![]() |
|
VAR again!!!!!!. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: VAR again!!!!!!. (/showthread.php?tid=25456) Pages:
1
2
|
VAR again!!!!!!. - Shabby Russian - 06-08-2022 What is the point of this, apart from to irritate me. Wales v Ukraine a very clear penalty for Ukraine ignored...in a game which really mattered. Germany v England, a far less clear penalty incident and they get involved...in a game of far less importance. I didn't see the play off final, but apparently Huddersfield were denied at least one penalty, again in a very important game. VAR was introduced to provide greater certainty in applying the rules of the game, but it seems to have only added another layer of uncertainty. I am convinced that how var is used comes down to the character and experience of individual referees. Some onfield refs appear to avoid making on field decisions, expecting var to bail them out if they have missed something. And some var refs seem wary of changing the decisions of more experienced refs, even when it is clear they have made a mistake. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Sliced - 06-08-2022 The Huddersfield v Forest ones were absolutely ridiculous. One of the most obvious penalties I've ever seen seemingly wasn't even checked and another blatant one that 99 out of 100 people would have said definite penalty and the 1 was the VAR guy who didn't want to embarrass John Moss on his last day. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Duffers - 06-08-2022 I always thought VAR was meant to address “clear and obvious” errors, where the referee has clearly missed something. For me that still leaves rooms for different interpretations and even potential mistakes. What we have now is everything being checked for every possible infringement, no matter how trivial. The Kane penalty last night was certainly not “clear and obvious”, having to draw lines and spends minutes analysing offsides to the millimetre is not “clear and obvious”. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - BaggieTom89 - 06-08-2022 Completely agree on the VAR front. The Huddersfield penalty claims in particular were ridiculous. I wonder if he'd have given Toffollo a further yellow if he'd made a further foul. Not only was he denied a clear penalty but he's also a defender then riding a tightrope. Madness! I also don't get the element of 'intention' with the offside rule. Benzema's disallowed goal in the Champions League final, to me it comes off Fabinho (and not a minor deflection) so to me that's onside. Last night whilst not complaining Kane looked offside to me for the penalty (did look a foul). It was never checked. The attempted through ball deflected off a German player which I'm guessing was the reason they didn't look at offside, but that was far less intentional than Fabinho! RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - baggie_ray - 06-08-2022 Football has always been a contact sport, and minimal contact does not have to mean a foul has been committed, regardless of the outcome. It annoys the hell out of me that slight contact is now judged by people as being a "clear penalty". Perhaps I'm just old school. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Pedders - 06-08-2022 What I don’t understand is the reluctunce to use the monitor at the side of the pitch. The season gone, anything being called by VAR, you know would be overturned, but why aren’t refs told…”maybe have a quick look on the monitor, and just make sure you dont want to change your mind”….then, as said above, there is still subjectivity, but at least the ref on the field gets the chance to get it more right. If Moss had been given that opportunity in the play off final, suspect he would have given at least one pen, then he also doesnt look an idiot? It is easy for the ref to say, look I didnt see that at full speed with bodies everywhere, so he can easily change his mind? It went so well at the Euros, we just seem to have got it so wrong RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Borin' Baggie - 06-08-2022 The whole system is a complete mess and fails at managing what should have been the priority - transparency. I don't know why the footballing authorities have this bizarre exceptionalism and think they can do things better, just copy the system used in rugby union. Communication being broadcast (even if not in the stadium over the TV) so people know why a decision has been made and what is being looked at and having all the referees work as a team instead of two separate teams should have been the first two things included but nope. Compare that with goal line technology where they took a proven system used in other sports and adapted it resulting in very few issues. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Brentbaggie - 06-08-2022 (06-08-2022, 10:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The whole system is a complete mess and fails at managing what should have been the priority - transparency. I think you e been warned before about bringing logic and common sense onto this website. I doubt the mods will tolerate much more of this kind of behaviour. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - Protheroe - 06-08-2022 (06-08-2022, 10:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The whole system is a complete mess and fails at managing what should have been the priority - transparency. The problem is that in rugby you can hear the players addressing the mic-ed up ref as "sir" when complaining about a decision. The audio feed from any football match would be x-rated. RE: VAR again!!!!!!. - MassDebater - 06-08-2022 (06-08-2022, 10:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The whole system is a complete mess and fails at managing what should have been the priority - transparency. TBF to footy, the goal line tech hasn't been too bad, just that one fecking time it amazingly got turned off for no reason... |