![]() |
|
Housing - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Housing (/showthread.php?tid=34036) |
Housing - Protheroe - 06-11-2024 Estate Agents have welcomed the Tories' Housing Proposals. Which tells you all you need to know about how awful those proposals are. RE: Housing - Borin' Baggie - 06-11-2024 Read the energy section. They literally call out that our reliance on fossil fuels has shafted energy prices and that we need more renewables to stabilise prices. Then in another section they say they want more CGGT (we have enough of those already) because they want more gas. Absolute nonsense. RE: Housing - Pipkins - 06-11-2024 More bullshit & soundbites from the two main parties Build more homes as not enough Instead ask large corporations to relocate to areas that desperately need jobs You can buy 2 bed terraced house in Stoke for about £50K that probably needs some work But much better than a 250K starter home with a 40 year mortgage RE: Housing - Protheroe - 06-11-2024 (06-11-2024, 05:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Read the energy section. I shall have a good look at them all at the weekend. I'm particularly keen on what Labour say about encouraging growth. The OBR's projections are very ambitious when set against the record. Fall just a couple of tenths of % short in the medium term and you're into a tax gap of tens of £billions. It's inevitable that we are all going to have to pay even more tax. (06-11-2024, 07:12 PM)Pipkins Wrote: More bullshit & soundbites from the two main parties Regional policy doesn't work. We need to direct housing investment towards the areas of highest demand - Oxford-Cambridge, M4 / Elizabeth Line, Banbury-MK-Wycombe and London. Whether you like it or not London drives the whole UK economy - if you need growth (which we do) you take the shortest route to get there. RE: Housing - Pipkins - 06-12-2024 (06-11-2024, 07:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-11-2024, 05:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Read the energy section. I agree London drives the economy in terms or Finance But huge demand low supply just drives prices & debt up (market forces) Ultimately there is only so much land there so homes have go somewhere else Last year 600000 people moved to the Uk thats the equivilant to the city of Glasgow RE: Housing - Borin' Baggie - 06-12-2024 (06-12-2024, 10:07 AM)Pipkins Wrote:(06-11-2024, 07:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(06-11-2024, 05:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Read the energy section. The best way to spread things out is to better connect the economic centres, HS2 is why companies started looking at moving their ops to Birmingham. The only reason I can work in the Midlands is because my office is an hour away from where industry and trade groups are HQ'd in London. London is prosperous because of gravity. Birmingham became prosperous in the 19th century due to new transport links to London and being able to service new heavy industries in the Black Country. Manchester became prosperous because of the shipping canal enabling better links for the cotton mill. Coventry became prosperous (and was named capital city) because of its central location close to the junction with Fosse Way and Watling Street giving it great connections. Or the EU enabling better trade links to central and Eastern European countries which has helped Poland, Slovenia, Croatia and Estonia rapidly progress over the last 20 years. That is how you organically stimulate regional growth, centralised state control over industry is how you fuck that up. Also, the UK population centres are less dense than Australia, Birmingham is less dense now than it was 100 years ago (if Birmingham was as densely populated as Copenhagen it would have a population 150k greater. There's loads of scope to build more densely populated houses, why is there a massive former council estate in Ladywood that's two-storey houses? Just replacing those with 5-8 storey houses would massively density Birmingham while letting people having more space (if you assume 2 or 3 units per building) than they do now. Not to mention building Georgian/Victorian style terraced townhouses instead of semi detached and detached houses, which is possible if you build a new town around existing rail connections - and I'd rather live in Poundbury or that modern estate on the outskirts of Solihull based on Georgian architecture than an estate full of Barratt boxes. Finally, UK population growth isn't that much despite the scary net migration numbers, it's lower than contemporary European countries even accounting for high net migration rates. The population grew by 220k in 2023 from 2022 even with 745k net migration, I don't think people realise how old the UK population actually is and therefore the numbers of people dying each year. It's a similar level of population growth as it was in the 1960s even though we had negative net migration then, because the birth rates now are so low. 220k isn't exactly a hard target to hit in terms of new houses, we managed more than that in the 1930s and those houses were built without modern tech and to a higher standard generally. Net migration is covering up for our appalling birthrates, which are caused by people like myself and my partner not wanting to have children until we're financially secure enough. Birthrates were 2.6 in the 1960s, they're 1.6 now. RE: Housing - Protheroe - 06-12-2024 Having spent a night in an anonymous shodilly built Shoreditch Air BnB flat last week I can't get excited about greater density BB. I wouldn't wish that existence on my worst enemy. There's also a practical problem with redeveloping estates where most of the homes will not be owned by the Council anymore anyway. RE: Housing - Borin' Baggie - 06-12-2024 Having been to Copenhagen, Lyon, San Sebastian, Munich and Amsterdam I can very much get excited about higher density, and it's not like the low density urban sprawl is high quality either. That's caused by backwards planning priorities. There's also mechanisms to allow redevelopment of areas that were sold off in the 1980s we've 90s, Manchester City Council has been excellent at doing this. RE: Housing - Protheroe - 06-12-2024 (06-12-2024, 01:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Having been to Copenhagen, Lyon, San Sebastian, Munich and Amsterdam I can very much get excited about higher density, and it's not like the low density urban sprawl is high quality either. That's caused by backwards planning priorities. I agree that quality is key, but unfortunately UK land values are so great in areas of high demand that quality goes out of the window. I'd also argue that razing low slung Ladywood to the ground is unnecessary when you have Icknield Port Loop and the areas around the Reservoir to prioritise first. RE: Housing - Tom Joad - 06-12-2024 BB's post mentions density. If tackled correctly this would go some way being a relatively easy answer. As would restricting developments top heavy with "executive homes" in nice areas. Time and again we see the slogans advertising a new development of 3, 4 and 5 bed houses. Just making sure there are more of the 3 beds and less of the 4s and 5s would help local young people. Then there are supermarkets buying land AOTS. Kingstanding Circle being such an example. An area so overloaded with shops the entire shopping centre went void but instead of being used for housing is going to be an entirely unnecessary Aldi/Lidl. Unnecessary because there are both of these stores represented numerous times locally along with all of the other supermarkets. |