WBAUnofficial
20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth (/showthread.php?tid=30147)

Pages: 1 2


20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - SuperBob2002 - 05-31-2023

Players who have scored more than 20 goals in the past five seasons. As you can see it doesn't always equate to promotion. (Apologies for shit formatting). 

Player Goals Club Season Postion Promoted?
Chuba Akpo 28 Boro 22/23 4th No
Viktor Gyökeres 21 Coventry 22/23 5th No
Carlton Morris 20 Luton 22/23 3rd Yes
Aleksandar Mitrović 43 Fulham 21/22 1st Yes
Dominic Solanke 29 Bournemouth 21/22 2nd Yes
Andreas Weimann 22 Bristol 21/22 17th No
Joël Piroe 22 Swansea 21/22 15th No
Ben Brereton Díaz 22 Blackburn 21/22 8th No
Ivan Toney 31 Brentford 20/21 3rd Yes
Adam Armstrong 28 Blackburn 20/21 15th No
Teemu Pukki 26 Norwich 20/21 1st Yes
Kieffer Moore 20 Cardiff 20/21 8th No
Aleksandar Mitrović 26 Fulham 19/20 4th Yes
Ollie Watkins 25 Brentford 19/20 3rd No
Lewis Grabban 20 Nottingham Forest 19/20 7th No
Teemu Pukki 29 Norwich 18/19 1st Yes
Neal Maupay 25 Brentford 18/19 11th No
Tammy Abraham 25 Seal Cunts 18/19 5th Yes
Dwight Gayle 23 West Brom 18/19 4th No
Billy Sharp 23 Sheffield United 18/19 2nd Yes
Jay Rodríguez 22 West Brom 18/19 4th No
Che Adams 22 Blues 18/19 17th No
Jarrod Bowen 22 Hull 18/19 13th No
Oliver McBurnie 22 Swansea 18/19 10th No

A few notes;

Karlam Grant 18 goals for West Brom during 20/21 & 19 goals for Huddersfield during 19/20. We already have a '20-goal-a-season' player in the squad. 

18/19 we had two strikers combining for 45 goals, finished 4th and failed to get promoted. 

2001/2 - Scott Dobie top scored with10 league goals. 
2003/4 - Geoff Horsfield top scored 7 (14 in total after joining from Wigan) league goals. 
2007/8 - Kevin Phillips top scored with 22 league goals. 
2009/10 - Chris Brunt top scored with 13 league goals. 
2019/20 - HRK and Charlie Austin top scored with 10 league goals. Meaning out of our 5 promotion winning seasons (each finishing in the top 2) we only once had a striker score more than 20 goals in Super Kev. No one else scored more than 15. 

Do you need a 20 goal-a-season striker to get you promoted? Discuss! I certainly would like to see us sign one, but it's not a necessity. I think it's a bit of a lazy comment to make when you know the squad needs strengthening but you don't know where, how or with whom.


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - Ted Maul - 05-31-2023

Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - AnelkasBeard - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?

By goals conceded, Burnley, Sheffield United and Luton...


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Birdman1811 - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-31-2023, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?

By goals conceded, Burnley, Sheffield United and Luton...

Nothing proves the point better.


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Psalm23 - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-31-2023, 12:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-31-2023, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?

By goals conceded, Burnley, Sheffield United and Luton...

Nothing proves the point better.

I'm surprised no one's mentioned this before.    Big Grin


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - Bob Fossil - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?

Imagine if we'd started the season with an actual, physical human being in goal rather than a cloud of fag smoke?


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 05-31-2023

Different era I know, but, IIRC, we went up under Giles in `76 with...
Bomber. 12 goals,
Ally Brown. 11 goals,
Joe Mayo. 9 goals.
Think we went up with only scoring 50 something in 42 games.
But, with Osborne in goal, Robertson, Wile, Mulligan & Cantello as a back 4, Robson in midfield, we kept about 23 clean sheets.


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Ted Maul - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-31-2023, 12:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-31-2023, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Nope.

We need to be better in defence. Strikers may win you games but defences win you titles. It's always been the same way.

Out of interest who were the three best defences in the Championship this season?

By goals conceded, Burnley, Sheffield United and Luton...

Nothing proves the point better.

Just for good measure, the team with the fourth best defence was Coventry, losing PO finalists. Best four teams in the division, best four defences.


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - Duffers - 05-31-2023

(05-31-2023, 12:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Karlam Grant 18 goals for West Brom during 20/21 & 19 goals for Huddersfield during 19/20. We already have a '20-goal-a-season' player in the squad. 

We actually don't because 18 and 19 are both smaller numbers than 20.


RE: 20 goal-a-season striker gets you promoted - the myth - devonbaggie - 05-31-2023

Reinforcing the defence debate ... I think we were 2nd highest team to lose games from a winning position this season.