WBAUnofficial
Strength in depth… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Strength in depth… (/showthread.php?tid=31595)

Pages: 1 2


Strength in depth… - CA Baggie - 10-31-2023

Do we have more than we recognise as fans?

I think it was Andy Hinchcliffe last night talking about us having quality to bring on - BTA, Townsend, Molumby, Furlong, Fellows.

Are we the antithesis of the Seals?  They’ve always bigged up their players (or abused very quickly) and we seem to down play the quality we have.

It would be a shame to see Fellows lose his place on the bench when Sarmiento is fit, I think he’s being used perfectly and is maybe an example of not rating our own high enough.

KC is going to have some tough decisions when Swift, Sarmiento and Maja are fit.


RE: Strength in depth… - Bob Fossil - 10-31-2023

(10-31-2023, 12:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Do we have more than we recognise as fans?

I think it was Andy Hinchcliffe last night talking about us having quality to bring on - BTA, Townsend, Molumby, Furlong, Fellows.

Are we the antithesis of the Seals?  They’ve always bigged up their players (or abused very quickly) and we seem to down play the quality we have.

It would be a shame to see Fellows lose his place on the bench when Sarmiento is fit, I think he’s being used perfectly and is maybe an example of not rating our own high enough.

KC is going to have some tough decisions when Swift, Sarmiento and Maja are fit.

Unfortunately, think it's inevitable that Fellows falls down the pecking order. Unless we are forced to sell players in January, can see a loan for him. Maybe at Champ level this time though.


RE: Strength in depth… - Lurker#3 - 10-31-2023

Yes, as a few of us have consistently said. With a fully fit squad there's not many better in the league.

But our injury record has been shocking and unfortunate.

Dike, Maja, BTA, Wallace, Grady, Sarmiento... That's some attacking options to have.


RE: Strength in depth… - Ted Maul - 10-31-2023

This point was made on here a week or so back.

On the face of it, we have a really good collection of Championship names that have been around the block and if this were FIFA or Football Manager we'd do really well. Reality is our squad is the product of years of mismanagement where 3-4 vastly different styles and varying levels of expenditure have pulled together a disjointed and uncomplimentary group of players.

This doesn't mean individually they're not good, but it is probably the reason that for the past couple of seasons we have not looked the sum of our parts. Fortunately Carlos seems to be changing that.


RE: Strength in depth… - Lurker#3 - 10-31-2023

(10-31-2023, 01:29 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This point was made on here a week or so back.

On the face of it, we have a really good collection of Championship names that have been around the block and if this were FIFA or Football Manager we'd do really well. Reality is our squad is the product of years of mismanagement where 3-4 vastly different styles and varying levels of expenditure have pulled together a disjointed and uncomplimentary group of players.

This doesn't mean individually they're not good, but it is probably the reason that for the past couple of seasons we have not looked the sum of our parts. Fortunately Carlos seems to be changing that.

The squad is actually more balanced now than at any point in the last decade. The unbalanced quad was produced by the reliance on older players such as Brunt, Mozza, Barry, Fletcher etc, then their subsequent replacements being short term; loans/players like Diagne, Gallagher, Maikland-Niles etc

Since our relegation and subsequent staying down. We have made better signings. Swift, Wallace, BTA, Maja, Dike, Molumby. All of the above had a level of rationale and logic. 

We now on paper have a balanced bunch in terms of age and abilities/skills. Except in CM and at wingback, where its still a bit of a hodgepodge.


RE: Strength in depth… - KRO - 10-31-2023

(10-31-2023, 12:11 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Do we have more than we recognise as fans?

I think it was Andy Hinchcliffe last night talking about us having quality to bring on - BTA, Townsend, Molumby, Furlong, Fellows.

Are we the antithesis of the Seals?  They’ve always bigged up their players (or abused very quickly) and we seem to down play the quality we have.

