WBAUnofficial
The Tax Gap - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Tax Gap (/showthread.php?tid=34149)

Pages: 1 2


The Tax Gap - Protheroe - 06-24-2024

All the parties claim that they can raise funds by reducing the tax gap, but it's already at a record low in percentage terms. Labour's plan to increase HMRC's budget may help, but their focus on the wealthy and big corporates is guided by politics rather than reality (plus ca change).

In reality, small businesses make up 60% of the tax gap, and it's only by targeting them that the gap could be reduced. However, the parties are also fighting for the votes of small business owners. 


https://www.tax.org.uk/tax-gap-at-record-high-and-record-low


RE: The Tax Gap - Ossian - 06-24-2024

Purely a personal perspective this, but my instinct is that the next administration will have a wretched first 2 to 3 years and attract the kind of headlines that would usually lead to electoral wipeout. Essentially a repeat of the most recent 3 years, but for different reasons, and they will just have to ride it out.

Then we'll see whether growth and levelling-up (which will probably be given an new name*) are showing any signs of becoming reality.

* Not Regional Development though - we've already used that one.


RE: The Tax Gap - Protheroe - 06-24-2024

I suspect that the Labour Administration will be one of the most unpopular in history within 18 months, with a combination of further tax rises and lamentable public services. I really do hope the growth they need actually does transpire - but the OBR's existing projection is already wildly optimistic compared with most forecasters.

The major concern I have is restlessness in the Labour ranks in the likely event that growth does not ride the rescue. Given Starmer's previous volte faces on virtually every possible policy position it's easy to see that the moderate face he presents today could be replaced by something very different within a couple of years, indeed even if he's still PM by then.


RE: The Tax Gap - Lurker#3 - 06-24-2024

The next government will be toothless as although they will on paper have a sizeable majority, by the time the Tories have got in bed with reform it will be much closer than people expect. Then you'll have the inevitable in fighting within Labour, within the first 2 years of parliament and it will all go massively to shit.

The only slight saving grace is Labour cant afford to go too far left as all those old Labour voters who return form the Tories in 2019 wont take much to go reform either. So they may try and rid the party of the far left and cement themselves on the middle ground.

Policy wise - Labour will hammer things like council tax and tax breaks for business. I think they will steer clear of income tax rises across the board.


RE: The Tax Gap - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-24-2024

CORBYN

(06-24-2024, 11:35 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The next government will be toothless as although they will on paper have a sizeable majority, by the time the Tories have got in bed with reform it will be much closer than people expect. Then you'll have the inevitable in fighting within Labour, within the first 2 years of parliament and it will all go massively to shit.

The only slight saving grace is Labour cant afford to go too far left as all those old Labour voters who return form the Tories in 2019 wont take much to go reform either. So they may try and rid the party of the far left and cement themselves on the middle ground.

Policy wise - Labour will hammer things like council tax and tax breaks for business. I think they will steer clear of income tax rises across the board.

Reform are on target for 6 seats, Tories 97.  There is some legitimacy in peoples' concerns about a Labour supermajority and the power this would hand to the executive... not that there is a credible alternative to 'water them down' with.

https://x.com/BritainElects/status/1804830183192428753


RE: The Tax Gap - Borin' Baggie - 06-24-2024

Really don't buy that argument about a "supermajority", that's not how our constitution is set up.


RE: The Tax Gap - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-24-2024

Brave Gary will have to see a c.20 point swing in the polls if he's to retain Northfield.

(06-24-2024, 01:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Really don't buy that argument about a "supermajority", that's not how our constitution is set up.

As I typed it I realised that i didn't actually know what the definition was, but in my mind I saw it as having such a sizeable majority that the scale of rebellion from its own MPs would have to be MASSIVE for it to have any hope of an impact, thus effectively rendering the cabinet as an absolute authority, bar a government crushing rebellion.  

Because, if the Britain Elects figures are true, around 50% of Labour MPs would have to revolt if they were to stop any legislation from the cabinet being passed.  That's not healthy. Imagine the fear if someone like CORBYN had that sort of power...

What it is called is immaterial, but it needs a name as it is a problem.


RE: The Tax Gap - Hudds1 - 06-24-2024

In the excise, we take the Tax Gap figures with a huge sack of salt. For example, the tax gap for oil (fuel) in HMRC’s published statement is summarized at 0.5%. This largely comprises unmarked gas oil (red diesel) at 0.8% of the diesel market. Somewhat bizarrely, the report states: “The petrol duty gap is assumed to be zero due to low demand from commercial sectors and the flammable nature of the product.” A truly weird "assumption" that has elicited a few titters. Moreover, the Tax Gap report is apparently unaware that HMRC prohibits the duty-suspended movement of petrol and diesel within the UK so that there is no opportunity for illicit diversion from the duty-suspended supply chain. I made this point to those responsible in HMRC when they presented this garbage to us. Lost for words, they were.


RE: The Tax Gap - Protheroe - 06-24-2024

(06-24-2024, 02:39 PM)Hudds1 Wrote: In the excise, we take the Tax Gap figures with a huge sack of salt.  For example, the tax gap for oil (fuel) in HMRC’s published statement is summarized at 0.5%. This largely comprises unmarked gas oil (red diesel) at 0.8% of the diesel market. Somewhat bizarrely, the report states: “The petrol duty gap is assumed to be zero due to low demand from commercial sectors and the flammable nature of the product.”  A truly weird "assumption" that has elicited a few titters. Moreover, the Tax Gap report is apparently unaware that HMRC prohibits the duty-suspended movement of petrol and diesel within the UK so that there is no opportunity for illicit diversion from the duty-suspended supply chain.  I made this point to those responsible in HMRC when they presented this garbage to us.  Lost for words, they were.

Arf. That is interesting.

This comment "it is reasonable to surmise that a lot of this is due to small business owners making mistakes with their tax" should tell the HMRC just one thing - simplify the Tax Code for small businesses.


RE: The Tax Gap - Birdman1811 - 06-24-2024

(06-24-2024, 03:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2024, 02:39 PM)Hudds1 Wrote: In the excise, we take the Tax Gap figures with a huge sack of salt.  For example, the tax gap for oil (fuel) in HMRC’s published statement is summarized at 0.5%. This largely comprises unmarked gas oil (red diesel) at 0.8% of the diesel market. Somewhat bizarrely, the report states: “The petrol duty gap is assumed to be zero due to low demand from commercial sectors and the flammable nature of the product.”  A truly weird "assumption" that has elicited a few titters. Moreover, the Tax Gap report is apparently unaware that HMRC prohibits the duty-suspended movement of petrol and diesel within the UK so that there is no opportunity for illicit diversion from the duty-suspended supply chain.  I made this point to those responsible in HMRC when they presented this garbage to us.  Lost for words, they were.

Arf. That is interesting.

This comment "it is reasonable to surmise that a lot of this is due to small business owners making mistakes with their tax" should tell the HMRC just one thing - simplify the Tax Code.

It doesn't need to be just for small businesses.