WBAUnofficial
Just back (ratings) - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just back (ratings) (/showthread.php?tid=36887)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Just back (ratings) - greetsgreenbaggie - 03-08-2025

Wildo-6 distribution awful, bad miss form QPR saved his blushes. 
Furgs-5 needless red, will miss him for 3 now.
Bart’s-7 captains performance 
Heggo-7 steady, did the good things well
Stylo-7 another steady if not spectacular performance
Mowatt-7 run of the mill performance 
Mulumby-7 energy energy energy! Marked down for the stupid yellow 
Fellows-8 best player on the pitch before being hooked
MJ-5 no more than 10 touches all game
Price-9 MOM by a mile
AA-6 goal aside, he offered nowt today
Subs
Holgate-7 good shithousery
Grant-7 added energy 
DD-6 still getting up to speed
Dia-6 no time to shine.

Overall a great result, if a underwhelming performance.


RE: Just back (ratings) - albion_pigeon - 03-08-2025

Fair ratings. I always think Mowatt is our most important midfielder, stitches everything together, but as a midfielder who makes the most difference it's definitely Price.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Runaroundandgroovelikeabaggie - 03-08-2025

Can't disagree with those bar Molumby who I'd give an 8.  Won the pen and was close to winning another in the second, after which he was geeing the Brummie up.  Just love him, has his limitations and prone to a bit of shit housery,  but his energy and the wearing of his heart on his sleeve is so important to the team.  As for Price he's the bollocks and we have a gem on our hands there.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Jerry - 03-08-2025

As DD was on for only a short time probably more than 6 is not justified, but he made a difference in the last 10 mins and maybe could have come on a little earlier.


RE: Just back (ratings) - BasingBaggie - 03-08-2025

Price MOM but Styles was very good in my opinion. Ref -10, both sides thought he was utter shit


RE: Just back (ratings) - SausEggBaton - 03-08-2025

Disagree with the Ferguson marks since that cheat Saito got him sent off.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-08-2025

I know GGB's ratings are meant to wind us up. Harsh on MJ, I'd give him 6. Dike was an instant and massive improvement on the ineffectual Armstrong. Cool penalty, but Grant or Wallace couldn't have been less effective than Armstrong otherwise.

Until I see some more conclusive video evidence, I'm not blaming Furlong for the red. Strange that you can roll around in agony after an elbow in the face, then run around without a mark on your countenance for the next 50 minutes of play. Little chance of getting it overturned, though..


RE: Just back (ratings) - Squid - 03-08-2025

6 for a keeper who kept a clean sheet with ten men seems very harsh and Johnston definitely had more than ten touches.


RE: Just back (ratings) - Sliced - 03-08-2025

Wildo-7.5 Solid, good shot stopping
Furlong - 5 Thought he was ok before the red, looked like a harsh sending off but no need to throw the arm
Barts - 7 A bit dodgy on the ground but solid in the air
Heggo - 7 Always looks a bit off balance but was solid enough. A couple of important challenges
Stylo - 7 Good defensive performance. A bit of a shithouse too.
Mowatt - 7.5 Good performance, was impressed by his defensive contributions
Mulumby - 8 Shaky first half but brilliant second half.
Fellows - 7 I don't agree that he was the best player on the pitch. He did alright but played a massive part in our goal
MJ - 6 Not his best but did a decent job of pushing us forwards on the counter. Could have scored first half
Price - 9 Brilliant
AA - 7 Extra mark for the goal. Anonymous at times but a decent contribution overall.
Subs
Holgate - 7.5 Outperformed Furlong. One of his best defensive performances
Grant - 6.5 Looked dangerous when we got forwards
DD - 6.5 A brief attacking cameo but looked lively
Diakite - 7 Only brief but a couple of really important clearances


RE: Just back (ratings) - wba13 - 03-08-2025

I still don’t think it’s a red card that QPR wanker made an absolute meal of it , glad the tossed missed a sitter second half.
Price has already more than doubled his fee what a find. Bartley led the troops brilliantly second half.
The crowd responded magnificently and the players responded to the crowd it was a great afternoon in the end.