WBAUnofficial
Bizarre substitutions - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bizarre substitutions (/showthread.php?tid=35373)

Pages: 1 2 3


Bizarre substitutions - Sheffieldbaggie - 10-19-2024

So we end up with Wallace in place of Maja and MJ instead of Fellows … both weaker offensively and defensively than the players in whose positions they ended up playing..

Is this pre-determined or an attempt to manage the game out? In either case it didn’t work. We invariably look so disjointed after the normal raft of substitutions. 

Again it looks like we’re playing with the handbrake on. So good for a period after the goal..as we were early doors this season. Then back into our shell as we were for so many away games last season.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Lurker#3 - 10-19-2024

Maja and Fellows both ran out of steam
Fellows especially. Wallace is the back up right winger in principle so it was a straight swap. The issue came when we needed to rotate Maja. Without a natural, trusted CF option from the bench we ended up shifting too many people into their less favoured position, and stopped being able to shift the ball through the lines effectively enough and we stopped retaining possession.

In hindsight, CC should have played Swift as a false 9 and played MJ as 10 when Grady and Maja had to be replaced.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Sliced - 10-19-2024

It seems like CC is trying his best to keep the players that aren't playing happy. It's impossible not to like Wallace but he's been rubbish. His final ball breaks down every time, and Johnston hasn't done anything to merit playing either.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Shabby Russian - 10-19-2024

If he didn't make subs he would be criticised.

And if he does he is still criticised.

No one should be surprised that substitutions are made . What is concerning is that our substitutions are struggling to make an impact.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Sheffieldbaggie - 10-19-2024

I saw no evidence that Maja and Fellows both ran of steam … Maja in particular had been immense. He found so much space and pulled their defence out of position all game.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Bob Fossil - 10-19-2024

(10-19-2024, 03:24 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I saw no evidence that Maja and Fellows both ran of steam … Maja in particular had been immense. He found so much space and pulled their defence out of position all game.

Me neither, Maja looked solid as he always does. Grant worked his socks off all day but managed 90 mins, why can’t Maja?
It’s a predetermined sub for me, which is just not working.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Sliced - 10-19-2024

(10-19-2024, 03:24 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I saw no evidence that Maja and Fellows both ran of steam … Maja in particular had been immense. He found so much space and pulled their defence out of position all game.

Agree, there was no need to make the change


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Tom Joad - 10-19-2024

(10-19-2024, 03:24 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I saw no evidence that Maja and Fellows both ran of steam … Maja in particular had been immense. He found so much space and pulled their defence out of position all game.

Aye, Maja is twice the player I thought he was and as such, is proving impossible to replace properly. Dobbin did really well on the left last outing and I was a little disappointed Jed got the call. I understand the subs are required with 3 games this coming week, I just thought they were the wrong ones. Wallace for Maja - if absolutely necessary, Swift for Grady,  Dobbin for TF if Tom was tired, would have been my shout, agree with the other sub.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Fido - 10-19-2024

(10-19-2024, 03:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-19-2024, 03:24 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I saw no evidence that Maja and Fellows both ran of steam … Maja in particular had been immense. He found so much space and pulled their defence out of position all game.

Me neither, Maja looked solid as he always does. Grant worked his socks off all day but managed 90 mins, why can’t Maja?
It’s a predetermined sub for me, which is just not working.

Just the way I saw it too. Agree with Shab as well on subs making no impact.


RE: Bizarre substitutions - Shabby Russian - 10-19-2024

Given we are playing midweek, I think it is unrealistic to expect everyone to keep playing 90 mins.

And the truth is we did not have the same control in the second half, even before any substitutions were made.