WBAUnofficial
Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party (/showthread.php?tid=37311)

Pages: 1 2 3


Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Derek Hardballs - 04-17-2025

Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - man in the corner shop - 04-17-2025

These are ideological choices made by a capitalist party that wishes only to tinker rather than effect irreversible change for working people.

Well done France

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/04/13/france-wants-to-make-one-off-wealth-tax-permanent_6740186_4.html#


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Pontificator - 04-18-2025

(04-17-2025, 09:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine

"could be rendered ineligible for the daily living personal independence payment" 
Do you agree that to receive this benefit there has to be a set of objective criteria?
Do you think that the centrist dad struggling with family responsibilities managing his difficult relationship and bringing up his kids, earning not a lot, gets up early every morning, knocks his pan out at work, comes home late at night, makes good decisons and gets by, deserves to know that his taxes are used properly?
Herbert Morrison (1946) “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
I really do think you should wind your neck in


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - baggy1 - 04-18-2025

(04-17-2025, 09:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine

The issue has come about due to widespread abuse of the system I’m afraid. There are people and families out there that have abused the system when it isn’t appropriate- I know of a family that pull in over £4k a month from benefits and because of the way their kids (in their 20s now) have been coached they will never work, not through disability but through their reliance on the state. They aren’t unable to work they simply saw an opportunity and take it.

And now we are here with no solutions being proposed by yourself again and in those vacuums someone will propose a solution that has no alternative proposal. If you seriously want to change this then come up with an alternative.

(04-17-2025, 11:38 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: These are ideological choices made by a capitalist party that wishes only to tinker rather than effect irreversible change for working people.

Well done France

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/04/13/france-wants-to-make-one-off-wealth-tax-permanent_6740186_4.html#

That’s not a wealth tax MICS, that’s an income tax.


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2025

(04-18-2025, 07:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(04-17-2025, 09:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine

"could be rendered ineligible for the daily living personal independence payment" 
Do you agree that to receive this benefit there has to be a set of objective criteria?
Do you think that the centrist dad struggling with family responsibilities managing his difficult relationship and bringing up his kids, earning not a lot, gets up early every morning, knocks his pan out at work, comes home late at night, makes good decisons and gets by, deserves to know that his taxes are used properly?
Herbert Morrison (1946) “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
I really do think you should wind your neck in

There already is a criteria set out and used. These are cuts to welfare, nothing more. You don’t like me posting this because it makes your beloved party look bad. 

Btw I work, pay taxes, have a family and get up early, I still don’t agree with the cuts, or punching down politics and don’t feel the need to know what someone else receives or doesn’t.


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - baggy1 - 04-18-2025

So your solution is to do more of the same and not make any changes?


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2025

(04-18-2025, 07:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(04-17-2025, 09:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine

The issue has come about due to widespread abuse of the system I’m afraid. There are people and families out there that have abused the system when it isn’t appropriate- I know of a family that pull in over £4k a month from benefits and because of the way their kids (in their 20s now) have been coached they will never work, not through disability but through their reliance on the state. They aren’t unable to work they simply saw an opportunity and take it.

And now we are here with no solutions being proposed by yourself again and in those vacuums someone will propose a solution that has no alternative proposal. If you seriously want to change this then come up with an alternative.

(04-17-2025, 11:38 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: These are ideological choices made by a capitalist party that wishes only to tinker rather than effect irreversible change for working people.

Well done France

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/04/13/france-wants-to-make-one-off-wealth-tax-permanent_6740186_4.html#

That’s not a wealth tax MICS, that’s an income tax.

The article is about PIP which is to help people live independently and live with the additional costs of being ill or disabled, people who work recieve it and the studies have shown there is very little fraud with regards to this support. This isn’t some anecdotal nonsense about some bloke you know not working and fiddling the system, this is about cuts to PIP for those with severe arthritis and cancer as examples. 

Your argument that one bloke on a message board should come up with a solution to a government policy who are failing to produce any meaningful growth so have decided to cut welfare as a solution without any real consultation with the sector is ridiculous.


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - baggy1 - 04-18-2025

Not at all and you miss the point brilliantly as ever. I’m not asking you for a solution, I’m saying no one is coming up with a viable solution therefore the choices are implement the solutions you don’t like or do nothing.

The article you have linked mentions those with mental health issues getting PIP to allow them to get taxis instead of using public transport - do you genuinely believe that is not getting abused and is good use of public money?


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Derek Hardballs - 04-18-2025

(04-18-2025, 08:58 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Not at all and you miss the point brilliantly as ever. I’m not asking you for a solution, I’m saying no one is coming up with a viable solution therefore the choices are implement the solutions you don’t like or do nothing.

The article you have linked mentions those with mental health issues getting PIP to allow them to get taxis instead of using public transport - do you genuinely believe that is not getting abused and is good use of public money?

You ignored the cancer and severe arthritis sufferers and went straight for the mental health problems, because they are easiest to label as not deserving of support/cynical about their condition. I don’t know if they need that support or not regarding their mental health. PIP rejects around 50% of claimants, its support for those who work and can’t, and the last study found nearly zero percent of fraud. Now even if that is inaccurate, I doubt it’s to the extent you are making out and I’ve seen no evidence regarding PIP to back your claims up.

Those on here that support these Labour plans seemingly want to quote another right of centre party former MP, the disabled community to ‘shut up and go away’. It’s not going to happen, nor should it, these are people’s lives the government are playing with.


RE: Labours green paper on disability - what nasty vile party - Pontificator - 04-18-2025

(04-18-2025, 08:07 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-18-2025, 07:19 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(04-17-2025, 09:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well done Labour… 

You’re proposing to condemn hundreds of thousands to a life of poverty

Centrist Dad’s combine… it’s your time to shine

"could be rendered ineligible for the daily living personal independence payment" 
Do you agree that to receive this benefit there has to be a set of objective criteria?
Do you think that the centrist dad struggling with family responsibilities managing his difficult relationship and bringing up his kids, earning not a lot, gets up early every morning, knocks his pan out at work, comes home late at night, makes good decisons and gets by, deserves to know that his taxes are used properly?
Herbert Morrison (1946) “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
I really do think you should wind your neck in

There already is a criteria set out and used. These are cuts to welfare, nothing more. You don’t like me posting this because it makes your beloved party look bad. 

Btw I work, pay taxes, have a family and get up early, I still don’t agree with the cuts, or punching down politics and don’t feel the need to know what someone else receives or doesn’t.

You completely misunderstand the Labour Party as did the enterists from the Hard Left (militant) It is a Party that embraces capitalism. Read Clause IV of the rule book. If the government come to the conclusion that PIP is too easily obtained, it is their duty to sort it out and make the difficult decisions. I actually think it makes the Party look good and electable. Just like keeping the two child allowance which had broad support amongst the electorate.
You've lost the plot