WBAUnofficial
The failed experiment... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The failed experiment... (/showthread.php?tid=27096)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


The failed experiment... - Lurker#3 - 10-12-2022

.. of hoping an out of date, out of touch manager is finally over. 

Good to read were looking for a long term manager with a decent vision for how the club will progress. Just hope the new guy, IF he is showing decent signs, gets the time needed.


RE: The failed experiment... - MassDebater - 10-12-2022

Time and a club in possible financial trouble that needs promotion, oft do not go together. Another season down here and next year we could be anywhere from 6th to 21st...
2 seasons, 2 failed experiments.


RE: The failed experiment... - baggie_ray - 10-12-2022

Wasn't this what Ken said about Val?

Fact is, there are no guarantees that any manager will succeed, short term or long term. If the club want the next big thing, they need to know that manager intrinsically which, ideally, means we should have been monitoring candidates since the Summer at least (as Bruce was out of contract this coming Summer).

Otherwise, like most clubs, we'll be going for a manager with recent success in the lower divisions. Providing we will pay the compensation.

I really really hope that Gourlay's plan was, in appointing Bruce (as a stop gap), he would have the breathing space to conduct due diligence on the next manager.

Or are we really really fucked?


RE: The failed experiment... - Sliced - 10-12-2022

One “failed experiment” had us in 5th, the other left us in 22nd.

I just hope that if we hire a manager who shows he can get something out of the team then we learn from our mistakes and give them a chance to turn it around if things go sour.


I say that, I reckon we’ll have to, we can’t afford to sack another one!


RE: The failed experiment... - SW4Baggie - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:02 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Wasn't this what Ken said about Val?

Fact is, there are no guarantees that any manager will succeed, short term or long term. If the club want the next big thing, they need to know that manager intrinsically which, ideally, means we should have been monitoring candidates since the Summer at least (as Bruce was out of contract this coming Summer).

Otherwise, like most clubs, we'll be going for a manager with recent success in the lower divisions. Providing we will pay the compensation.

I really really hope that Gourlay's plan was, in appointing Bruce (as a stop gap), he would have the breathing space to conduct due diligence on the next manager.

Or are we really really fucked?

LOL!

This is a CEO who appointed a manager with no interview and was considering promoting Ian Pearce whilst admitting our scouting system is players he and Bruce know about... 

The man's only plans are dinner reservations.


RE: The failed experiment... - Ted Maul - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: One “failed experiment” had us in 5th, the other left us in 22nd.

I just hope that if we hire a manager who shows he can get something out of the team then we learn from our mistakes and give them a chance to turn it around if things go sour.


I say that, I reckon we’ll have to, we can’t afford to sack another one!

We've wasted whatever advantage we did have. I don't buy the parachute money is everything argument, with proper coaching teams can come from nowhere in this league. See Forest last season. I predicted over the summer that the relegated sides wouldn't be anything to worry about and they're not, we've just shot ourselves in the foot by keeping hold of Bruce for a quarter of the season. Get it right off the pitch and it will fall into place on it. A change of manager is one step, but I worry everything we try will fail under Gourlay and Lai.


RE: The failed experiment... - Spandaubaggie - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: One “failed experiment” had us in 5th, the other left us in 22nd.

I just hope that if we hire a manager who shows he can get something out of the team then we learn from our mistakes and give them a chance to turn it around if things go sour.


I say that, I reckon we’ll have to, we can’t afford to sack another one!

We've had 2 shit appointments, but your line about 5th with Val is completely out of context with what was happening with Val. For the millionth time by numerous posters we did not finish 5th under Val and he was sacked because we had shown bottom 6 for for 3 months and he was not arresting the slide.
Bruce came in as the wheels had come off and he couldn't put them back on keeping similar abject form.

You are certainly right with your last line about making sure owe don't sack this guy(or gal) if Soph gets his way with the appointment!


RE: The failed experiment... - baggie_ray - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:20 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 08:02 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Wasn't this what Ken said about Val?

Fact is, there are no guarantees that any manager will succeed, short term or long term. If the club want the next big thing, they need to know that manager intrinsically which, ideally, means we should have been monitoring candidates since the Summer at least (as Bruce was out of contract this coming Summer).

Otherwise, like most clubs, we'll be going for a manager with recent success in the lower divisions. Providing we will pay the compensation.

I really really hope that Gourlay's plan was, in appointing Bruce (as a stop gap), he would have the breathing space to conduct due diligence on the next manager.

Or are we really really fucked?

LOL!

This is a CEO who appointed a manager with no interview and was considering promoting Ian Pearce whilst admitting our scouting system is players he and Bruce know about... 

The man's only plans are dinner reservations.

Yep, if Gourlay has basically been sat on his arse regarding this then he has been stealing a living and should be sacked for gross negligence.

We are a professional football club in the second tier of the pyramid, recently down from the first. We should not be looking through the CVs of the applicants. We should know them anyway. We should have been sounding out replacements in the run up to Bruce's sacking, if we knew that there was a possibility we would be sacking Bruce.

I've been quite placid over the Bruce position but I'm getting more and more annoyed over the thought that we might not have had any fall back position for when he left.


RE: The failed experiment... - SW4Baggie - 10-12-2022

(10-12-2022, 08:32 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-12-2022, 08:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: One “failed experiment” had us in 5th, the other left us in 22nd.

I just hope that if we hire a manager who shows he can get something out of the team then we learn from our mistakes and give them a chance to turn it around if things go sour.


I say that, I reckon we’ll have to, we can’t afford to sack another one!

We've had 2 shit appointments, but your line about 5th with Val is completely out of context with what was happening with Val. For the millionth time by numerous posters we did not finish 5th under Val and he was sacked because we had shown bottom 6 for for 3 months and he was not arresting the slide.
Bruce came in as the wheels had come off and he couldn't put them back on keeping similar abject form.

You are certainly right with your last line about making sure owe don't sack this guy(or gal) if Soph gets his way with the appointment!

I must have missed how we didn't get promoted under Bilic for finishing 2nd despite showing bottom 6 form in our last 10 games.


RE: The failed experiment... - Birdman1811 - 10-12-2022

Table doesn't ever lie. We were 5th. That is a fact, no spinning changes that.

Until players totally lost faith (he carries blame for that too) we were a finisher away from winning the vast majority of games, losing Dike so early was probably what finished him to be honest.