WBAUnofficial
Penalties thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Penalties thread (/showthread.php?tid=30137)



Penalties thread - cornishbaggie - 05-30-2023

Thinking about this, I have often wondered about the wisdom of selecting penalty takers, it seems all the best penalty takers are chosen for the first five, when if someone misses it can be retrieved and then those that didn't want to or wasn't trusted to take one, are faced with a sudden death situation.


RE: Penalties thread - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-30-2023

(05-30-2023, 09:12 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: Thinking about this, I have often wondered about the wisdom of selecting penalty takers, it seems all the best penalty takers are chosen for the first five, when if someone misses it can be retrieved and then those that didn't want to or wasn't trusted to take one, are faced with a sudden death situation.

I suppose the counter argument is that if a couple of your less competent penalty takers screw up and their top five don't, you're out. And then people wonder why the best penalty takers never got a go.


RE: Penalties thread - Birdman1811 - 05-30-2023

I'm a firm believer best takers go first, it can't help even the best takers confidence if the two or so before have missed.


RE: Penalties thread - SuperBob2002 - 05-30-2023

It's an interesting debate and shows you that there's skill and tactics involved. As well as individual mental strength and physical stamina. It's not a lottery.

I wouldn't go on the basis of best takers during the season or in practice, although I can see why and I won't argue too much against that viewpoint, but I'd leave it until the time, and look players in the eye and select those who clearly feel confident and are up for it. 

How many times do you witness a known strong penalty taker step up, looking like he's already missed, before he's even taken the penalty? (No shame in that, it's a damn difficult situation, filled with unimaginable pressure). But there's no point in asking a lad who doesn't fancy it. 

Under no circumstances would I want to see a penalty like the one that Notts County lad took in their final shootout. I'd make it clear to the players that you pick a spot and put your foot through the fucker. I'd rather see a player miss the target by blazing it over than seeing it saved by a GK who hasn't had to move because you've tried being a smart ass by attempting a chip or a soft rolled shot down the middle. Recall Euro 96 against the Germans? Every German put it top corner with some pace and power. 

Yours in undoubted penalty knowledge (I've missed plenty in my time!).


RE: Penalties thread - MrFizz - 05-30-2023

(05-30-2023, 12:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's an interesting debate and shows you that there's skill and tactics involved. As well as individual mental strength and physical stamina. It's not a lottery.

I wouldn't go on the basis of best takers during the season or in practice, although I can see why and I won't argue too much against that viewpoint, but I'd leave it until the time, and look players in the eye and select those who clearly feel confident and are up for it. 

How many times do you witness a known strong penalty taker step up, looking like he's already missed, before he's even taken the penalty? (No shame in that, it's a damn difficult situation, filled with unimaginable pressure). But there's no point in asking a lad who doesn't fancy it. 

Under no circumstances would I want to see a penalty like the one that Notts County lad took in their final shootout. I'd make it clear to the players that you pick a spot and put your foot through the fucker. I'd rather see a player miss the target by blazing it over than seeing it saved by a GK who hasn't had to move because you've tried being a smart ass by attempting a chip or a soft rolled shot down the middle.

Yours in undoubted penalty knowledge (I've missed plenty in my time!).

I tried that in the one and only penalty shootout i was involved in. Put the ball down, walked back 5 paces, ran up and absolutely leathered the fecker. Never felt the ball on my foot i hit it that true. Unfortunately it hit the crossbar smack on, and the ball rebounded so far i could have caught it. Big Grin

Didn't matter anyway because we ended up winning the shootout, and a place in the prestigious Sandwell District 4 Cup Final.


RE: Penalties thread - SuperBob2002 - 05-30-2023

(05-30-2023, 12:16 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(05-30-2023, 12:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's an interesting debate and shows you that there's skill and tactics involved. As well as individual mental strength and physical stamina. It's not a lottery.

I wouldn't go on the basis of best takers during the season or in practice, although I can see why and I won't argue too much against that viewpoint, but I'd leave it until the time, and look players in the eye and select those who clearly feel confident and are up for it. 

How many times do you witness a known strong penalty taker step up, looking like he's already missed, before he's even taken the penalty? (No shame in that, it's a damn difficult situation, filled with unimaginable pressure). But there's no point in asking a lad who doesn't fancy it. 

Under no circumstances would I want to see a penalty like the one that Notts County lad took in their final shootout. I'd make it clear to the players that you pick a spot and put your foot through the fucker. I'd rather see a player miss the target by blazing it over than seeing it saved by a GK who hasn't had to move because you've tried being a smart ass by attempting a chip or a soft rolled shot down the middle.

Yours in undoubted penalty knowledge (I've missed plenty in my time!).

I tried that in the one and only penalty shootout i was involved in. Put the ball down, walked back 5 paces, ran up and absolutely leathered the fecker. Never felt the ball on my foot i hit it that true. Unfortunately it hit the crossbar smack on, and the ball rebounded so far i could have caught it. Big Grin

Didn't matter anyway because we ended up winning the shootout, and a place in the prestigious Sandwell District 4 Cup Final.

Nothing like hitting wood just after the semi, though.