![]() |
|
Ratings - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=31541) |
Ratings - greetsgreenbaggie - 10-24-2023 After a shit show to get there, just made kick off. Journey home a dream in comparison. Palmer-7 not a lot to do, but another clean sheet Kipre-8 getting better and better, lets hope injury is a minor 1 Barts-7 Steady as a rock Pieters -6 better than Saturday, but still showing his age Furlong-6 going backwards, can't pass to a team mate, slips over A LOT! Chalobah-8 great performance tonight, superb assist Oaky-6 Not really okay is he? Seems way off it Philips-7 just doing enough Diang-7 great for him to score, unlucky to only finish with the 1 Wallace-6 awful tonight, can't really defend him, crossing poor, touch poor, vision poor, effort okay BTA-7 balls of steel to take the pen, shocking before, revitalised after. Molumby-7 added energy Mowatt-7 looks a different player under Carlos Fellows-7 nice to see someone attacking the full backs Gordon-6 not enough time to judge 1st half team mark-4! Teams must love playing against us 1st 45mins, as we pass side, side, backwards, side, side, forwards, side, side, backwards, repeat! It's awful to watch and winds the fans up no end. I get while we have the ball teh opposition can't score, but jesus it's frustrating. 2nd half team mark (after 55mins)-8 Battered QPR, hit them with pace, power movement, why we can't do this from the 1st minute is baffling. I know we can't do it for 90mins but we need to press more than we did tonight, sterner tests will come. RE: Ratings - Sliced - 10-24-2023 I got accused of having it out for Grady last week, which I absolutely don't, I thought he was absolutely brilliant tonight. Well worth an 8 at least RE: Ratings - greetsgreenbaggie - 10-24-2023 (10-24-2023, 10:22 PM)Sliced Wrote: I got accused of having it out for Grady last week, which I absolutely don't, I thought he was absolutely brilliant tonight. Well worth an 8 at least I'd of given him an 8, but he went hiding a couple of times. He did play 3/4 brilliant through balls though. RE: Ratings - Man from delmonte - 10-24-2023 A real game of two halves for us tonight. First half was desperately poor but enjoyed the second far more. Mowatt coming on for Yokuslu made a big difference. The latter was absolutely shocking tonight. Once we got the penalty, and then the red card, it completely changed the game. Diangana looked far more direct second half and it really caused them problems. Such a shame that curling shot from him didn't go in - would have been a cracking goal. Lovely stuff from Chalobah to set up the second. Very pleased for him that he's starting to look much more of a player now. Good for BTA to score again after a bit of a barren run. Took his penalty well and hopefully that eases any confidence worries he may have been having. Although he only came on fairly late again, I really like the look of Fellows. An exciting player who always looks to attack and take his man on. I hope that natural instinct won't be coached out of him like it is with some players. That year at League Two level has really done him some good. As for QPR, I'm struggling to remember the last time we played such a poor side. Sheffield Wednesday were pretty abject but at least had a go at us. QPR offered nothing at all and looking at their squad, it's not as if they're relying on a bunch of kids. There's a decent amount of experienced pros in there. I'd be amazed if they stay up from what I saw tonight. RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 10-24-2023 Palmer 7 Claimed crosses well, little to do Furlong 7 Solid enough, passive first half at times, needs to run the full back more, moved into a central midfield role 2nd half as Carlos went full on Pep! Pieters 6 Too slow on the ball and sloppy but an improvement on Plymouth, would have fancied Townsend to get the nod if fit surely? Kipre 7 Solid with good distribution, in good form Bartley 7 Better tonight, liked his physicality, which was sadly smiling v Plymouth, missed a sitter 2nd half, Toblerone head! Phillips 7 Starved of the ball first half but always a threat when we get him in space Okay 7 Thought he was fine, always looks to play forward if it’s on which we badly need, not at his best but harshly dropped I thought Saturday in the first place Chalobah 7 Another good showing,thought he was fading badly when Okay went off and felt it should have been him but got a second wind and had a great 20 minute spell when we took control Grady 8* Always lively but was unplayable second half, once we get him in those areas he’s as good as anything in this league Wallace 6 Can never fault his work rate, always running and trying but off it currently, also wants to play wide and is way too central in this shape BTA 6 Great penalty and came alive once he scored that, hopefully the confidence boost he needs Subs Mowatt 7 nice and tidy and ticked things over Molumby 7 full of running if sloppy with the ball at times Fellows 7 Lively and direct,as he is, two great crosses, if only for a number 9….. Pippa 7 Tidy and supported the attacks well Taylor 6 Lost the ball once carelessly but that apart was solid and tidy QPR are desperate, what a poor side, some individual talent in that side but they were shocking, Ainsworth dead man walking Cuzer RE: Ratings - MancBaggie - 10-24-2023 He’s a goner GA. Warnock and Beale available RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 10-24-2023 I thought it was the repeat of many a game when the away side comes for a point. Get a goal (and a sending off tonight to boot), and the plan goes out of the window leaving spaces AOTS. we really should have had 4 or 5 after that. Fellows put two on a plate, Grady struck the post with a beaut and Bartley ought to have done better. There was no lack of effort from our attack but there is a screaming lack of a proper striker. I wouldn't dare challenge CC on tactics but sometimes 1st half, a ball over the top would have been a nice variation. Well done Albion for getting 3 points but we won't play a worse side again at The Hawthorns this season. Grady M O M with Kipre a 2nd and special mention for Chalobah for his drive and that assist. (There's a sentence no one ever thought they'd see....) RE: Ratings - Man from delmonte - 10-24-2023 (10-24-2023, 10:40 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: He’s a goner GA. Warnock and Beale available The curse of playing the Albion struck both the Sheff Wed manager and Eustace at Blues. It's surely curtains for Ainsworth as well now. QPR's record over the last 12 months is awful. RE: Ratings - Baggie_in_the_Lye - 10-25-2023 My ratings below - people are getting carried away we huffed and puffed against one of the worst teams in the league... Palmer 7 - Not much to do, but came for every cross Kipre 7- Finally looks like a footballer, shame he's out for 6-8 weeks Barts 6 - Average against a shit attack Pieters 5 - Below Average against a shit attack Furlong 6 - worst performance for a while Chalobah 7 - decent performance Okay 5 - struggling at the moment, odd decision to put him in the in front of Mowalumby Philips 6 - beginning to look leggy, winter injury just around the corner Diang 8 - best performance since injury return - let's see if he can replicate against tougher opposition in Cov Wallace 4 - needs a rest, pity we ain't got anyone to replace him BTA 6.5 - great pen, needs a rest, pity we ain't got anyone to replace him Molumby 7 - must start next game Mowatt 7 - back to the player we signed under Ish Fellows 8 - will make things happen if he's given game time Pipa 7.5 - See Fellows comments Taylor 6 -not really on long enough to judge, we will see what he's like Monday I think |