![]() |
|
Ratings and thoughts - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Ratings and thoughts (/showthread.php?tid=27222) Pages:
1
2
|
Ratings and thoughts - Lurker#3 - 10-18-2022 Thoughts... Hang over from Brucie is evident. Absolutely no blame attached the Beale. The back 3 were fucking pathetic. Never had the bollocks to get high enough to press and compact the game after we got caught with that ball over the top. Which ironically was because we didn't get out quick enough. After that we became too open, but not offensively. Which is a recipe for disaster. We need to either pack the team with gifted footballers and trust them to take the ball man for man, or pack it with pace and compact the game down and look to break quicker. Right now we're (and have for 12 months) doing neither. Negatives: Kelly - the main culprit for dropping too deep and caused the line to crumble for both goals. The second especially would never have happened if he was in line with Pieters and Dara. Phillips and Jake - Not because they are shit, but because we are still having to rely on them because they are 2 of the only ones that show any maturity and tactical knowledge. They just can't sustain it anymore. Both played well today for the most part though, regardless of others foaming at the mouth. Positives: Cleary and BTA - Both have pace and rawness. Need to play closer together in a 2 if they play. Swift - Passed the ball with purpose and confidence from that deep role which is where he should play. TGH - Real quality on the ball and full of running. Ratings: Palmer - 6 - Poor kicking conceded 2. Not his fault though. OShea - 5 - Partially to blame for our awful defensive line. He's the defacto Captain and needs to show leadership to get us up the pitch. Kelly - 4 - Directly at fault for the second, so slow to react and some awful passing. Pieters - 6 - Tried to get us up the pitch and some decent passing. Got caught a couple of times in the air. Phillips - 6 - Started really well and took the ball under pressure and kept it. Ran out of steam. But at 33 it's hardly surprising. Jake - 6 - See above. Both are not the issue some make them out to be. TGH - 6 - Some great ability on the ball and drive. But does vacate his position quite alot and rarely screened the defense when they kept rolling the ball into Wells. Townsend - 6 - Better, but pisses me off whe. He gets too safe and square. But that's cause he's a full back and not a wing back. Wallace - 6 - Works his bollocks off but was dog shit in possession today. BTA - 7 - Really worked hard and stretched them, but hindered by how deep we were and the gaps between the midfield and him. Grady - 5 - The best we've got, but like Sessegnon, when we're not playing well, he will never drag us to a result single handedly. Would have left him on when he added Cleary to the attack though as Grady plays better when we support him. Subs: Cleary - 7 - Stretched them, shot, crossed, backed in. Caused problems. Should start next game. Swift - 7 - Passed accurately and purposefully. Streets ahead of all our midfielders on the ball. Rogic - 6 - Showed glimpses. Molumby - 6 - Tried, didn't improve us, just replaced Jake's effort. RE: Ratings and thoughts - wba13 - 10-18-2022 I’m sorry but if you think Livermore and Phillips were ok you were at another match to me.Livermore needless booking and terrible defending for the first goal. Phillips great chance to equalise and missed by miles.TGH was easily the best of a poor midfield. Cleary put himself about and looked decent. But we were well beaten. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Lurker#3 - 10-18-2022 (10-18-2022, 09:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: I’m sorry but if you think Livermore and Phillips were ok you were at another match to me.Livermore needless booking and terrible defending for the first goal. Phillips great chance to equalise and missed by miles.TGH was easily the best of a poor midfield. Cleary put himself about and looked decent. But we were well beaten. I wasn't at the match, I was watching it from my armchair on holiday in the Algarve. Supping a delicious Super Bock stout. Much warmer. Phillips didn't have a great chance. He had 2 players up his trumpet and if his shot was on target it would have been blocked. Jake pressed fantastically for 35 mins but nobody went with him and he visibly got frustrated. TGH looks great and has a great future. But need to learn his trade in one position, that should be CM but he shouldn't be starting every game yet. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Logic1 - 10-18-2022 BTA rating of 7 lol. The guy is a League 2 striker. The fact he is in our team just shows how much we have fallen. He's useless and we even have a song for him! RE: Ratings and thoughts - wba13 - 10-18-2022 Sorry but your wrong even the other threads are stating how bad they were. They cannot play 2 games in a few days. Good for you being on holiday I would much rather be watching us live. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Lurker#3 - 10-18-2022 (10-18-2022, 09:45 PM)wba13 Wrote: Sorry but your wrong even the other threads are stating how bad they were. They cannot play 2 games in a few days. Good for you being on holiday I would much rather be watching us live. I hope you enjoyed your evening, wba13, lad. (10-18-2022, 09:45 PM)Logic1 Wrote: BTA rating of 7 lol. The guy is a League 2 striker. The fact he is in our team just shows how much we have fallen. He's useless and we even have a song for him! I think he's got all the tools but really raw. What has suprised me the most is his ability to hold the ball up. His touch is good. And he regularly makes the right runs, even if his timing is somewhat off at time.s but that will come quickly given the right coaching. It's a shame we haven't got a Super Kev for him to learn off in training. