![]() |
|
The Squad - in and out as it stands - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: The Squad - in and out as it stands (/showthread.php?tid=34677) Pages:
1
2
|
The Squad - in and out as it stands - ColliersWoodBaggie - 08-09-2024 I for one am looking forward to the beginning of the season, although we shall have more idea where the squad is, in 3 weeks from now. Since Southampton, most understood what could happen. Not a fire sale, but a restructure. Players coming to the end of their (large) contracts, quite frankly, for not enough return, in the majority. The Outs: Reach Kelly Pieters M'Vila Chalobah Phillips Malcolm Pipa(loan) Marshall (loan) Ashworth Weimann Kipre BTA Yokuslu Townsend Johnstone (Loan) I was disappointed at BTA going, as I liked his attitude, but he's replaceable and it's a good profit. His first touch isn't the best and 12 goals a season.......Still, he'd have been useful. Yok - well I half expected him to go and the wages were high - for 60-70 mins a week. I was surprised at Townsend going initially, but 1m for a 30 year old left back, who has been decent in the Championship, but little more, is good money. And he's probably on good wages. Kipre is a bit of a blow, as he was offered a new deal, but one good season in three. I've seen calls for Johnstone to come back, but he's overpriced and Dobbin is his replacement. I was glad about Bartley and Mowatt. They have improved hugely under Corboran. I do not have figures, but this saves a heck of a lot on salaries, as well as bringing in approx 6-7m in fees. Hopefully, we will get something from O'Shea going to Brentford too (20% of profit I think). And these are players who contributed to our lowest League positions in 20 years plus. Not all bad, but replaceable. I think with one or two exceptions, most supporters will not be too upset. So the ins: Heggem Diakete McNair (until Jan) Wildsmith Dobbin Frambotta Cole Out of those, largely unknowns at this level. McNair the only one with experience of the Championship or playing higher. However, we still have a core of the squad together that has played in the Champ. Hopefully, we are moving in the direction of getting in (mainly) younger, more hungry players with energy. We had the highest squad age in the League and it showed at times. But, overall, I'd like to see the rest stay now, as I doubt we really need to sell desperately (only at our value) . I can see , maybe Swift going, but we need (IMO) to keep hold of our midfielders unless more come in. Some of our younger players like Heard may also step up in the way Fellows has. Remember , Maja will be like a new signing . Let's hope we see the early season Maja, as I thought he looked useful. Better movement than BTA. So, I think this is a season to look forward to. Albion have done much better buying in players who have something to prove, are young and largely unknowns. The Megson side of 01-02 was like this. As was Giles' side of 1976 (or so I'm told). With CC and his team, plus the newer scouting structure, we can move forwards on the pitch. We need 3-4 more IMO (especially a RB, midfielder and another striker). You have to have confidence with Shilen Patel, as there appears now to be a strategy which was missing and one where the manager and his team are supported properly. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - Duffers - 08-09-2024 Of all the players we’ve lost only six were what you would describe as first team regulars - Phillips, Kipre, BTA, Townsend, Okay and Pieters at a push. The rest were mostly deadwood that needed shifting anyway. We’ve signed seven players so far (plus Taylor coming back into the fold and hopefully ready to challenge for the first team), most of whom are younger than the ones they’ve replaced. Whether they’re as good is the key question but time will tell. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - SW4Baggie - 08-09-2024 When you see the list of players to have exited, and take into account the wage reduction for Bartley and Mowatt as part of their new deals I think it’s entirely reasonable to assume we’ve cut around £200-250k/wk off the wage bill, along with bringing in c. £6m in fees. I doubt we are paying more than 7-10k/wk to any of the new additions - perhaps Dobbin is more given his move to Villa. Conservatively we’ve probably cut the wagebill by around £10M and brought in some cash too, and come out of the summer with a much younger side. We just have to hope 3-4 of them have some quality! RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - Man from delmonte - 08-09-2024 (08-09-2024, 07:11 AM)Duffers Wrote: Of all the players we’ve lost only six were what you would describe as first team regulars - Phillips, Kipre, BTA, Townsend, Okay and Pieters at a push. The rest were mostly deadwood that needed shifting anyway. And of those 6 Phillips couldn't be relied upon to stay fit for the majority of the season, Pieters is relatively ancient, Yokuslu's fitness levels are steadily decreasing and Townsend is in early 30s. Only Kipre and BTA would have ideally been good to keep for any sort of long term development of the club. The OP's list really helps to hit home the point that we've lost a lot of players this summer but I'm not sure that we're really that much worse off when you consider the big financial boost it has given the club in terms of getting us out of the financial hole we find ourselves in. Obviously we're relying on our new foreign signings to turn out to be decent but I'm reasonably hopeful for this season. I don't expect top 6 but I think we can definitely be a very steady upper mid-table team. I think the most exciting aspect of it will be seeing younger players come into the squad and hopefully blooding the best of our Academy lads to see if they have it in them to make the grade. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - 1878andallthat - 08-09-2024 Good post Giles signed Mulligan, Martin & Treacy btw but also gave starts to Robson & Statham. Maybe signed Cunningham also? RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - MrBater - 08-09-2024 For me the only out that was of concern is BTA. Sure we don't know much about Heggem and Diakite, but hopefully they'll be decent and if so then I'm not bothered about Kipre (it wasn't that long ago that he was one of our worst defenders), and Yok, just didn't have the engine The other outs were pretty much deadwood and wouldn't even have sparked let alone lit any fires. Johnston wasn't ours so I don't consider him an out. The bigger concern for me is up from t, but then again it's been like it for years, and now with Diane's injury we really are reliant on unknowns at this level. We'll see, but qué Sera Sera RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - Shabby Russian - 08-09-2024 (08-09-2024, 09:04 AM)1878andallthat Wrote: Good post Stalham and Cunningham brought into the team after promotion. Giles inherited some top quality players, who may have lost their way. But Tony Brown, Robertson, Wile and Cantello were all capable of playing well in the top division. Osborne was a reasonable top league keeper. And Giles himself was at Div 2 level, still an outstanding player. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-09-2024 (08-09-2024, 09:04 AM)1878andallthat Wrote: Good post Ronnie Allen signed Cunningham, I think? He signed in 1977, I thought it was after Giles left. I stand to be corrected, though. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - BurleyBaggie - 08-09-2024 I agree with what many have said, sad to see BTA go but for the money and his output he can be replaced. The Yok was great but it was the right time to sell, same for Townsend. The biggest disappointment was Kipre for me as he had power and pace, not something we are blessed with at CH. I would also add that in addition to Maja, Molumby will be a big addition and like a new signing (regardless of his limitations) as he has energy and bite - though not a great right hook. We are short, the lad Hayden from Newc would be a smart addition to cover CH and RB, also has pace and power. We are probably three short; CB/RB cover. a 6 in the Yok mold and a CF. RE: The Squad - in and out as it stands - Spandaubaggie - 08-09-2024 (08-09-2024, 10:42 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(08-09-2024, 09:04 AM)1878andallthat Wrote: Good post Giles bought him towards the end of 76/77. Allen got Regis. Back up to date, I seriously expect 3-4 new signings before the end of the month, when we can assess things better. |