![]() |
|
Birmingham City Councillors... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Birmingham City Councillors... (/showthread.php?tid=36555) |
Birmingham City Councillors... - Protheroe - 02-07-2025 Have just voted themselves a 5.7% pay rise. I assume that's performance related pay, oh.... RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - baggy1 - 02-07-2025 Probably need a bit of context there Proth, their allowance has gone up to £19,952. On one hand you suggest that MPs should be paid more to attract better candidates and then you don’t like it when representatives increase pay to reflect the workload. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - Protheroe - 02-07-2025 Here's a bit of context - Joseph Chamberlain didn't get paid a penny and transformed the city. More recent leaders have pocketed over £50,000 in annual allowances and bankrupted the city. Current Birmingham City Councillors would have been sacked from any enterprise if they'd have engaged in similar gross mismanagement and illegal activity. In my experience working at the city and knowing several current serving councillors the vast majority of their "workload" is delegated to officers. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - Borin' Baggie - 02-07-2025 (02-07-2025, 12:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Probably need a bit of context there Proth, their allowance has gone up to £19,952. Isn't that really high for a member allowance? It's nearly double the Warwickshire County Council member allowance RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - baggy1 - 02-07-2025 Slightly mad to suggest someone that died over a century ago as the model for modern day representations but that aside, any individual that has engaged in illegal activity should be charged through the court. The allowance is for the role not the individual, you have highlighted the need for better pay to attract the right people to the roles, this is an example where that is happening and you are against it - that is contradictory. (02-07-2025, 01:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(02-07-2025, 12:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Probably need a bit of context there Proth, their allowance has gone up to £19,952. That's probably reflective of the budgets and scaled responsibilities having worked for both authorities in the distant past. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - Protheroe - 02-07-2025 (02-07-2025, 01:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Slightly mad to suggest someone that died over a century ago as the model for modern day representations but that aside, any individual that has engaged in illegal activity should be charged through the court. The allowance is for the role not the individual, you have highlighted the need for better pay to attract the right people to the roles, this is an example where that is happening and you are against it - that is contradictory. Adding context, that's all. Having met and known personally hundreds of them I'm not convinced that local councillors ought to be paid anything other than expenses at all if they can't prove competence in the areas in which the have influence. I can't tell you how many planning committee meetings I sat through where members don't understand planning law or the implications of various planning conditions, let alone rejections on non-planning grounds which end up costing authorities huge sums in appeal costs. I've lost count of how many local authorities were incapable of even producing a Local Plan. Don't even start on the incompetents who signed off property "investments" the length and breadth of the country. Here's an example. I gained consent to develop an industrial park under the M6 at Bromford in Birmingham, but only after we legally challenged the City to remove an hours of use restriction applied because of the threat of "noise". On an industrial park, under the M6. Please. Councillors led by one particular twat made that decision, not the officers. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - baggy1 - 02-07-2025 (02-07-2025, 01:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(02-07-2025, 01:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Slightly mad to suggest someone that died over a century ago as the model for modern day representations but that aside, any individual that has engaged in illegal activity should be charged through the court. The allowance is for the role not the individual, you have highlighted the need for better pay to attract the right people to the roles, this is an example where that is happening and you are against it - that is contradictory. Don't get me wrong I would agree that a number, if not majority, of councillors aren't fit for purpose to the extent that some of them will be in the role for entirely the wrong reasons. But paying them less, or not giving them a pay rise, is not the problem. The problem comes from the rules in which they operate that allow them to be twats. That's what I'd be looking at changing. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - Protheroe - 02-07-2025 Good. Personally I'd have single-tier elected mayors in every local authority (and far fewer local authorities). RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - Kit Kat Chunky - 02-07-2025 The pay rise will be funded by the hard working residents of Birmingham who have been hit with an inflation busting Council Tax rise to fund these failed people. If they don't like the pay/allowance, they can always resign. RE: Birmingham City Councillors... - man in the corner shop - 02-07-2025 (02-07-2025, 12:59 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Here's a bit of context - Joseph Chamberlain didn't get paid a penny and transformed the city. More recent leaders have pocketed over £50,000 in annual allowances and bankrupted the city. Here is a bit of context. Joseph Chamberlain didn't need paying a penny. He had a load of cash from his rich daddy to give him a headstart (ain't it the Tory way) and become independently wealthy, having made a fortune by finishing off his competitors and retired at 38. You are the king of irrelevant comparisons. False equivalence I believe is your favourite term for these circumstances. |