WBAUnofficial
Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff (/showthread.php?tid=30413)

Pages: 1 2


Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-30-2023

<adopts bunged up hayfeverish voice>

"And that's why we've put record levels of investment into the NHS"


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Protheroe - 06-30-2023

One of the great bugbears I have is whether health outcomes were any worse when nurses didn't need a degree. I doubt they were, so what's the point?


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-30-2023

(06-30-2023, 09:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote: One of the great bugbears I have is whether health outcomes were any worse when nurses didn't need a degree. I doubt they were, so what's the point?

As usual, the answer isn't black and white.  The need for degree level knowledge arguably only more important as you climb the slippery slope towards leadership.  But if you don't gain that foundation at an early stage of your career and apply it in practice then the leap to a leadership role is too great a leap to make without the technical knowledge needed to supervise and train others.  It's not just about what your nurse can do for you today; it;s what they can do for the whole ward tomorrow (and this is particularly relevant when you consider how much they've taken over what were, traditionally, doctor's responsibilities over the years).  The level of responsibility a nurse manager has is insane and you wouldn't allow anyone else in any industry that level of accounatbility without robustly governed assurance around knowledge, skills and experience.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Protheroe - 06-30-2023

(06-30-2023, 10:01 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(06-30-2023, 09:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote: One of the great bugbears I have is whether health outcomes were any worse when nurses didn't need a degree. I doubt they were, so what's the point?

As usual, the answer isn't black and white.  The need for degree level knowledge arguably only more important as you climb the slippery slope towards leadership.  But if you don't gain that foundation at an early stage of your career and apply it in practice then the leap to a leadership role is too great a leap to make without the technical knowledge needed to supervise and train others.  It's not just about what your nurse can do for you today; it;s what they can do for the whole ward tomorrow (and this is particularly relevant when you consider how much they've taken over what were, traditionally, doctor's responsibilities over the years).  The level of responsibility a nurse manager has is insane and you wouldn't allow anyone else in any industry that level of accounatbility without robustly governed assurance around knowledge, skills and experience.

Quite. But a degree isn't prerequisite of being able to provide 'care'. Care is sadly lacking in the NHS, and isn't something that can be taught at University.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Borin' Baggie - 06-30-2023

Lack of a nursing and medicine degrees for nurses and doctors reduces mobility as it's less likely they'll be eligible for jobs in other countries.

(06-30-2023, 09:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote: One of the great bugbears I have is whether health outcomes were any worse when nurses didn't need a degree. I doubt they were, so what's the point?

Nursing schools became affiliated with universities for efficiency reasons as medical care became more specialised.

100 years ago you still needed 3 years of training to be a nurse and you only qualified after obtaining a qualification through passing exams. Sounds very much like doing a degree.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Squid - 07-01-2023

(06-30-2023, 09:38 AM)Protheroe Wrote: One of the great bugbears I have is whether health outcomes were any worse when nurses didn't need a degree. I doubt they were, so what's the point?

In no other job do people claim that more education makes some one worse, so why nursing is viewed differently after nearly 40 years of 50% uni 50% ward-based education I do not know. Nobody complains about physiotherapists and radiographers having university education and they used to be trained on the job too.

Firstly, research from across Europe indicates that better education for nurses does indeed improve patient outcomes:

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(13)62631-8/fulltext

Secondly, patients are sicker and their conditions much more complex. Take neonatal care. Once upon a time that was babies who were 28 weeks plus who needed an incubator, some oxygen and tube feeding. Now there are babies from 23 weeks gestation who need various types of ventilation, a slew of medications infused, blood transfusions and regular blood gas monitoring. To care for those babies takes a greater knowledge of physiology and pharmacology. It is a similar story in most critical care wards.

As for the workforce plan, two big factors will need to change for it to have any impact:

1) Sort out social care and primary care. Care for people properly in the community so that they can stay well, stay at home and if in hospital, go home promptly.

2) Nurses' training places are limited by placement capacity. The only way to increase this is to cut placement hours during placement. Australian and American student nurses spend far less time on placement then our students do and seem to fair well in practice, but this would likely be hugely unpopular with the general public.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Derek Hardballs - 07-01-2023

The plan is only going to work if they pay medical professionals a decent wage. Otherwise the NHS will carry on losing staff to other countries and other sectors.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Squid - 07-01-2023

(07-01-2023, 06:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The plan is only going to work if they pay medical professionals a decent wage. Otherwise the NHS will carry on losing staff to other countries and other sectors.

It wouldn't just be medical staff who need more money, but also, it's not just about wages, but working conditions and in some places, staff feeling that there isn't enough of them to provide quality care. There needs to be safe staffing levels by law, as there is in Wales.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Protheroe - 07-01-2023

(07-01-2023, 02:46 AM)Squid Wrote: In no other job do people claim that more education makes some one worse

I wasn't claiming that, I posed a very specific question. If there is empirical evidence that health outcomes are better due to nurses having a degree I'm happy to accept that.

However the suggestion that "care" is improved by nursing degrees is extremely debatable.


RE: Historic 15 year plan to invest in NHS staff - Birdman1811 - 07-01-2023

As someone working in the NHS.

Be thankful for Nurses, they stop the dr's from killing you. They deserve a lot more.