WBAUnofficial
Central defenders - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Central defenders (/showthread.php?tid=24569)



Central defenders - YoYoBaggie - 03-12-2022

For next season ,we have six in and around the first team squad ,can see Clarke going back to Brighton and Taylor out on loan leaving us with this seasons lot of Bartley Ajayi ,Kipre ,and O'Shea as all of these are still in contract .Do we need reinforcements  in this area or will that be enough .?


RE: Central defenders - Gzbaggy - 03-12-2022

you have missed Bryan, who will probably be injured anyway. We also have Livermore and Reach who can play there


RE: Central defenders - Sliced - 03-12-2022

Yeah that’s the one area where we’re absolutely fine.


RE: Central defenders - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-12-2022

(03-12-2022, 01:41 PM)Sliced Wrote: Yeah that’s the one area where we’re absolutely fine.

Yes, that came across loud and clear yesterday  Big Grin


RE: Central defenders - SW4Baggie - 03-12-2022

(03-12-2022, 01:37 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: you have missed Bryan, who will probably be injured anyway. We also have Livermore and Reach who can play there

We need to look to improve wide areas too, so I would imagine both Furlong and Townsend could be options in a back 3 also, especially with Phillips being an option at RWB during August and September next season. 

Considering how poorly our squad is performing, we don’t need much this summer.  Some legs and creativity in midfield, and a couple of wingbacks, and depending what happens with the goalies, maybe another one for cover.

GK: Palmer, Griffiths

CB: Bryan, Bartley, Kipré, O’Shea, Ajayi  (Furlong, Townsend, Livermore, Taylor, Reach)

LWB: Reach, Townsend

RWB: Furlong, PhillipS (TGH, Ingram)

MC: Livermore, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, (Molumby?) 

ML: Reach, Grady, Robinson 

MR: Phillips, Grady, TGH,

ATK: Grant, Robinson, Dike, Zohore (Phillips, Carroll) 

Resigning Carroll feels a no brainier at the moment but I’d wait ‘til the summer and see what his demands are.

If we could move Bartley, Phillips, Zohore, Reach on that would be great - even if it was on loan with us subsidising… it would free some cash up to hopefully bring in 3-4 players who can improve in the areas we are so obviously short.


RE: Central defenders - Hopalong - 03-12-2022

(03-12-2022, 01:05 PM)YoYoBaggie Wrote: For next season ,we have six in and around the first team squad ,can see Clarke going back to Brighton and Taylor out on loan leaving us with this seasons lot of Bartley Ajayi ,Kipre ,and O'Shea as all of these are still in contract .Do we need reinforcements  in this area or will that be enough .?

Firstly we need a new keeper. 

Defensively, it depends what formation we play. 

If 4 at the back we need a new right back unless TGH is going to play there and I'm not convinced with Townsend. 

We need a new right winger and two central midfielders.  

Difficult to see how we can improve our front-line with our budget.


RE: Central defenders - Tom Joad - 03-12-2022

SW4Baggie Wrote:
Gzbaggy Wrote:you have missed Bryan, who will probably be injured anyway. We also have Livermore and Reach who can play there

We need to look to improve wide areas too, so I would imagine both Furlong and Townsend could be options in a back 3 also, especially with Phillips being an option at RWB during August and September next season. 

Considering how poorly our squad is performing, we don’t need much this summer.  Some legs and creativity in midfield, and a couple of wingbacks, and depending what happens with the goalies, maybe another one for cover.

GK: Palmer, Griffiths

CB: Bryan, Bartley, Kipré, O’Shea, Ajayi  (Furlong, Townsend, Livermore, Taylor, Reach)

LWB: Reach, Townsend

RWB: Furlong, PhillipS (TGH, Ingram)

MC: Livermore, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, (Molumby?) 

ML: Reach, Grady, Robinson 

MR: Phillips, Grady, TGH,

ATK: Grant, Robinson, Dike, Zohore (Phillips, Carroll) 

Resigning Carroll feels a no brainier at the moment but I’d wait ‘til the summer and see what his demands are.

