WBAUnofficial
The damage was done in the summer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The damage was done in the summer (/showthread.php?tid=24305)

Pages: 1 2


The damage was done in the summer - SW4Baggie - 02-23-2022

Our shocking transfer business has been discussed to death on here, but what I find truly unforgivable is the naive belief that going into the summer our squad was good enough to return at the first time of asking without investment, or at the very least, some strong characters to blow away the undercurrent of failure.

We knew a much stronger side had very nearly blown promotion 2 seasons ago, and we also knew we had lost 7-8 players from our first team from the admittedly short spell where the Fat Fraud had at least made us look like we could be competitive.

Looking back at previous relegation/promotions, the two seasons were we have kept faith in the players have resulted in poor seasons, Robson/Mowbay's playoff season and the Moore/Shan promotion season were both punctuated by senior players not giving a shit, dressing room squabbles and struggles against poorer sides where our boys needed to put some graft in. 

The seasons where we've actually gotten promoted again have both followed summers of change and clearing the decks. Megson's second promotion season saw us hoover up the best talent in the Championship, Mowbray's title win was following a massive rebuild where we made a significant profit, and Bilic's promotion again followed a considerable turnover of players... Whilst RDM's promotion saw minimal summer recruitment, we built the side around youth... Dorrans and Mulumbu went from bit part/subs to the heart of the midfield, and I think that summer Thomas was the only player who arrived over 23... we then added Reid's character and nous to see us over the line in January.

We have never been successful when we've let players who've been relegated "attempt to put things right" - and we were wrong to think the bulk of this squad could get us up this season. We needed fresh blood, and not just squad fillers.

I have a good feeling about Dike, his personality seems exactly what this squad needs, and Carroll has been a breath of fresh air. Similarly, I'd back Mowatt over our current group of wasters as I feel he's being dragged down by the lack of motivation of those around him. I just wish we had a manager and club that judged players on their output, not on their reputation and actually punished and acted on failure instead of rewarding it with nice, juicy contract extensions when they deserved a prolonged spell in the reserves.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Tom Joad - 02-23-2022

Good points. I'd add Megson made huge changes after our first relegation from the Prem and when asked he said. "We need to get rid of that losing mentality".


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Ted Maul - 02-23-2022

VI had one hand tied behind his back from the start. He wanted Dike and got Hugill, not sure anything else needs to be said.

It is entirely pointless to appoint a manager on a four year contract and not give him to tools to do a long-term job.

If the club knew the situation in terms of recruitment etc then it makes the decision to veto the Wilder appointment even stranger. The extra £2m we spent on Val could have been better spent on new players.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Squid - 02-23-2022

(02-23-2022, 10:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Our shocking transfer business has been discussed to death on here, but what I find truly unforgivable is the naive belief that going into the summer our squad was good enough to return at the first time of asking without investment, or at the very least, some strong characters to blow away the undercurrent of failure.

We knew a much stronger side had very nearly blown promotion 2 seasons ago, and we also knew we had lost 7-8 players from our first team from the admittedly short spell where the Fat Fraud had at least made us look like we could be competitive.

Looking back at previous relegation/promotions, the two seasons were we have kept faith in the players have resulted in poor seasons, Robson/Mowbay's playoff season and the Moore/Shan promotion season were both punctuated by senior players not giving a shit, dressing room squabbles and struggles against poorer sides where our boys needed to put some graft in. 

The seasons where we've actually gotten promoted again have both followed summers of change and clearing the decks. Megson's second promotion season saw us hoover up the best talent in the Championship, Mowbray's title win was following a massive rebuild where we made a significant profit, and Bilic's promotion again followed a considerable turnover of players... Whilst RDM's promotion saw minimal summer recruitment, we built the side around youth... Dorrans and Mulumbu went from bit part/subs to the heart of the midfield, and I think that summer Thomas was the only player who arrived over 23... we then added Reid's character and nous to see us over the line in January.

We have never been successful when we've let players who've been relegated "attempt to put things right" - and we were wrong to think the bulk of this squad could get us up this season. We needed fresh blood, and not just squad fillers.

I have a good feeling about Dike, his personality seems exactly what this squad needs, and Carroll has been a breath of fresh air. Similarly, I'd back Mowatt over our current group of wasters as I feel he's being dragged down by the lack of motivation of those around him. I just wish we had a manager and club that judged players on their output, not on their reputation and actually punished and acted on failure instead of rewarding it with nice, juicy contract extensions when they deserved a prolonged spell in the reserves.

Really? The likes of Brunty, J-Rod and Hegazi not caring?! I don't think so. I agree that we are in a very bad way, but there's no reason to sully the names of players of that standing.

If we'd allowed the defenders to defend and kept Barnes all season, we would have been promoted automatically. Too many 1-1s killed us and then we were cheated by a heinous referee.

You are right about contract extensions though.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Cunninghamismagic - 02-23-2022

Despite the weaknesses the squad, with some proper additions, was more than capable of making the Playoffs if we had employed a decent manager in the summer.
Watmore helped turn the game for Boro last night. Was acquired on a free from Sunderland. Are we really saying that Furlong is worse than Peltier (3rd or 4th choice right back not so long ago)?