It would be a shame to see Fellows lose his place on the bench when Sarmiento is fit, I think he’s being used perfectly and is maybe an example of not rating our own high enough.

KC is going to have some tough decisions when Swift, Sarmiento and Maja are fit.

Still very much a top 10 squad. Definitely a top 6 head coach


RE: Strength in depth… - Ted Maul - 10-31-2023

(10-31-2023, 01:45 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-31-2023, 01:29 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This point was made on here a week or so back.

On the face of it, we have a really good collection of Championship names that have been around the block and if this were FIFA or Football Manager we'd do really well. Reality is our squad is the product of years of mismanagement where 3-4 vastly different styles and varying levels of expenditure have pulled together a disjointed and uncomplimentary group of players.

This doesn't mean individually they're not good, but it is probably the reason that for the past couple of seasons we have not looked the sum of our parts. Fortunately Carlos seems to be changing that.

The squad is actually more balanced now than at any point in the last decade. The unbalanced quad was produced by the reliance on older players such as Brunt, Mozza, Barry, Fletcher etc, then their subsequent replacements being short term; loans/players like Diagne, Gallagher, Maikland-Niles etc

Since our relegation and subsequent staying down. We have made better signings. Swift, Wallace, BTA, Maja, Dike, Molumby. All of the above had a level of rationale and logic. 

We now on paper have a balanced bunch in terms of age and abilities/skills. Except in CM and at wingback, where its still a bit of a hodgepodge.

Agree, and we actually have a manager at the helm who will take these players and make them better.

The constant chopping and changing of managers and tactical (or lack of) styles plays a part in this as well. Carlos hopefully is going nowhere fast so for the first time in a long time we can concentrate on developing a core of players to build around like you say. Genuinely when was the last time we had that? There were times on here last season we were saying there's none of them we'd be sad to see go, now there's at least a couple I'd like to keep.


RE: Strength in depth… - Squid - 10-31-2023

The main thing watching us now, us that everyone knows their role. It is exactly the level of organisation needed to overcome so many years of chopping and changing managers, playing style and transfer policies.

That some fans then bleat that we aren't "exciting" to watch fills me with despair.


RE: Strength in depth… - Bob Fossil - 10-31-2023

(10-31-2023, 01:45 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-31-2023, 01:29 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This point was made on here a week or so back.

On the face of it, we have a really good collection of Championship names that have been around the block and if this were FIFA or Football Manager we'd do really well. Reality is our squad is the product of years of mismanagement where 3-4 vastly different styles and varying levels of expenditure have pulled together a disjointed and uncomplimentary group of players.

This doesn't mean individually they're not good, but it is probably the reason that for the past couple of seasons we have not looked the sum of our parts. Fortunately Carlos seems to be changing that.

The squad is actually more balanced now than at any point in the last decade. The unbalanced quad was produced by the reliance on older players such as Brunt, Mozza, Barry, Fletcher etc, then their subsequent replacements being short term; loans/players like Diagne, Gallagher, Maikland-Niles etc

Since our relegation and subsequent staying down. We have made better signings. Swift, Wallace, BTA, Maja, Dike, Molumby. All of the above had a level of rationale and logic. 

We now on paper have a balanced bunch in terms of age and abilities/skills. Except in CM and at wingback, where its still a bit of a hodgepodge.
Have to agree on this as we've pretty much achieved CC's dream of two players for each position, apart from CF, we are pretty much there.
Stalwarts like Molumby, Furlong and Townsend on the bench last night, Ajayi, Swift and Dike injured, yet still a well drilled and professional performance in every position. More balance than we've seen for many a year.

We probably don't have the quality for top 3, or even to guarantee top 6, but, if we can keep this discipline and avoid any further bouts of injuries, we could spring a surprise.


RE: Strength in depth… - NewWanker - 10-31-2023

I tend to ignore commentator's assessments of our players / bench, as invariably they say stupid things. Pretty sure a commentator once biggesd up Burke and others have with others, calling them quality etc...