![]() |
|
Levelling Up mapping the future - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Levelling Up mapping the future (/showthread.php?tid=25299) |
Levelling Up mapping the future - Derek Hardballs - 05-18-2022 Very interesting report by Bloomberg… Let’s see if it changes RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Protheroe - 05-18-2022 The whole concept of Levelling Up is flawed and symptomatic of the current Tories' Keynesian instincts; in order to for the UK as a whole to prosper London must remain and flourish as a prime global hub, and with that comes disproportionate investment, growth, salary growth, property valuations etc. Regional Policy in the UK was responsible for turning London into the cesspit it was at the end of the 1970s. Regional Policy is a Socialist construct and if the Labour Party hadn't have fucked about with the development of the West Midlands twice, we wouldn't be in the position of needing to be levelled up. In order that you understand how to map the future, you must first understand the past. Regional Policy doesn't work. A History Lesson Up until the 1930s it had been a basic assumption of Birmingham's leaders that their role was to encourage the city's growth. Post-war national governments, however, saw Birmingham's accelerating economic success as a damaging influence on the stagnating economies of the North of England, Scotland and Wales, and saw its physical expansion as a threat to its surrounding areas – "from Westminster's point of view was too large, too prosperous, and had to be held in check". A series of measures, starting with the Distribution of Industry Act 1945, aimed to prevent industrial growth in the "Congested Areas" – essentially the booming cities of London and Birmingham – instead encouraging the dispersal of industry to the economically stagnant "Development Areas" in the north and west. The West Midlands Plan, commissioned by the Minister for Town and Country Planning from Patrick Abercrombie and Herbert Jackson in 1946, set Birmingham a target population for 1960 of 990,000, far less than its actual 1951 population of 1,113,000. This meant that 220,000 people would have to leave the city over the following 14 years, that some of the city's industries would have to be removed, and that new industries would need to be prevented from establishing themselves in the city. By 1957 the council had explicitly accepted that it was obliged "to restrain the growth of population and employment potential within the city. Birmingham itself was second only to London for the creation of new jobs between 1951 and 1961. Unemployment in Birmingham between 1948 and 1966 rarely exceeded 1%, and only exceeded 2% in one year. By 1961 household incomes in the West Midlands were 13% above the national average, exceeding even than those of London and the South East. Although employment in Birmingham's artificially restricted manufacturing sector shrank by 10% between 1951 and 1966, this was more than made up during the early post-war period for by employment in the service sector, which grew from 35% of the city's workforce in 1951 to 45% in 1966. As the commercial centre of the country's most successful regional economy, Central Birmingham was the main focus outside London for the post-war office building boom. Service sector employment in the Birmingham conurbation grew faster than in any other region between 1953 and 1964, and the same period saw 3 million sq ft of office space constructed in the city centre and Edgbaston. The city's economic boom saw the rapid growth of a substantial merchant banking sector, as major London and international banks established themselves within the city, and professional and scientific services, finance and insurance also grew particularly strongly. However this service sector growth itself attracted government restrictions from 1965. Declaring the growth in population and employment within Birmingham to be a "threatening situation", the incoming Labour Government of 1964 sought "to control the growth of office accommodation in Birmingham and the rest of the Birmingham conurbation before it got out of hand, in the same way as they control the growth of industrial employment". Although the City Council had encouraged service sector expansion during the late 1950s and early 1960s, central government extended the Control of Office Employment Act 1965 to the Birmingham conurbation from 1965, effectively banning all further office development for almost two decades.” These policies had a major structural effect on the city's economy. While government policy had limited success in preventing the growth of Birmingham's existing industries, it was much more successful in preventing new industries establishing themselves in the city. Birmingham's economic success over the previous two centuries had been built on its economic diversity and its ongoing ability to adapt and innovate – attracting new businesses and developing new industries with its large supply of skilled labour and dynamic entrepreneurial culture – but this was exactly the process that government industrial location policy sought to prevent. Birmingham's existing industries grew strongly and kept the economy buoyant, but growing local fears that the city's economy was becoming over-specialised were dismissed by central government, even though danger signs were