WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=34845)

Pages: 1 2 3


Ratings - greetsgreenbaggie - 08-24-2024

Palms-7 solid display 
AJ- 7 no ricks today 
Barts- 7 couple of mistakes, but still a good performance 
Furgs- 7 best performance this season 
Heggo-8 class, just class
Mowatt- 8 never stops running, just wish he’d get a goal
Swift-6 poor, again
Molumbey-8 full of energy, plays with confidence 
Fellows-9 two assists, say no more POTM
Grant-8 superb game from him
Maja-8 a thorn in his former clubs side

Diakite-6 not enough time to judge
Bobbins-7 best outing so far
Diang-5 hope the injury isn’t serious 
Fans-6 see Diakite
Wallace-7 positive runs, looked to hurt Stoke

CC
Got tactics and subs spot on again.


RE: Ratings - Borin' Baggie - 08-24-2024

I'd bump Bartley down to a 6, his passing was poor and nearly cost us twice because of it.


RE: Ratings - BasingBaggie - 08-24-2024

Thought Diakite was superb when he came on, was exactly the right sub and did his job superbly. There is a good player there if we can keep him fit


RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 08-24-2024

Palmer - 6

Furlong - 7
Ajayi - 7
Bartley - 6
Heggem - 6

Mowatt - 6
Molumby - 6
Swift - 6

Fellows - 8
Maja - 8
Grant - 8

Subs:

All came in and out a good shift in. Bobbins showed more promise, Oussie and Frabotta will be fine. Hope Grady is okay as we need him fully fit and in the team.


RE: Ratings - Berthe of a Nation - 08-24-2024

(08-24-2024, 04:49 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Palms-7 solid display 
AJ- 7 no ricks today 
Barts- 7 couple of mistakes, but still a good performance 
Furgs- 7 best performance this season 
Heggo-8 class, just class
Mowatt- 8 never stops running, just wish he’d get a goal
Swift-6 poor, again
Molumbey-8 full of energy, plays with confidence 
Fellows-9 two assists, say no more POTM
Grant-8 superb game from him
Maja-8 a thorn in his former clubs side

Diakite-6 not enough time to judge
Bobbins-7 best outing so far
Diang-5 hope the injury isn’t serious 
Fans-6 see Diakite
Wallace-7 positive runs, looked to hurt Stoke

CC
Got tactics and subs spot on again.
You can't say Swift was poor. He's the second coming to some on here.

Personally, I would play I am a passenger when he gets subbed.

Great to see the rest of your scores, especially Grant.

I cannot rate anyone as I only listened to it on the radio.

What happened to Grady, as I lost reception when I went into the bullring?


RE: Ratings - Babel - 08-24-2024

Interestinlgy, it seems the difference between good and poor is 7 vs 6 ratings. Is that so?


RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 08-24-2024

(08-24-2024, 05:20 PM)Babel Wrote: Interestinlgy, it seems the difference between good and poor is 7 vs 6 ratings. Is that so?

5 is poor for me. 6 average. 7 good. 8 great. 9 usually MOTM. 10 very rare.


RE: Ratings - MancBaggie - 08-24-2024

(08-24-2024, 05:21 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-24-2024, 05:20 PM)Babel Wrote: Interestinlgy, it seems the difference between good and poor is 7 vs 6 ratings. Is that so?

5 is poor for me. 6 average. 7 good. 8 great. 9 usually MOTM. 10 very rare.

Pretty much agree. 

4 poor
5 off form
6 average/ par
7 good
8 excellent 
9 outstanding 
10 out of this world/Laurie


RE: Ratings - Jacko - 08-24-2024

Palmer 7

Furlong 7
Ajayi 6
Bartley 6
Heggem 7

Molumby 7
Mowatt 8

Fellows 8
Swift 6
Grant 7

Maja 7.5

Wallace 6
Diangana 6
Diakite 7
Frabotta 6.5
Dobbins 6.5


RE: Ratings - Vinebaggie - 08-24-2024

(08-24-2024, 04:49 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Palms-7 solid display 
AJ- 7 no ricks today 
Barts- 7 couple of mistakes, but still a good performance 
Furgs- 7 best performance this season 
Heggo-8 class, just class
Mowatt- 8 never stops running, just wish he’d get a goal
Swift-6 poor, again
Molumbey-8 full of energy, plays with confidence 
Fellows-9 two assists, say no more POTM
Grant-8 superb game from him
Maja-8 a thorn in his former clubs side

Diakite-6 not enough time to judge
Bobbins-7 best outing so far
Diang-5 hope the injury isn’t serious 
Fans-6 see Diakite
Wallace-7 positive runs, looked to hurt Stoke

CC
Got tactics and subs spot on again.

wouldn’t disagree with any of these scores.  On Swift think he was OK as opposed to poor.  Swift doesn’t make killer passes but he doesn’t tend to lose the ball giving away goals either.  I was at St Mary’s and tbh while Swift isn’t great I’d rather see him playing 10 than Grady every fucking day of the week