WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=23333)



Ratings - SW4Baggie - 01-02-2022

Getting harder to support Val as the games go by… 2 points from Barnsley, Derby and Cardiff is in no way acceptable and to have lost two of our key men to ill discipline just adds further fuel to the fire.

FWIW I’m bought into Val. He has got us fit, well organised and we have a clear identity. Throughout his career he has a track record of mostly overachieving and there are traits in this style that will give us a platform to attack the PL, unfortunately we seem a long way off getting there currently. This squad of players has shown no fight, no bottle and little signs of the quality we are paying them very well to demonstrate. This is the fourth manager, and fourth style that these guys have failed in, and eventually we have to double down on a manager, decide on a longer term strategy and accept that we may have to go through some tough times before they get better.

Today however, the first half was amongst the worst 45 minutes of football I’ve ever seen from us. I thought Derby was bad but today was atrocious. Cardiff are limited but pressed us and we had no answer. We had no runners, a stationary midfield, and could barely string the most basic of passes together. Our crossing was abysmal continuously, and we seemed to have no ideas other than getting the ball out wide where their wingbacks were sitting as fullbacks in a back 5 and whipping a poor ball into the box where 3 giant CBs didn’t need to jump to beat our midget front line.

Second half we tried to play through them and for 15 minutes looked capable of turning it round… Cardiff to their credit dropped an extra man between their defence and midfield and nullified the space and Mowatt’s red then killed any chance of stretching the game, Reach rendered the addition of pointless.

Positives were that Val didn’t do the lazy subs on the hour mark, slightly changed our shape and Hugill didn’t come on. Negatives are that we will need much more than Dike to get up this year. Without Phillips we have no direct runners, without Mowatt we will now lack guile in midfield, and Button isn’t as good as Johnstone - although today he was poor. TGH had his poorest game since breaking through (standard curse of a new contract for our kids!) and Fellows looks well off the pace.

Oh, and referees at this level remain utter shit. Today’s was spectacularly inept.

Johnstone - 5 - distribution very shaky, looks affected by last week, and utterly stupid at FT.

Kipré - 7 - rapidly becoming our best CB… looked wobbly at the end but think he was carrying a knock for final 10
Bartley - 6 - think it was his man for the goal, some sloppy challenges on half way line 
Clark 6 - didn’t cover himself with glory, going through a dip in form. Seems to have lost the confidence to bring the ball into midfield, and was targeted by their press 

Townsend - 4 - poorest game I’ve seen him have. Delivery totally off, decision marking very poor, that ball under zero pressure to Reach when he was saying to wait til he was onside epitomised a crap day.
Livermore - 6 - better from Jake, he enjoyed the battle today, but went to pieces in Cardiff half - struggles to make a penetrative pass forward which with our lack of runners just slows everything down.
Mowatt - 4 - absolutely stupid and needless red, put us in danger when we looked like grabbing a win
TGH - 5 - poorest game since breaking into team. Ponderous build up, too many touches.

Fellows - 3 - want him to do well but was a liability defensively - positioning poor, and was easily marked. Their CBs were huge in fairness to him, and couldn’t get any time on the ball - back on the bench Val.
Robinson - 7 - points for a very tidy finish, but he was off. Too many touches around the box again but looks our main threat.
Grant - 5 - more dangerous in our half, did a lot of tracking back and a lot of running today, but failed to work their keeper. Not sure he touched the ball first half 

—-

Reach - 3 - thought he was supposed to have decent delivery - takes too many touches, slows breaks down and failed to put a decent cross in 
Diangana - 4 - should have had a penalty and stretched their back line more than Grant/Fellows but half hearted finish at keeper when through showed just how little he gives a fuck currently.
Molumby - 5 - not sure he touched the ball, which would be an improvement on some of those that did.


RE: Ratings - ericlegrisly - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 04:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Getting harder to support Val as the games go by… 2 points from Barnsley, Derby and Cardiff is in no way acceptable and to have lost two of our key men to ill discipline just adds further fuel to the fire.