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Cuzer - 10-18-2022 I think you're bob on about our back three ,it's comical how as a club we've loaned our Kipre and somehow eneded up with Erik Pieters and Martin Kelly in our back line, Taylor and Kipre would improve our back three and dare I say it Captain Shitbeard, training like a Demon apparently, should be back in at Milwall IMO, centre halves play centre half, Peters or Kelly are not centre halves, they are plug the gaps short term So so poor tonight and so typical Albion, I always wonder how Pearson is still in a job, takes Bristol City nowehere every season despite a decent budget but one thing about them, they play for him, off the back of a defeat Saturday they were bang at it tonight and frankly that was more than enough against our primadonna's Were putting balls into the box for strikers who can't win headers, so learn to play through the lines, rocket science it ain't! You could see tonights Bristol's system nullified ours and carried more threat, 70 minutes I think we changed the shape was it? Very poor on Beale and clan's game management Palmer 5 - Looked shaky, one woeful kick but little chance with goals Phillips 4 - Couldn't get forward against City's shape and their wing backs so basically offered little, decent chance begging but did at least seem to try but he's not got 2 x 90's in him in the space of 3 days, Beale should have known this Townsend 3 - Stealing a living, I think he's trying, he's just looking like a League One defender more and more each day, no competition so being average to poor gets him a game every week O'Shea 3 - Leader my arse, so soft for a CH, take the game by the scruff of the neck FFS, lets the ball bounce, not vocal enough, the list goes on, our back 3 made the City forwards look like Shearer and Sutton.......... Kelly 3 - Games in short space of time caught up with him here, at fault for 2nd and slow all night, again how he's playing in our XI with Taylor, Kipre not here makes you lost for words Pieters 3 - Should be at left back to make us more solid, Townsend needs a rest and playing LCH isn't working Livermore 3 - At fault for first, always on a tightrope after yellow, rightly hooked but in hindsight should have sat this one out TGH 6* Only midfielder we have, central midfielder, who actually tries to go forward, the innocence of youth I guess, not at his best by any stretch but better than the rest Grady 3 - Went missing after 15 minutes, didn't seem up for it at all, very disappointing Wallace 2 - Shocking, at fault for 2nd, pissing about in the wrong area then not closing down, never beat Dasilva all night, looked miles off it, he's been one of the few bright spots this season but was shocking tonight IMO BTA 3 - He works hard, you have to give him that, Grant is bone fucking idle so that gets him in on merit, the pathetically bizarre decision to sell Robinson and not replace him looks more barmy with every passing second Subs Moloumby 4 - Usual energy and running around with an array of sidewards passing, bottom half Championship footballer, which suits us perfectly Cleary 4 - Didn't go for him and lost his footing on a few occasions but kept on till the end and had the beating of his man time and time again in the last 10, those of us who watch him week in, week out, in the stiffs know he's not the finished article but needs to stick around the squad as gives us something Rogic 3 - Nice touches, tidy player but this isn't a 5 a side game, not fit, slow, ponderous, one footed, shows how bad the Pub League is in Scotland if this guy is the messiah, can he play? Yes, does he want to bust a gut to play this side of the World Cup? Not a chance, more ingenius transfer dealings by our rabble Swift 4 - Looked a bit more interested tonight, unlucky with late shot which hit the crossbar, as mentioned elsewhere deserves a go playing deeper This would be my team for Milwall Palmer Furlong Bartley O'Shea Pieters Okay Swift TGH Wallace BTA Grady Back 4 more defensive, TGH to do the running in midfield with Okay and Swift dictating the tempo, Grady and Wallace making it a 5 without the ball, as per Norwich, but breaking when we have it with pace, BTA to work for 60 minutes before Grant/Cleary coming on Milwall are no shakes but we must defend set pieces and long balls against them, Flemming is a player so by having Okay and Swift a little deeper we shoudl nullify his threat After tonight, frankly bar TGH they all could be dropped Cuzer RE: Ratings and thoughts - Dumbo - 10-18-2022 TGH - decent. The rest - shite. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Lurker#3 - 10-18-2022 (10-18-2022, 10:28 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I think you're bob on about our back three ,it's comical how as a club we've loaned our Kipre and somehow eneded up with Erik Pieters and Martin Kelly in our back line, Taylor and Kipre would improve our back three and dare I say it Captain Shitbeard, training like a Demon apparently, should be back in at Milwall IMO, centre halves play centre half, Peters or Kelly are not centre halves, they are plug the gaps short term We saw it similar mate. Just your ratings are perhaps a touch angrier. My start XI would be. Palmer Okay OShea Livermore Phillips Swift TGH Grady Wallace Cleary BTA But I am aware that it'll never happen. Squeeze the game right up. Having Jake and Okay in the back line would help. Use the front three pace and running power along with TGH to press high. And try and spring Grady in the pockets. RE: Ratings and thoughts - Calgary_Baggie - 10-18-2022 (10-18-2022, 09:24 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Thoughts... Hang over from Brucie is evident. Absolutely no blame attached the Beale. Absolutely no blame attached to Beal. Lol. |