WBAUnofficial
The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. (/showthread.php?tid=23791)

Pages: 1 2 3


The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Lurker#3 - 01-27-2022

Come on then yow lot... whats the magic formula? 

If I was gonna pick, and had to "change shape" I would go. 

SJ
Furlong Bartley Clarke Townsend
Livermore Mowatt 
Phillips Robinson Grant Grady


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - baggpuss - 01-27-2022

Can't say I disagree with any of the anti Val stuff but.........
Surely the players are not exonerated from blame after that garbage?
These are highly played professionals who owe it to the fans to put in a shift?
They really should hold their heads in shame!!!


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - rsbaggy2 - 01-27-2022

If there was a suitable option I would relegate Furlong to the benches.

Don't disagree with your line up ... basically let the goalie keep goal, the defenders defend, the midfield provide cover and ball retention, the wingers ''wing'' and the attackers attack.

Can football really be that simple?


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Pfister - 01-27-2022

(01-27-2022, 06:42 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: If there was a suitable option I would relegate Furlong to the benches.

Don't disagree with your line up ... basically let the goalie keep goal, the defenders defend, the midfield provide cover and ball retention, the wingers ''wing'' and the attackers attack.

Can football really be that simple?

Have to agree with this. Plus, if your centre forward is injured (or out of form) use the “reserves” centre forward. Give him (Cleary) a go. Can’t be much worse than what we’ve seen thus far.


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - wbamitch - 01-27-2022

Shipping out Pereira and Sawyers with no intention of replacing what they offered doesn't give us a great deal to work with, but certainly a 4 back with 3 in midfield I think would give an instant improvement. At full strength I'd go something like this:

Button 

Furlong O'Shea Bartley Townsend 

Livermore
Mowatt Gardner-Hickman

Phillips Dike Grant

Midfield is still rubbish but that's what we have.


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Lightnin - 01-27-2022

4-3-3

We Saturday bring next on the list
Button
Furlong, Bartley, Clarke, Townsend
TGH, Livermore, Mowatt
Grady, Robbo, Grant

When fit then Dike plays obviously


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Spandaubaggie - 01-27-2022

Honestly, I really don't blame the players. They are probably on the floor morale wise as he persists with this hoofing style which leaves 8 opponents packing penalty areas and the ball bouncing around like a pinball, with each hopeless punt being classed as a shot.

The spirit must be sucked out of them.

There's no guile, no change of formation, no nothing. I think I've seen 20 games and bar a handful they have been exactly the same.
In the past 3 months only the Bristol City performance really stands out as a good one from start to finish.

Barnsley, Blackpool, Derby etc, etc- gash sides we can't score against because we are so predictable.


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Lurker#3 - 01-27-2022

(01-27-2022, 07:05 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Honestly, I really don't blame the players. They are probably on the floor morale wise as he persists with this hoofing style which leaves 8 opponents packing penalty areas and the ball bouncing around like a pinball, with each hopeless punt being classed as a shot.

The spirit must be sucked out of them.

There's no guile, no change of formation, no nothing. I think I've seen 20 games and bar a handful they have been exactly the same.
In the past 3 months only the Bristol City performance really stands out as a good one from start to finish.

Barnsley, Blackpool, Derby etc, etc- gash sides we can't score against because we are so predictable.

Your Magic wand solution if you were in charge  Spandau?I was trying to get a post going which would stay devoid of any monotonous val bashing/loving.  Big Grin


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Lillwall's left foot - 01-27-2022

We don't have a CF. We don't have a creative midfielder. We don't have a natural holding midfielder. In a back four any combination of Barts, Clarke and Kipre makes me nervous. Cant see a magic bullet but FWIW. Robinson dropping deep.

SJ
Furlong Barts ClarkeTownsend
Phillips TGH Mowatt Grady
Grant Robinson

Full strength??

SJ
Furlong Dara Clarke Townsend
TGH Livermore/Molomby Mowatt
Grady Grant
Dike


RE: The "we would get more from these players in a different system" starting XI thread.. - Jack Halford - 01-27-2022

(01-27-2022, 06:40 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Can't say I disagree with any of the anti Val stuff but.........
Surely the players are not exonerated from blame after that garbage?
These are highly played professionals who owe it to the fans to put in a shift?
They really should hold their heads in shame!!!

A good number of the squad are part of the problem and they owe the fans a lot for their performances.

Highly paid yes, professional absolutely not. They too easily down tools and lack mental fibre.

The lack of leadership and motivation from our senior players and captain is shameful. The marriage between them and Val is a marriage made in hell. If we could afford to I’d jettison the majority.

They are ok though as they drive off to their comfy mansions…