FWIW I’m bought into Val. He has got us fit, well organised and we have a clear identity. Throughout his career he has a track record of mostly overachieving and there are traits in this style that will give us a platform to attack the PL, unfortunately we seem a long way off getting there currently. This squad of players has shown no fight, no bottle and little signs of the quality we are paying them very well to demonstrate. This is the fourth manager, and fourth style that these guys have failed in, and eventually we have to double down on a manager, decide on a longer term strategy and accept that we may have to go through some tough times before they get better.

Today however, the first half was amongst the worst 45 minutes of football I’ve ever seen from us. I thought Derby was bad but today was atrocious. Cardiff are limited but pressed us and we had no answer. We had no runners, a stationary midfield, and could barely string the most basic of passes together. Our crossing was abysmal continuously, and we seemed to have no ideas other than getting the ball out wide where their wingbacks were sitting as fullbacks in a back 5 and whipping a poor ball into the box where 3 giant CBs didn’t need to jump to beat our midget front line.

Second half we tried to play through them and for 15 minutes looked capable of turning it round… Cardiff to their credit dropped an extra man between their defence and midfield and nullified the space and Mowatt’s red then killed any chance of stretching the game, Reach rendered the addition of pointless.

Positives were that Val didn’t do the lazy subs on the hour mark, slightly changed our shape and Hugill didn’t come on. Negatives are that we will need much more than Dike to get up this year. Without Phillips we have no direct runners, without Mowatt we will now lack guile in midfield, and Button isn’t as good as Johnstone - although today he was poor. TGH had his poorest game since breaking through (standard curse of a new contract for our kids!) and Fellows looks well off the pace.

Oh, and referees at this level remain utter shit. Today’s was spectacularly inept.

Johnstone - 5 - distribution very shaky, looks affected by last week, and utterly stupid at FT.

Kipré - 7 - rapidly becoming our best CB… looked wobbly at the end but think he was carrying a knock for final 10
Bartley - 6 - think it was his man for the goal, some sloppy challenges on half way line 
Clark 6 - didn’t cover himself with glory, going through a dip in form. Seems to have lost the confidence to bring the ball into midfield, and was targeted by their press 

Townsend - 4 - poorest game I’ve seen him have. Delivery totally off, decision marking very poor, that ball under zero pressure to Reach when he was saying to wait til he was onside epitomised a crap day.
Livermore - 6 - better from Jake, he enjoyed the battle today, but went to pieces in Cardiff half - struggles to make a penetrative pass forward which with our lack of runners just slows everything down.
Mowatt - 4 - absolutely stupid and needless red, put us in danger when we looked like grabbing a win
TGH - 5 - poorest game since breaking into team. Ponderous build up, too many touches.

Fellows - 3 - want him to do well but was a liability defensively - positioning poor, and was easily marked. Their CBs were huge in fairness to him, and couldn’t get any time on the ball - back on the bench Val.
Robinson - 7 - points for a very tidy finish, but he was off. Too many touches around the box again but looks our main threat.
Grant - 5 - more dangerous in our half, did a lot of tracking back and a lot of running today, but failed to work their keeper. Not sure he touched the ball first half 

—-

Reach - 3 - thought he was supposed to have decent delivery - takes too many touches, slows breaks down and failed to put a decent cross in 
Diangana - 4 - should have had a penalty and stretched their back line more than Grant/Fellows but half hearted finish at keeper when through showed just how little he gives a fuck currently.
Molumby - 5 - not sure he touched the ball, which would be an improvement on some of those that did.
Not a million miles off in terms of ratings, but the highlighted bit above is just fundamentally not true.


RE: Ratings - Peachy - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 04:27 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 04:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Getting harder to support Val as the games go by… 2 points from Barnsley, Derby and Cardiff is in no way acceptable and to have lost two of our key men to ill discipline just adds further fuel to the fire.

FWIW I’m bought into Val. He has got us fit, well organised and we have a clear identity. Throughout his career he has a track record of mostly overachieving and there are traits in this style that will give us a platform to attack the PL, unfortunately we seem a long way off getting there currently. This squad of players has shown no fight, no bottle and little signs of the quality we are paying them very well to demonstrate. This is the fourth manager, and fourth style that these guys have failed in, and eventually we have to double down on a manager, decide on a longer term strategy and accept that we may have to go through some tough times before they get better.

