOS is a planet polluter of the worst kind. And don't even get me started on the Glazers.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Ted Maul - 04-24-2025

Made my head hurt reading that shite.


RE: Relegation clauses are killing the hopes of promoted clubs - Vinebaggie - 04-24-2025

I’m not a financial spurt but my understanding for next year is we have to balance the books, simply because of EFL rules and the fact we’ve lost close to £40m over last couple of years. So Bikul run another loss that will probably mean a points deduction or transfer embargo. Can you imagine the melt down “those fucking idiots in charge have got us a points deduction!” Samuel’s logic here is a complete irrelevance to us next season.