WBAUnofficial
Today - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Today (/showthread.php?tid=29420)

Pages: 1 2 3


Today - MancBaggie - 04-01-2023

Tough game today against a very cynical but effective Millwall side. I don’t think we were particularly negative but made poor final ball decisions and didn’t get enough shots off.  We just haven’t got that much quality - esp with a stretched squad.  3 different managers and the same results. 

Marks 

Griffiths. 7.5 some good stops second half and used the ball well. Unconvincing with one 2nd half that might have dropped in. 

Furlong 6.  Solid enough at the back.  Just nowhere near enough quality going forward 

CT 6.5. Battled well and tried to get forward. Difficult spell with Burke mid 2 half

Pieters. 7.5. Clearly carrying injuries. Absolutely gave every bit of effort.  Tried to play forward

Semi 7. One huge error but won it back.  Decent shift today and tried to bring it out

Okay 7.5.  Solid game and showed his touch and class a few times.  Looked leggy again and hope only a minor knock

Chalobah. 6. Clearly playing with an injury and struggled from 10 min in. Poor passing but battled and got a head or foot in defending the many set pieces 

Swift 6. Decent first half - appalling second. Terrible giveaway and then got done easily by ex ding Saville. .  Needs to produce more shots and final balls

Jed 5.5. Looked fazed playing against Millwall. Anonymous for an hour and didn’t even show - criminal given his ability.  Much more himself late on

Reach. 5.5. Effort is there and involved first half.  No pace and bang average.  

BTA 7 quiet and didn’t ask questions first 45.  Useful outlet and running 2 half. Important player for us

Dike 7. Made a difference and played full tilt. Unlucky not to get more decisions from that utter dickhead of a ref

TGH 7. Got on the ball and influenced the game as quarterback.  Should of started tbf

Albrighton 6 Steady enough when we switched to RWB

Rogic 6.5. Decent cameo and good touches. Really should of got that shot off on 90 min.  That’s what he’s good at


RE: Today - Dumbo - 04-01-2023

Spot on lad. As with most teams that have come up the Hawthorns this season, really didn’t think much of Millwall. Cynical, long ball shite. But came for a draw and got one. With the other results going our way, massive dropped points.

Yok and BTA our standouts for me.


RE: Today - TartanRug - 04-01-2023

Good assessment. Biggest problem for me was our main creative players Wallace and especially 2nd half Swift just didn't perform today


RE: Today - MancBaggie - 04-01-2023

(04-01-2023, 08:15 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Good assessment. Biggest problem for me was our main creative players Wallace and especially 2nd half Swift just didn't perform today

That was the main issue with the players who were available today.  

He could of started TGH and might have hooked Reach earlier.  

Wallace is POTY so far but thought he was utterly anonymous for large parts today


RE: Today - Jerry - 04-01-2023

Did Semi win one header during the game?


RE: Today - Man from delmonte - 04-01-2023

Agree with most of that. It was a very odd game. Barely any incident but I suppose because of the importance it just seemed to flash by. It was obviously far more important for us to gain 3 points than for Millwall. They were fairly happy with a point but if it was a boxing match I think they would have won.

I thought Griffiths was excellent again. Ajayi is both frustrating and gives the ball away but has sufficient talent, pace and bloody long legs to regain the ball. I think some of today's comments on Chalobah are harsh. As I've said elsewhere, I thought he was good today. Pleased to see Carlos gave it a go and played Dike and BTA together. He's a flexible and thoughtful manager. I really like that.

Negatives: Wallace was crap today. I think he tried too hard. The rule of the ex-player never seems to go for us. As for Reach, I know there was a thread on here a couple of weeks a go praising him but he is so mediocre it's untrue. I wouldn't have an issue with him if he was a kid filling in or a stop-gap on a short term deal. However, we're paying 20k a week for 3 years for a guy who's greatest achievement so far at the club is he's sort of reliable and is capable of not being completely incompetent in a few positions. I imagine he would be one of, if not the highest paid player at Millwall or Luton. A shining example of the incompetency of our recruit system in recent years.


RE: Today - MancBaggie - 04-01-2023

No problem with any of that DM. 