If we could move Bartley, Phillips, Zohore, Reach on that would be great - even if it was on loan with us subsidising… it would free some cash up to hopefully bring in 3-4 players who can improve in the areas we are so obviously short.

I'd say, we need considerable improvements this summer. The midfield is not fit for purpose.

The main changes are needed here, at not too drastic an expense;

Keepers. Drop SJ  and use the rest of the season to assess Palmer who should be re-called ASAP, then with Griffiths as no 2 we may be ok.
Midfield. Jake as either screening the centre backs or as a CB. TGH should play (but maybe as a FB?). Then we need a captain, someone that will lift the players and not tolerate any heads dropping. I've said elsewhere, Barry Bannan would be a cheap but effective option although I've not seen him this season. Some creativity should be targeted.
Strikers. Give Carroll a 12 month deal, with Dike and Grant plus Diang backed up by Tulloch and Fellows we should be ok. This will negate the need to spend on the most expensive part of the jigsaw, a striker. Any splashing out should be solely directed at solving our non existent midfield.
Players surplus to requirements. Make Bartley, Robinson and Zohore available for loan (unless we can mug someone into paying for them).


RE: Central defenders - Cheshire East Baggie - 03-12-2022

(03-12-2022, 04:24 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:
Gzbaggy Wrote:you have missed Bryan, who will probably be injured anyway. We also have Livermore and Reach who can play there

We need to look to improve wide areas too, so I would imagine both Furlong and Townsend could be options in a back 3 also, especially with Phillips being an option at RWB during August and September next season. 

Considering how poorly our squad is performing, we don’t need much this summer.  Some legs and creativity in midfield, and a couple of wingbacks, and depending what happens with the goalies, maybe another one for cover.

GK: Palmer, Griffiths

CB: Bryan, Bartley, Kipré, O’Shea, Ajayi  (Furlong, Townsend, Livermore, Taylor, Reach)

LWB: Reach, Townsend

RWB: Furlong, PhillipS (TGH, Ingram)

MC: Livermore, Mowatt, Reach, TGH, (Molumby?) 

ML: Reach, Grady, Robinson 

MR: Phillips, Grady, TGH,

ATK: Grant, Robinson, Dike, Zohore (Phillips, Carroll) 

Resigning Carroll feels a no brainier at the moment but I’d wait ‘til the summer and see what his demands are.

If we could move Bartley, Phillips, Zohore, Reach on that would be great - even if it was on loan with us subsidising… it would free some cash up to hopefully bring in 3-4 players who can improve in the areas we are so obviously short.

I'd say, we need considerable improvements this summer. The midfield is not fit for purpose.

The main changes are needed here, at not too drastic an expense;

Keepers. Drop SJ  and use the rest of the season to assess Palmer who should be re-called ASAP, then with Griffiths as no 2 we may be ok.
Midfield. Jake as either screening the centre backs or as a CB. TGH should play (but maybe as a FB?). Then we need a captain, someone that will lift the players and not tolerate any heads dropping. I've said elsewhere, Barry Bannan would be a cheap but effective option although I've not seen him this season. Some creativity should be targeted.
Strikers. Give Carroll a 12 month deal, with Dike and Grant plus Diang backed up by Tulloch and Fellows we should be ok. This will negate the need to spend on the most expensive part of the jigsaw, a striker. Any splashing out should be solely directed at solving our non existent midfield.
Players surplus to requirements. Make Bartley, Robinson and Zohore available for loan (unless we can mug someone into paying for them).

Tom's right, we need to make changes to improve the attitude and morale. Leaving aside the question of contracts, I'd be happy to lose Bartley, Robinson, Ajayi, Furlong, Livermore and Phillips simply because they are all tainted by repeated failure. Johnstone as well, of course. Zohore must go, can't believe that situation is still going on. Mowatt is just a bit shit, will he improve with better players around him? So I want to see right back, centre back and three midfielders, plus Carroll. There needs to be a captain in there. And no old blokes (apart from Carroll).