![]() |
|
EV's pro's & con's - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: EV's pro's & con's (/showthread.php?tid=26292) Pages:
1
2
|
EV's pro's & con's - Remi_Moses - 08-26-2022 What's the general feelings on EV's. Expensive to purchase Greener, is charging suppler calculated in I wonder. Has charging fees gone up with utility increases. Disposal charges at EOL and environmental issues. Charging points. Distance on full charge issues. Huge reduction in distance when towing. How and where do you charge if towing a caravan. RE: EV's pro's & con's - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-26-2022 I'm not convinced that the mad dash towards EVs has been properly costed out, either economically or environmentally. Electricity has to be generated somehow - construction costs for wind farms are huge, while many parts of Europe still burn brown coal in power stations without flue gas de-sulphurisation or carbon capture. Electricity has to be distributed - what is the environmental impact of mining copper for cable? Batteries are full of rare earth minerals, which are notoriously messy to process in manufacture and disposal. The infrastructure isn't in place yet. I wouldn't have contemplated my recent road trip to Denmark in an EV. E10 gasoline or B7 diesel are available at every stop from Cheshire East to Copenhagen and back. As with all things, EVs are part of but not the whole answer. I don't think hybrids should be discounted, I don't think old but functional cars should be scrapped and replaced by new EVs. If I needed a new car purely for local use I'd consider an EV. As things stand, we'll stick with the 2 year old petrol SUV and the 10 year old diesel hatch and see what happens when it's time to change. RE: EV's pro's & con's - MassDebater - 08-26-2022 EVs are a no go if you live in a house with no drive. Always seems to get ignored, probably by the mcw types who look at EVs and therefore have drives. RE: EV's pro's & con's - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-26-2022 Happy with my straight 6 petrol delivering 40 to the gallon on a 250 mile round trip on Wednesday, driven sensibly. There needs to be a solution but EV isn't it. I think it's hydrogen. RE: EV's pro's & con's - SausEggBaton - 08-27-2022 Loads of Hamsters, loads of wheel cages, done. RE: EV's pro's & con's - Lurker#3 - 08-27-2022 We have our 8 seater MPV / weekend camper, which is a 1.6 diesel as there's no real EV/Hybrid option. We are replacing our 'run around' next year and will no doubt go EV as the most we would ever do in a day is 100 miles. The future should be hydrogen, or even a Hydrogen/EV Hybrid. As I think we will always like to put liquid in a tank as it's convenient. RE: EV's pro's & con's - Pipes of Peace - 08-27-2022 Had A leaf for a while. Was a nightmare. Range too low. Impossible to use outside of localish trips. Always arguing or long waits over public charging points. This country isn’t ready unless you have long range and have decent home charging. I’ll wait a couple more years but the infrastructure doesn’t look like it’s really getting better. RE: EV's pro's & con's - BurleyBaggie - 08-27-2022 I’ve had an EV for 18 months, Polestar 2, best decision I’ve ever made. On Octopus Go so get 28kw/h of charge per night for about £2.50. That’s about 95 miles…the Polestar range is 240 miles city and 200 miles motorway on spring summer. I’d do your research, but consider energy efficiency of an petrol engine is c37% while gas fired power stations are nearer 60%. So even if your power is generated by fossil fuel it’s still better for the environment than micro generation (an internal combustion engine) and less CO2 is produced per mile. It’s true there are rare earth metals and mining concerns on batteries but there is a huge rise in recycling EV batteries and a high percentage of them can be reused. In addition new batteries (BMW are forward in this) are starting to move away from materials that are causing the most environmental damage. We have a home charger and a fair amount of local rapid chargers. We drive 240 miles to SE London from Orpington to visit the in laws and have no issues. It’s a 4/5hr journey with a baby. So we drive 2.5/3 hours, plug it in, have a coffee and feed the little one and 40 minutes later we are in our way. The devil for me (and again there’s some great articles on this) are Plug in Hybrid Electric Vehicles. They advertise say 200mpg but is a falsehood. That’s only ever achievable while the car has charge but the batteries are small c10kw/h so on pure electric about 40miles. Even in combined mode they run out over a long journey - why is this bad? Well it’s about mass: you are literally carrying about an engine as per a normal car, but also an electric motor, ancillaries and a heavy battery pack. So when you’re out of elections your mpg is worse than a standard petrol car. The choice, and to be fair the facts you want to believe, is yours. But we love our EV, that said if it doesn’t work for you get a small turbo petrol rather than a hybrid. RE: EV's pro's & con's - HawkingsHalfpint - 08-27-2022 Drove a client’s Tesla a few years back when they were still fairly new. He didn’t like it, nor did I much if I’m honest. He told me he was giving it to someone who worked for him as a company car. It was fast, and quite smart inside, but for all the extras and luxury I couldn’t help feeling it was America does nouveau riche (odd that). Impressive in a way I suppose, but not for me. Not long after, the genius but somewhat flighty guy I was working for decided one day he would launch his own one man tax-avoidance crusade against HMRC (some people really, really hate paying tax, and have incredibly strange and varied reasons why), and chopped his Mondeo (he was quite tight for a wealthy bloke) for a Nissan iMiev. It was the ugliest, shittiest little thing I’ve ever seen. He looked like a little bumble bee when he was shoehorned into it, and they was he drove it about (in some sort of bravado ‘look at me, this car is as good and fast as yours, it doesn’t matter that I look like a legoland baggage handler’) not much less irritating. It took an age to charge, and after a year or two you were lucky to get 35 miles out of the useless sack of lithium ion shite. The battery had to be changed not long after, and eventually the whole car, and by the time he retired and I took over, I then had a shite car to offload because he didn’t want to look like a twat anymore for the sake of paying less tax. So the best we could get anyone to offer is for it was about £2k. A really shite investment. Dunno what I’ll get next, currently have a diesel A5 that I should change but I really like it and don’t drive that much except to the office and to Somerset and back. Was gonna go for something similarly sporty but maybe hybrid, but after all this global energy bollocks I’m not sure the grids are going to be ready to support all these new EVs by 2030. Not when we’re talking about brownouts now. Quite happy to keep driving what I have for a bit because we’ve seen false drivetrain dawns before. It will of course all happen, but we need a lot more onshore windmills or Hunterstone and Dungeness Cs before it all works as it should. Oh and this totally ignores that fact that it would all be waaaaaaaaaaay more efficient if modern cars worked like trams or scalextrics, and didn’t have 2 tonnes of rare earth to lug around wherever you go (really efficient, that). Even Elon knows that. RE: EV's pro's & con's - BurleyBaggie - 08-27-2022 EVs have come along way since the days of sub 100 Mile range and slow charging. At DC Charger I can get 180 miles of range in 25 minutes… …the wind farm and renewable point that keeps cropping up perplexes me. So it’s ok to generate more CO2 per mile from your engine at a much lower energy efficiency than it is to consume electricity which at any point in time is a mix of 3-85% renewable and is generated at a much higher energy efficiency ie better for the environment. I take the point on rare earth metals, though that’s becoming moot, the high cost of initial ownership and the need for better infrastructure - it’s the range/charging/electricity generation I struggle to see. |