Today however, the first half was amongst the worst 45 minutes of football I’ve ever seen from us. I thought Derby was bad but today was atrocious. Cardiff are limited but pressed us and we had no answer. We had no runners, a stationary midfield, and could barely string the most basic of passes together. Our crossing was abysmal continuously, and we seemed to have no ideas other than getting the ball out wide where their wingbacks were sitting as fullbacks in a back 5 and whipping a poor ball into the box where 3 giant CBs didn’t need to jump to beat our midget front line.

Second half we tried to play through them and for 15 minutes looked capable of turning it round… Cardiff to their credit dropped an extra man between their defence and midfield and nullified the space and Mowatt’s red then killed any chance of stretching the game, Reach rendered the addition of pointless.

Positives were that Val didn’t do the lazy subs on the hour mark, slightly changed our shape and Hugill didn’t come on. Negatives are that we will need much more than Dike to get up this year. Without Phillips we have no direct runners, without Mowatt we will now lack guile in midfield, and Button isn’t as good as Johnstone - although today he was poor. TGH had his poorest game since breaking through (standard curse of a new contract for our kids!) and Fellows looks well off the pace.

Oh, and referees at this level remain utter shit. Today’s was spectacularly inept.

Johnstone - 5 - distribution very shaky, looks affected by last week, and utterly stupid at FT.

Kipré - 7 - rapidly becoming our best CB… looked wobbly at the end but think he was carrying a knock for final 10
Bartley - 6 - think it was his man for the goal, some sloppy challenges on half way line 
Clark 6 - didn’t cover himself with glory, going through a dip in form. Seems to have lost the confidence to bring the ball into midfield, and was targeted by their press 

Townsend - 4 - poorest game I’ve seen him have. Delivery totally off, decision marking very poor, that ball under zero pressure to Reach when he was saying to wait til he was onside epitomised a crap day.
Livermore - 6 - better from Jake, he enjoyed the battle today, but went to pieces in Cardiff half - struggles to make a penetrative pass forward which with our lack of runners just slows everything down.
Mowatt - 4 - absolutely stupid and needless red, put us in danger when we looked like grabbing a win
TGH - 5 - poorest game since breaking into team. Ponderous build up, too many touches.

Fellows - 3 - want him to do well but was a liability defensively - positioning poor, and was easily marked. Their CBs were huge in fairness to him, and couldn’t get any time on the ball - back on the bench Val.
Robinson - 7 - points for a very tidy finish, but he was off. Too many touches around the box again but looks our main threat.
Grant - 5 - more dangerous in our half, did a lot of tracking back and a lot of running today, but failed to work their keeper. Not sure he touched the ball first half 

—-

Reach - 3 - thought he was supposed to have decent delivery - takes too many touches, slows breaks down and failed to put a decent cross in 
Diangana - 4 - should have had a penalty and stretched their back line more than Grant/Fellows but half hearted finish at keeper when through showed just how little he gives a fuck currently.
Molumby - 5 - not sure he touched the ball, which would be an improvement on some of those that did.
Not a million miles off in terms of ratings, but the highlighted bit above is just fundamentally not true.

Agree. Im dying for a journo to ask "So Val you mention players must have bought in to the philosophy and the project. I'd just like you to explain what they both are?"

I sure as shit don't have a clue what our philosophy is?


RE: Ratings - Lurker#3 - 01-02-2022

SJ - 5 - Shaky and stupid.

Kipre - 7 - Strong, quick and is learning.
Bartley - 6 - Okay.
Clarke - 5 - Don't really see the point. Not that dominating and not althat great on the ball.

TGH - 6 - Poor positioning, but showed balls and played some decent forward passes.
Livermore - 4 - Worked hard enough as usual, but never once influenced the game either offensively or defensively.
Mowatt - 6 - Grafted, pressed and played some decent forward passes... Silly tackle.
Townsend - 4 - Shockingly out of touch for him.