I thought JW was simply fazed playing against his old team mates. I don’t think he demanded or got on the ball enough. Tbf he did well last 15 when he finally made himself space and ran at the LB


RE: Today - Mr Nimbus - 04-01-2023

(04-01-2023, 08:32 PM)Jerry Wrote: Did Semi win one header during the game?

Yep, numerous.


RE: Today - rsbaggy2 - 04-01-2023

(04-01-2023, 06:34 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Tough game today against a very cynical but effective Millwall side. I don’t think we were particularly negative but made poor final ball decisions and didn’t get enough shots off.  We just haven’t got that much quality - esp with a stretched squad.  3 different managers and the same results. 

Marks 

Griffiths. 7.5 some good stops second half and used the ball well. Unconvincing with one 2nd half that might have dropped in. 

Furlong 6.  Solid enough at the back.  Just nowhere near enough quality going forward 

CT 6.5. Battled well and tried to get forward. Difficult spell with Burke mid 2 half

Pieters. 7.5. Clearly carrying injuries. Absolutely gave every bit of effort.  Tried to play forward

Semi 7. One huge error but won it back.  Decent shift today and tried to bring it out

Okay 7.5.  Solid game and showed his touch and class a few times.  Looked leggy again and hope only a minor knock

Chalobah. 6. Clearly playing with an injury and struggled from 10 min in. Poor passing but battled and got a head or foot in defending the many set pieces 

Swift 6. Decent first half - appalling second. Terrible giveaway and then got done easily by ex ding Saville. .  Needs to produce more shots and final balls

Jed 5.5. Looked fazed playing against Millwall. Anonymous for an hour and didn’t even show - criminal given his ability.  Much more himself late on

Reach. 5.5. Effort is there and involved first half.  No pace and bang average.  

BTA 7 quiet and didn’t ask questions first 45.  Useful outlet and running 2 half. Important player for us

Dike 7. Made a difference and played full tilt. Unlucky not to get more decisions from that utter dickhead of a ref

TGH 7. Got on the ball and influenced the game as quarterback.  Should of started tbf

Albrighton 6 Steady enough when we switched to RWB

Rogic 6.5. Decent cameo and good touches. Really should of got that shot off on 90 min.  That’s what he’s good at
Spot on. Chalobah got better as the game wore on. May have needed this start to get going. Hopefully see a continuing progression.


RE: Today - Tom Joad - 04-01-2023

Agree with much of that, Manc. I thought Millwall made life difficult although they committed more forward than I expected (1st half) and we could have got in behind them. The ref needs a special mention, from first to last he was dire and Millwall played on it to the max. It was always going to be a tough game and how we could have done with a stroke of luck. Typical of this season, it didn't happen.  

Griffiths 7.5.   Did what was asked when called on, got up CC's nose 2nd half when not releasing the ball quick enough.
Furlong 5.     Can't fault the effort but very little quality.
Townsend 4.    I like the guy but poor yet again, even managed to make Ollie Burke look a threat late on.
Ajayi 7.     Got away with his rick and had a good game without ever looking comfortable.
Pieters 8.  Competent, effective and played like a captain despite carrying a knock. Great attitude.
Okay 7. 5  Difficult game when you're not allowed to tackle. That tackle that did for him was technically fair, but a yellow all day these days.
Chalobah 6.   Started great and faded. there is quality there, I just hope there is desire too.
Jed 5.      Did not see this coming, a first ever anonymous game. Did once almost make something happen but not at it today.
Reach 5.    Can't fault the effort but little to no quality.
Swift 6.    A game of two halves for him, some sublime passes 1st half and kamikaze passing 2nd.
BTA 7.     Always trying, some great turns, could have been awarded 20 free kicks by a capable ref.

Dike 7   What a sub to have! Unlucky, great effort.
TGH 7   Should have started or at least been on at HT.
Rogic 6.  Worth chucking on, definite quality there.
Albrighton 6.  Did OK.

Came out of the ground both furious and frustrated. A fair result I'd say, but I never, ever, want to see Gary Rowett mentioned in connection with being Albion's manager. I don't care how efficient he may be.