WBAUnofficial
Thoughts - GK - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Thoughts - GK (/showthread.php?tid=27631)

Pages: 1 2


Thoughts - GK - ColliersWoodBaggie - 11-13-2022

I think the improvement in defence has a lot to do with the introduction of Palmer, who may well be a slightly unsung hero at the moment. I don't want to slag Button off, as there is a feel good factor returning, but we do need to remember threat some of the early season draws and loss at Blackburn might be down to him and the lack of confidence, which I think the defence had in the keeper. 

Button - 12 games, 1 clean sheet. (v Cardiff who came for a point). 
Palmer - 9 League games and 2 Cup Games - 6 Clean Sheets. 

In the League games Palmer has played, he's certainly improved in his own games week on week. Only major error cost s a point v Millwall. 
4 wins and a draw in 9 games with AP in goal. Better than the previous 12 games. 

Perhaps defence coaching will also help Button; although he's limited, he wasn't helped by na  lack of planning or strategy.


RE: Thoughts - GK - Calgary_Baggie - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 12:31 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think the improvement in defence has a lot to do with the introduction of Palmer, who may well be a slightly unsung hero at the moment. I don't want to slag Button off, as there is a feel good factor returning, but we do need to remember threat some of the early season draws and loss at Blackburn might be down to him and the lack of confidence, which I think the defence had in the keeper. 

Button - 12 games, 1 clean sheet. (v Cardiff who came for a point). 
Palmer - 9 League games and 2 Cup Games - 6 Clean Sheets. 

In the League games Palmer has played, he's certainly improved in his own games week on week. Only major error cost s a point v Millwall. 
4 wins and a draw in 9 games with AP in goal. Better than the previous 12 games. 

Perhaps defence coaching will also help Button; although he's limited, he wasn't helped by na  lack of planning or strategy.

No, Button needs to leave. Not even good enough to a a number 2 keeper. Surely he's shown that?


RE: Thoughts - GK - ColliersWoodBaggie - 11-13-2022

I seem to think so too (I do think we need a better number 2 to challenge AP) but perhaps he could respond to better coaching and organisation.


RE: Thoughts - GK - SW4Baggie - 11-13-2022

Button has won promotion from this division and played - sporadically - in the PL.

I think Palmer has to be the undisputed number 1 now, but I wont write off Button as cover until he’s played a couple games under CC.


RE: Thoughts - GK - Squid - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 12:50 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Button has won promotion from this division and played - sporadically - in the PL.

I think Palmer has to be the undisputed number 1 now, but I wont write off Button as cover until he’s played a couple games under CC.

Button was absolutely diabolical in the Under 23s on Monday. Shockingly, atrociously bad. I would not be at all surprised to see another GK come in during January, because the thought of having Button in goal for a first-team match match is terrifying.


RE: Thoughts - GK - SW4Baggie - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 01:02 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-13-2022, 12:50 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Button has won promotion from this division and played - sporadically - in the PL.

I think Palmer has to be the undisputed number 1 now, but I wont write off Button as cover until he’s played a couple games under CC.

Button was absolutely diabolical in the Under 23s on Monday. Shockingly, atrociously bad. I would not be at all surprised to see another GK come in during January, because the thought of having Button in goal for a first-team match match is terrifying.

I’m not sure how much time the U23s have had to buy into CC’s methods.

Agree I expect us to be looking, but we are lumbered with Button on a very decent, and very lengthy contract… with Bruce and his team’s payoff, I’m not sure how much wiggle room Carlos has.


RE: Thoughts - GK - Dumbo - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 12:31 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think the improvement in defence has a lot to do with the introduction of Palmer, who may well be a slightly unsung hero at the moment. I don't want to slag Button off, as there is a feel good factor returning, but we do need to remember threat some of the early season draws and loss at Blackburn might be down to him and the lack of confidence, which I think the defence had in the keeper. 

Button - 12 games, 1 clean sheet. (v Cardiff who came for a point). 
Palmer - 9 League games and 2 Cup Games - 6 Clean Sheets. 

Blackpool only came for a point also. Arguably so did Stoke yesterday. It’s only fair to say, if you’re saying that about Buttons clean sheet. 

That’s said….Button is awful.


RE: Thoughts - GK - oldun - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 01:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-13-2022, 12:31 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think the improvement in defence has a lot to do with the introduction of Palmer, who may well be a slightly unsung hero at the moment. I don't want to slag Button off, as there is a feel good factor returning, but we do need to remember threat some of the early season draws and loss at Blackburn might be down to him and the lack of confidence, which I think the defence had in the keeper. 

Button - 12 games, 1 clean sheet. (v Cardiff who came for a point). 
Palmer - 9 League games and 2 Cup Games - 6 Clean Sheets. 

Blackpool only came for a point also. Arguably so did Stoke yesterday. It’s only fair to say, if you’re saying that about Buttons clean sheet. 

That’s said….Button is awful.
He looks to be growing in confidence week by week, good kicking yesterday, 1 pass to Furlong was perfect, decent tip over save, also a nice catch on the penalty spot to relieve the pressure late on.


RE: Thoughts - GK - Jacko - 11-13-2022

Palmer is clearly the better keeper, but it's fair to say he's playing in a much more organised team.


RE: Thoughts - GK - TETLEY74 - 11-13-2022

(11-13-2022, 02:27 PM)oldun Wrote:
(11-13-2022, 01:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(11-13-2022, 12:31 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: I think the improvement in defence has a lot to do with the introduction of Palmer, who may well be a slightly unsung hero at the moment. I don't want to slag Button off, as there is a feel good factor returning, but we do need to remember threat some of the early season draws and loss at Blackburn might be down to him and the lack of confidence, which I think the defence had in the keeper. 

Button - 12 games, 1 clean sheet. (v Cardiff who came for a point). 
Palmer - 9 League games and 2 Cup Games - 6 Clean Sheets. 

Blackpool only came for a point also. Arguably so did Stoke yesterday. It’s only fair to say, if you’re saying that about Buttons clean sheet. 

That’s said….Button is awful.
He looks to be growing in confidence week by week, good kicking yesterday, 1 pass to Furlong was perfect, decent tip over save, also a nice catch on the penalty spot to relieve the pressure late on.

Definitely seems like another determined to seize his chance and prove a point, well done lad.