![]() |
|
The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? (/showthread.php?tid=36892) |
The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Spandaubaggie - 03-08-2025 I haven't seen too clear footage of it, but from what I have it seems a shade harsh. Mowbray said the same. I actually didn't notice the incident at the time, despite being in the Brummie. Most around me were equally perplexed. I think part of the issue in cases like this is the height of the lad elbowed. Being considerably shorter an accidental arm that might catch someone on shoulder height is going to clout someone 5ft 7 in the mush against Furlong, who is around the 6ft mark. I think the QPR bench put pressure on the ref to make the decision. It was justice that we held on for the win. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Swanage Baggie - 03-09-2025 Looking at it from the back of the SME it was difficult to see what was happening.....tellingly the away fans didn't react (as you would expect them to do if they've seen something that warrants a red) and the highlights of the game show the ref and lino in close proximity, neither of which do a great deal/no reaction at all until the cheating fucker rolls round the pitch like he's been hit by Frank Bruno. This suggests that it was something out of nothing. With the appeal (for those that know about these things) do we go with there's no conclusive proof and the non-reaction of the ref/lino at the time suggests simulation from the QPR player, or do we use the evidence from the rest of the game that similar challenges were given either nothing or a yellow card? RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Lightnin - 03-09-2025 I was sat in the Brummie. What I saw was that furlongs arm/elbow was out but the challenge was more of a coming together than an attempt to elbow. Their player was equally running into the elbow and it was more a brush. I did notice their player rolling on the floor with no physio required until the card was shown after which he got straight back to his feet unscathed. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Pedders - 03-09-2025 (03-09-2025, 03:53 AM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Looking at it from the back of the SME it was difficult to see what was happening.....tellingly the away fans didn't react (as you would expect them to do if they've seen something that warrants a red) and the highlights of the game show the ref and lino in close proximity, neither of which do a great deal/no reaction at all until the cheating fucker rolls round the pitch like he's been hit by Frank Bruno. This suggests that it was something out of nothing. Neither of those, you have to provide proof the officials made an error, so even if they had got it wrong, if there is no clear video evidence, we will have to lump it. Didnt see the incident, just the aftermath, but the ref after he blew did go straight towards his back pocket, before then talking into his headset, so either he noticed something himself or was told by the linesman/4th official. Given the reaction to the lino, it may have come from him. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - sickParrot - 03-09-2025 We seem to be having awful refs week in week out. Was the foul on Bartley worse, seemed to be in real time. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - SausEggBaton - 03-09-2025 If a poster on here was sitting in the Halfords in front of the incident and saw it, I'd like them to post their perspective please. Watching from stream, at HT you could clearly hear a lot of Halfords fans chanting "cheat" as Saito as he walked to the tunnel. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - sickParrot - 03-09-2025 He went down very easily in the 2nd half, 2 or 3 times. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - rsbaggy2 - 03-09-2025 (03-09-2025, 07:55 AM)sickParrot Wrote: We seem to be having awful refs week in week out. Didn't have enough of a perspective to judge on the Furlong incident, but the 2nd half challenge on Bartley was a clear red IMO. I had a clear view and their player launched himself full on with his arm outstretched and directed straight into the side of Bartley's face. A clear and obvious red. As for Saito, the amount of times he went down when looking for a free kick that was not given didn't even earn a yellow. Cumilatively could have totted up to 2 yellows. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - Bob Fossil - 03-09-2025 Doesn’t seem to be definitive view so appeal unlikely I reckon. RE: The sending off of Darnell harsh or not? - rsbaggy2 - 03-09-2025 (03-09-2025, 08:48 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Doesn’t seem to be definitive view so appeal unlikely I reckon. Contrary to what Mowbray is thinking. |