Fellows - 4 - Got bullied, was a protest selction to give the players a kick up the arse I think.
Robbo - 7 - MOTM - So much better, got on it, kept it and got his goal. Albeit offside.
Grant - 6 - Thought he played okay, unlucky kn 2 occasions when he got his snap shots off. Will really benefit from Dike.

Subs:

Reach - 6 - improved us.
Diangana - 6 - see above. Should have been 9 with the peno he didn't get and the 2 goals he should have had.
Molumby - Can we send him back and get Okay on loan with view to a perm?


RE: Ratings - Duffers - 01-02-2022

I actually thought Grady looked very bright when he came on.

Fellows looked nervous a little out of his depth early doors but improved as the game went on.

Robinson - nice finish, fuck all else.

Grant - nice assist, fuck all else.

Mowatt - shite

Livermore - Livermore

Clarke- Fine

Bartley - Fine

Kipre - Less fine

Johnstone - Stupid

Townsend - Poor but should have had a pen

TGH - Ok, not quite the upgrade on Furlong folk were hoping for.


RE: Ratings - MassDebater - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 04:45 PM)Duffers Wrote: I actually thought Grady looked very bright when he came on.

Fellows looked nervous a little out of his depth early doors but improved as the game went on.

Robinson - nice finish, fuck all else.

Grant - nice assist, fuck all else.

Mowatt - shite

Livermore - Livermore

Clarke- Fine

Bartley - Fine

Kipre - Less fine

Johnstone - Stupid

Townsend - Poor but should have had a pen

TGH - Ok, not quite the upgrade on Furlong folk were hoping for.

Was going to say the same about Diang. 2 cracking efforts on another day one would have gone in. Can't take it away from their keeper though. Best he's looked in a while I'd say.

Everyone else was pretty shit.
SJ 3 - no excuse for his red, what was he even doing up there?
Robinson 6 - simply for the goal.
Mowatt 3 - stupid red that could have cost us.

Everyone else 5.


RE: Ratings - Dumbo - 01-02-2022

I thought we were poor all over. Kiprè the pick of the bunch at the back. Both the kids showed they’re far from ready for first team Championship football. Grant our best player today. The only one who looked to create, drive play on and run with the ball.

All round shite. Has been for months.


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 01-03-2022

A hard one to mark as we were so poor 1st 45, improved 2nd half, and then a crazy end to end sloug it out when down to 10 men. It was a stand up and be counted game against some proper shithousery, many didn't stand up.  Livermore did. For all the criticism, we'd have lost that if he had have been out. I know that isn't a popular view but it's how I saw it.

SJ 3.  So little to do yet managed a couple of glorious fuck ups and a post 90 red card. Bizarre.
TGH 5.  Up against it today but didn't hide, may have helped if he had  more experienced cover in front. Should start next game.
Kipre 6. I thought he did ok and am surprised at some of the low marks.
Bartley 4. I'm just not a fan. At his age he ought to be the mainstay of the defence. O' Shea should take over ASAP.
Clarke 6. Would be 6.5 but for that one rick plus I fear it was his zone they scored from.
Townsend 5.  Enthusiastic as ever but woeful crossing. Someone should tell him he is allowed to cut in and shoot.
Jake 6. I maintain, he'd be better with an extra man assisting the midfield, but he was up for the battle.
Mowatt 3. Would have been 4-5 but he probably cost us 2 points.
Fellows 5. Good attitude even when things weren't going for him. Very promising, he'll have easier games.
Robbo 6. Abysmal game, couldn't pass water, yet somehow scored one and narrowly missed another, hence a 6.
Grant. 6.5 Terrible 1st half although that was a rocket shot. Best player on the pitch 2nd. Great ball out of defence to the right wing 2nd half and created the goal. Showing a much better attitude this season.

Subs. Diang, best showing in a while. Funny how competition brings him up a notch.
        Molumby, did enough in a ten man team to earn his place in the squad.
        Reach, would have been a decent display but for some terrible crossing. He isn't a bad signing for us.
 

The subs were effectively a man short of a team so all did ok really. Overall it felt like a defeat. The latest in the long line of disappointing Xmas holiday Albion results.