WBAUnofficial
If you had carte blanche this summer… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: If you had carte blanche this summer… (/showthread.php?tid=23860)

Pages: 1 2


If you had carte blanche this summer… - Moore Than - 01-29-2022

So you’ve got the job and the board have said you can get rid of anyone you want to. What decision are you making on the players based on what you’ve seen this season? Assume we’ve not gone up.

I’d be something like this:

Johnstone - leaving anyway.
Button - probably worth keeping as a cover for a new GK but not bothered if he stays or goes.
Furlong - awful defender, not good enough, would sell.
TGH - the future. He stays.
O’Shea - our new captain. Stays.
Ajayi - I’d consider selling but I’m not against him staying.
Bartley - he’s shite. I’d want him gone.
Clarke - nothing there to suggest I’d want him permanently. Get rid.
Kipre - sell him.
Townsend - solid enough. I’d keep.
Reach - he’s a journeyman. Get rid of him.
Mowatt - I’d be selling him based on the last month unless he improves. No skill at all.
Livermore - cheers Jake but goodbye.
Molumby - dreadful. Get him out.
Snodgrass - getting on a bit, I’d get rid.
Robinson - thinks he far better than he is. Been woeful at times. I’d sell him.
Phillips - one of the first I’d get rid of, he’s been phoning it in for years.
Grant - I’d be selling except he’s scored a few. Would sell for a good offer.
Diangana - still a half decent player in there. I’d keep.
Dike - looks decent on the brief bits we’ve seen. Obviously keep.
Zahore - dreadful. To the point that we were selecting Hugill ahead of him.

I reckon that’s 75% of the squad I’d happily move on if possible.


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - Ted Maul - 01-29-2022

Tough to disagree with most of that. I'd probably sell Ajayi as well tbf.


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - wba13 - 01-29-2022

I understand a lot of this but one big problem you need buyers we will only get crap offers if any.


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - Moore Than - 01-29-2022

(01-29-2022, 10:30 PM)wba13 Wrote: I understand a lot of this but one big problem you need buyers we will only get crap offers if any.

“Carte blanche”!


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - MancBaggie - 01-29-2022

Good post MT

Val’s the short term problem

That collective sack of shite is the medium to long term issue


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - Sliced - 01-29-2022

Given how we're basically again going to be relying on loans and frees for replacements and the rate at which our quality is declining I would be going for:

Johnstone - Bye
Button - Keep but hope he's not first choice
Furlong - Bye
TGH - Stay
O’Shea - Stay
Ajayi - Stay
Bartley - Bye
Clarke - Don't think he'll stay as he costs a fee
Kipre - Stay
Townsend - Stay
Reach - Stay
Mowatt - Stay
Livermore - Bye.
Molumby - Bye
Snodgrass - Bye
Robinson - Stay
Phillips - Bye
Grant - Stay
Diangana - Stay
Dike - Stay
Zahore - Bye

That basically means next season we'll have a total transfer budget of 0 and will need:

1 Keeper
1 Right Back
1 Centre Back
3 Central/Attacking Midfielders
1 Wide Midfielder/Attacker
1 Striker

At a minimum


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - TartanRug - 01-29-2022

Looking at that list makes it easier to understand, along with the stubborn manager, why we struggle. Especially with the utter garbage that is most of our midfield


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - SW4Baggie - 01-29-2022

Im glad Livermore has activated his extension and we have Furlong and Phillips new deals.

I might go watch The Moors for a bit, the thought of Livermore ambling around got another season and Phillips being decent until September fucks me right off.


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - Johnnykayeengland - 01-29-2022

Not gonna happen.
Nobody ever replaces 15 players at a go. Not least because 15 newcomers won't gel.
There are plenty of good championship players there.
With the right manager obviously.


RE: If you had carte blanche this summer… - ElbowGrease1973 - 01-29-2022

(01-29-2022, 10:57 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Not gonna happen.
Nobody ever replaces 15 players at a go. Not least because 15 newcomers won't gel.
There are plenty of good championship players there.
With the right manager obviously.

This - And even if we decide to replace 15 players, who's going to take the ones that aren't out of contract? If only it were as simple as a game of Championship Manager perhaps Val's tactics would also be successful.