RE: The damage was done in the summer - SW4Baggie - 02-23-2022

(02-23-2022, 11:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Despite the weaknesses the squad, with some proper additions, was more than capable of making the Playoffs if we had employed a decent manager in the summer.
Watmore helped turn the game for Boro last night. Was acquired on a free from Sunderland. Are we really saying that Furlong is worse than Peltier (3rd or 4th choice right back not so long ago)?

Physical ability is only part of the puzzle, mental ability is just as important, if not more so.

We have enough of the former to be in the top-6 with ease, unfortunately the latter we’d barely manage in League 2.

Andy Carroll, who was without a club for several months before being given a £1k a week contract by a desperate and relegation threatened Reading is our BEST player. Let that sink in.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - KratosBaggie - 02-23-2022

The damage was done during the end of Pulis' tenure. He spunked vast (for a club of our stature) amounts of money on aging, overrated and rubbish players, and we've never truly recovered from the mess he left us in.

The fact that mess was never allowed to be cleaned up, combined with poor player recruitment, a lack of investment in playing squad, clueless backroom staff, and an owner that couldn't give a fuck, means you will only face disaster and a downward spiral that will carry on until all the above is remedied.

The management recruitment hasn't been a problem, for me. I was happy and pleased (at the time) with the appointments of Big Dave, Slav and Val. Even Big Sam and Bruce are logical appointments given the circumstances we found ourselves in.

The aforementioned managers all made errors that have cost us points in big games, but they're the equivalent of trying to mend two broken legs with a bandage. The issues run far deeper than what incumbent is managing the absolute pathetic shambles of a club we have declined to since 2018ish.

As always it all starts from the top. Lai either needs to sell up, or appoint backroom staff that are competent. Once a solid boardroom has been appointed, we can look at clearing the deadwood from this utter shit show of a squad. In order to get back on track, and be successful at this level, 90% of the squad NEEDS to be moved on, and replaced with playing staff with the right attitude, and more importantly, fit the style of play that the current coaching staff want to implement, or fit the style of play that the board sees as the clubs identity, and appoint a manager that fits said identity.

Then, and only then, once you get the right staff, and playing staff, can you fairly judge a manager, and expect him to achieve success. 

In short we need to hit the reset button big time. A mass clearout is a must. Then we can look at building back up. We are currently where we were when Megson took over, in terms of the rebuild task that needs to take place. It's a mammoth task, it'll be tough, and it needs strong leadership from the top. We don't have that, so I'm not holding my breath, and I expect things to get much worse before they get any better.

It's a fucking disgrace.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Sliced - 02-23-2022

(02-23-2022, 11:43 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-23-2022, 11:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Despite the weaknesses the squad, with some proper additions, was more than capable of making the Playoffs if we had employed a decent manager in the summer.
Watmore helped turn the game for Boro last night. Was acquired on a free from Sunderland. Are we really saying that Furlong is worse than Peltier (3rd or 4th choice right back not so long ago)?

Physical ability is only part of the puzzle, mental ability is just as important, if not more so.

We have enough of the former to be in the top-6 with ease, unfortunately the latter we’d barely manage in League 2.

Andy Carroll, who was without a club for several months before being given a £1k a week contract by a desperate and relegation threatened Reading is our BEST player. Let that sink in.

Our best player despite being a striker who really hasn't looked like scoring as well


RE: The damage was done in the summer - Big Daddy Cool - 02-23-2022

I was looking through our player contracts earlier and had a feeling of dread that we could be stuck with these lot for a while yet.

Livermore - 2023
Bartley - 2023
Ajayi - 2023
Zohore - 2023
Mowatt - 2024
Phillips - 2024
Reach - 2024!
Kipre - 2024
Diangana - 2025
Robinson - 2025
Furlong - 2025
Townsend - 2025

Most of these will be on good money too so it would be hard to shift them. The fact that Reach was given a 3 year deal and Phillips is here until 2024 despite being years past his best is why we're in the situation we're in. Just a badly run club.


RE: The damage was done in the summer - SW4Baggie - 02-23-2022

(02-23-2022, 12:18 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: The damage was done during the end of Pulis' tenure. He spunked vast (for a club of our stature) amounts of money on aging, overrated and rubbish players, and we've never truly recovered from the mess he left us in.

The fact that mess was never allowed to be cleaned up, combined with poor player recruitment, a lack of investment in playing squad, clueless backroom staff, and an owner that couldn't give a fuck, means you will only face disaster and a downward spiral that will carry on until all the above is remedied.

The management recruitment hasn't been a problem for me. I was happy and pleased (at the time) with the appointments of Big Dave, Slav and Val. Even Big Sam and Bruce are logical appointments given the circumstances we found ourselves in.

The aforementioned managers all made errors that have cost us points in Big games, but they're the equivalent of trying to mend two broken legs with a bandage. The issues run far deeper than what incumbent is managing the absolute pathetic shambles of a club we have declined to since 2018ish.

It's a fucking disgrace.

Pulis was sacked in November 2017 - we have had 9 windows to put it right, much like people laying the blame at Peace's door, Pulis is gone and we can't cling to blaming him for the current mess we find ourselves in.

Since we got relegated in 2018 we've sold players for over £80m and spent around that much again... the damage has been done well after Pulis left.