growing by the early 1970s. In 1950 Birmingham's economy could still be described as "more broadly based than that of any city of equivalent size in the world", but by 1973 the West Midlands had an above-average reliance on large firms for employment, and the small firms that remained were increasingly dependent as suppliers and sub-contractors to the few larger firms. The "City of Thousand Trades" had become over-specialised on one industry – the motor trade – much of which by the 1970s had itself consolidated into a single company – British Leyland. Trade union organisation grew and the motor industry in particular saw industrial disputes from the 1950s onwards. A city that for most of its history had a reputation for weak trade unionism and strong cooperation between workers and management, developed a reputation for trade union militancy and industrial conflict. Be careful what you wish for. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Borin' Baggie - 05-18-2022 Regional Policy was at the very least in part a Tory idea, it was originally put into place by the National Government that was dominated by Tory MPs, it was built upon under Baldwin and Chamberlain neither of whom can be considered anything close to a socialist and successive postwar Tory governments maintained it as part of the postwar consensus. The restrictions on Birmingham (and Coventry, as the restrictions extended there as well) recommended by the West Midlands Plan were put into place by government under Churchill, Eden and Macmillan who, again, are not socialists. Don't act like it was all Labour and the socialists, it was the abandonment of municipal liberalism due to the decline of the Liberal Party and the irrelevance of remnants of the Liberal Unionists within the Tory Party. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Protheroe - 05-18-2022 You're right Keynesians dominated the political landscape from 1945 to the ascension of Dear Margaret. It's no coincidence that this period also witnessed Britain's long term industrial decline. It was Labour governments who enacted the two worst acts of vandalism on Birmingham. Can you imagine being a Brummie in 1961 earning more, on average, than a Londoner? You're right about Cov too. Without the WM plan there'd be no Rootes Group in Linwood, there'd be no Leyland plant at Speke which ruined Triumph as a marque. Both massive failures of Regional Policy and both integral to the decline of the parent companies. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Borin' Baggie - 05-18-2022 The foundations of the DIA 1945 were set by the "Special Areas Act 1934" and it's extension in 1937 - that set the precedent that led to the decline of Birmingham, Coventry and Leicester post-war - were Tory policies endorsed by Baldwin. The Conservatives held power for nearly 15 years from the 50s and declined to reverse the DIA 1945, Ted Heath even opted to bring it up as a good thing in Parliament when he was challenging for the leadership. Also, it was the Tory fuckwits in the National Government who ostracised Labour's greatest chancellor in Philip Snowden and ultimately replaced him to enable central economic planning. I would also like to point out that your "Dear Margaret" did no such good for the city of Birmingham, the rate of economic decline within the city as set during the 70s continued through to Major's premiership and it was only under Major and Blair that the turnaround actually started. I'd also like to note, given you are keen to bring up Keynesianism destroying Birmingham, that the direct precursors to Keynesianism that he build his work on - the Birmingham School and the "New Liberal" movement - are the two things responsible for Birmingham's (and in the case of the latter also Coventry's) rapid development first in the early 19th century and then in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The key difference is municipalism and regionalism vs central planning and there was only party in Parliament challenging central planning and advocating a return to municipal rights, it wasn't the Tories or Labour. I hold them both equally in contempt for screwing over the local economies of Birmingham, Coventry and Leicester in Labour's attempts to subsidise the operation of unproductive areas and the Tories attempts to subsidise London. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Protheroe - 05-18-2022 You are Chris Huhne and I claim my £5. BTW, I can't lay claim to supporting the Tory Party before Dear Margaret. I wasn't alive. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Borin' Baggie - 05-18-2022 I am literally on the complete opposite wing of the Lib Dems to what Huhne was, I also have zero points on my licence. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Protheroe - 05-18-2022 The Lib Dems have wings? Surely there’s not enough of them RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Ossian - 05-19-2022 (05-18-2022, 08:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The Lib Dems have wings? Surely there’s not enough of them There were 3.7 million of them at the 2019 election. RE: Levelling Up mapping the future - Borin' Baggie - 05-19-2022 (05-19-2022, 08:07 AM)Ossian Wrote:(05-18-2022, 08:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The Lib Dems have wings? Surely there’s not enough of them And I wasn't even one of those! |