WBAUnofficial
Ratings today... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings today... (/showthread.php?tid=35087)



Ratings today... - Lurker#3 - 09-15-2024

What my eyes see ratings before I get my mitts on the stat pack tomorrow Big Grin

Palmer - 5 - Nowt to do in terms of goal keeping really but some really bad work on the ball costs him a point. 

Furlong - 9 - Superb in all aspects. His GCA with that throw was a genius but of play. 
Ajayi - 7 - Solid, won some good challenges and brought the ball out well a couple of times. Some iffy positioning as always but didn't cost us. 
Bartley - 9 - Beast mode. His leadership, nous and passing range really does add up to being a top CB. 
Heggem - 8 - Played well. Dealt with their winger well one v one as they go man for man, a couple of silly passes early on, but as the game went on he passed the ball much more safely and covered a lot of ground. 

Molumby - 7 - All his usual energy and graft. Good solid showing. Right hooked as he looked leggy second half. 
Mowatt - 9 (MoTM) - 10/10 second half. But knocked a mark off for the first 30 where he was caught in possession a few times and struggled to dictate like he usually does. Those goals though, class. And he won so many challenges and seemed to recover the ball endlessly second half. 

Fellows - 8 - Great assist and could have set up another 2 with some good deliveries to Maja and Grant and nearly scored. Faded badly second half, but he had done his damage. 
Swift - 7 - Same again. In an out the game, but most of what we do good goes through him at some point. When the game slows down and there's more space he's brilliant. 
Grant - 7 - Got through a ton of work, and was unlucky a couple of times not to score. Lacks a bit of quality as we all know, but never stops grafting.

Maja - 9 - Class. Great goal, great movement, great link play. Makes the game look effortless. 

Subs:

Racic, MJ, Grady - 7 - All contributed positively and helped us keep and progress the ball as their press started to fail. 

Wallace - 6 - Solid and dependable. 

Bobbins - 6 - Did nowt wrong. 

CC - 9 - Changed how we were progressing the ball second half and we simplified things. Was an obvious tactical change and it worked a dream. Subs were on point, too. 

Great away day.


RE: Ratings today... - Gzbaggy - 09-15-2024

How can you give a goalkeeper who kept a clean sheet 5?

He was competent on crossess and organized his defence well


RE: Ratings today... - Lurker#3 - 09-15-2024

(09-15-2024, 05:08 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: How can you give a goalkeeper who kept a clean sheet 5?

He was competent on crossess and organized his defence well

He caught one cross all game. Had no saves to make. 

But he almost cost us twice with horrific, hospital passes first half. Then did that brain fart throw out to Furlong second half. 

So being as 6 is baseline, he had no real goalkeeping work to do, but performed poorly in possession he loses a mark.


RE: Ratings today... - Bob Fossil - 09-15-2024

(09-15-2024, 05:14 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-15-2024, 05:08 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: How can you give a goalkeeper who kept a clean sheet 5?

He was competent on crossess and organized his defence well

He caught one cross all game. Had no saves to make. 

But he almost cost us twice with horrific, hospital passes first half. Then did that brain fart throw out to Furlong second half. 

So being as 6 is baseline, he had no real goalkeeping work to do, but performed poorly in possession he loses a mark.
Yeah, unfortunately his performance was governed by our superb defending meaning that Pompey had no shots on target! Means his errors were magnified, without any saves to offset. Fair score.

Shows that the whole is greater than the sum of it's parts when we can pick players out for weaknesses, Palmer, Heggem, Grant, yet still won comfortably. That's the definition of good coaching and team spirit for me.


RE: Ratings today... - Stillclem4england - 09-15-2024

Good comments on Swift.

Josh’s threw away performances have been the best performances by an Albion striker since the Big Dave season. Finishing is class but his touch, lay offs and passing are even better.


RE: Ratings today... - Tom Joad - 09-15-2024

Re Palmer. He collected a no.of crosses, positioning was great and he read that 1st half through ball a treat to cut out the danger. Make no mistake he contributed a lot to our clean sheet. Conversely he also contributed to Pompey's best 2 chances and also messed up a couple of other clearances. I'd say a 6.


RE: Ratings today... - yeoman lai - 09-15-2024

7 across the board bar:

Palmer - 6 (shite kicking)
Bart landor - 8
Josh - 8.5
Mowatt - 9


RE: Ratings today... - Jacko - 09-15-2024

Palmer 6

Furlong 8
Ajayi 6.5
Bartley 8
Heggem 7.5

Mowatt 9
Molumby 6

Fellows 8
Swift 7
Grant 6

Maja 8.5

Wallace 6
Diangana 6
Račić 7

Dobbin 6
Johnston 6.5


RE: Ratings today... - Lurker#3 - 09-15-2024

(09-15-2024, 05:23 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(09-15-2024, 05:14 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-15-2024, 05:08 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: How can you give a goalkeeper who kept a clean sheet 5?

He was competent on crossess and organized his defence well

He caught one cross all game. Had no saves to make. 

But he almost cost us twice with horrific, hospital passes first half. Then did that brain fart throw out to Furlong second half. 

So being as 6 is baseline, he had no real goalkeeping work to do, but performed poorly in possession he loses a mark.
Yeah, unfortunately his performance was governed by our superb defending meaning that Pompey had no shots on target! Means his errors were magnified, without any saves to offset. Fair score.

Shows that the whole is greater than the sum of it's parts when we can pick players out for weaknesses, Palmer, Heggem, Grant, yet still won comfortably. That's the definition of good coaching and team spirit for me.

Exactly that, Bob. It wasn't the perfect performance, but it was a ruthless, dogged performance against a tricky opposition. 

CC has got us really well drilled and those individual weaknesses are never laid bare for teams to exploit.


RE: Ratings today... - wba13 - 09-15-2024

So Palmer is being blamed for his kicking hmm, yes some was bad but his long kick to Furlong from which We won the throw in that furlong threw to Fellows,who then made the pass to Maja o promptly scored. So I give hi 1 point back for quick thinking. Also Palmers long kick broke to Johnston who shot was saved before Ragic was fouled for Mowatt to score the third goal. Helped with two goals so he’s now up to 6.5 which is about right as he did most duties right except for a couple of short passes.