WBAUnofficial
What are we playing for? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: What are we playing for? (/showthread.php?tid=22241)

Pages: 1 2 3


What are we playing for? - KratosBaggie - 10-23-2021

And what's the point?


RE: What are we playing for? - Birdman1811 - 10-23-2021

To win football games.

Which means we can get promoted from the division we are in and we can play in the top division of the sport in this country, making us among the top 20 teams.


RE: What are we playing for? - Albionmad - 10-23-2021

(10-23-2021, 08:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: To win football games.

Which means we can get promoted from the division we are in and we can play in the top division of the sport in this country, making us among the top 20 teams.

We can be like Norwich. Whilst in the Championship be praised as a role model, a real "family club." Get promoted. Be ripped apart most weeks. Be an object of derision by pundits who from their comfortable sofas criticise them for being out of their depth and having no ambition. Get relegated, trouser the cash, sell their best players, recruit young up and coming players and go again. A season of bliss followed by a season of purgatory. Rinse and repeat. Until the greed merchants realise that English football should include more than say 8 clubs things will always be the same. Villa have spent over 200 million on players after the jammiest couple of seasons in their jammy history. They're a midtable team and could soon be bottom 6 if things go well.

The point I'm making is that under the current PL setup there is no point.


RE: What are we playing for? - Tom Joad - 10-23-2021

I'm singing along "What is it good for...."


RE: What are we playing for? - Birdman1811 - 10-23-2021

(10-23-2021, 09:12 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(10-23-2021, 08:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: To win football games.

Which means we can get promoted from the division we are in and we can play in the top division of the sport in this country, making us among the top 20 teams.

We can be like Norwich. Whilst in the Championship be praised as a role model, a real "family club." Get promoted. Be ripped apart most weeks. Be an object of derision by pundits who from their comfortable sofas criticise them for being out of their depth and having no ambition. Get relegated, trouser the cash, sell their best players, recruit young up and coming players and go again. A season of bliss followed by a season of purgatory. Rinse and repeat. Until the greed merchants realise that English football should include more than say 8 clubs things will always be the same. Villa have spent over 200 million on players after the jammiest couple of seasons in their jammy history. They're a midtable team and could soon be bottom 6 if things go well.

The point I'm making is that under the current PL setup there is no point.

Of course there is a point.

We don't HAVE to be like Norwich, we went up once,  and stayed there for years.

Personal example.

I've said before I play wargames, I play competitively, I have no hope of winning any tournie, I have one at the end of November, I know already, winning is going to be all but impossible, several players are better, have better armies, and play more. However I enjoy playing the games, and there is always that chance I beat one of the better players, and therefore get to enjoy that.

Of course, football is very skewed towards the top 6, so we can't win it, but we can stay up, other teams have, including us.


RE: What are we playing for? - Remi_Moses - 10-23-2021

FFS the point is that our beloved club stays in business.
To maintain our current position within the league we need the cash that the PL generates. So getting promotion secures us financially. 
If you're of the opinion what's the point I suggest you support one of the top 6


RE: What are we playing for? - Albionmad - 10-23-2021

(10-23-2021, 09:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: FFS the point is that our beloved club stays in business.
To maintain our current position within the league we need the cash that the PL generates. So getting promotion secures us financially. 
If you're of the opinion what's the point I suggest you support one of the top 6

Or not support any team except one in the lower leagues  where the playing field is level.
I've had it up to here with modern football. I've been a Baggie since 1969 after attending my first game aged 7. We've never been an elite club but the gap was narrow enough that you hoped  would be closed. We got close in 78/79 but it slipped away when RM took LC and ManU took BR and RA. Since then its been a battle and we were on the fringe again until the sweet FA took RH & DA. Now to close the gap again will require at least 500 million of investment and shrewd use of that. I find I'm happiest when I dont watch games and look for the results. Im better around my family as well which is the most important thing.

Sorry this is a bit Emperors New Clothes but thats how I feel.


RE: What are we playing for? - aj21 - 10-24-2021

Can’t blame you, I often feel why do I care and I have cared far less over recent seasons as the gap has continued to widen. You just have to remember it’s only a game, you’ll always be Albion and be thankful for the odd good day in a year. To me it’s why cups are more important than the league, life to me is about creating memories and getting to a cup final would be one of those. Sadly it’s never happened since most of us have been watching.


RE: What are we playing for? - Remi_Moses - 10-24-2021

(10-24-2021, 05:04 AM)aj21 Wrote: Can’t blame you, I often feel why do I care and I have cared far less over recent seasons as the gap has continued to widen. You just have to remember it’s only a game, you’ll always be Albion and be thankful for the odd good day in a year. To me it’s why cups are more important than the league, life to me is about creating memories and getting to a cup final would be one of those. Sadly it’s never happened since most of us have been watching.

Spot on, this is one thing that pi55es me off. We always have a chance of winning a cup. For any supporters it's as big as winning the league. So why oh why do we field a weakened side in these games. I fully understand they don't generate the same money as the league does. If we are not interested why bother entering? IMO by fielding a weakened side it treats the supporters with disrespect. Even getting to the later rounds creates a buzz. And you may end up not playing a top 6 team along the way.


RE: What are we playing for? - Pragmatist - 10-24-2021

It’s a very valid question. Norwich are either ranked 21st (top of the Championship) or 20th (bottom of the Premier League). But they’re only 5 points off 17th place. They got hammered 7-0 at Chelsea yesterday - a game that we won 5-2 last year and we put 8 past Chelsea - Champions League winners no less - in 2 games. We also did well v City, Liverpool, United and several top sides.

The gulf between the two divisions gets bigger and bigger. Several teams get promoted, have a decent first season and then plunge to the bottom. Squad depth just isn’t there, they get found out, and without a big cash injection (and sometimes even with a big cash injection) that’s just the way it is. The gulf between Norwich and say Burnley and Southampton and (the current) Wolves is not huge, and big clubs like Leeds and Newcastle flirt with relegation. The risk comes from spending £200m trying to stay up and then failing, which puts the club’s entire future existence at risk.

There are lots of decent clubs in that 21-26 ranking. Let the ESL happen, take 6 clubs out at the top end and from a competition perspective it would be fantastic for us. Sure, the Premiership money would go down, but everyone would need less as they wouldn’t be trying to complete with the big 6 and so wages would also reduce. However it would just create a new gap between the new “top 20” and the new “21-26”, but I suspect that would be a smaller gulf. As it is, Norwich, Watford, Brentford, us, Fulham, Bournemouth are just likely to play musical chairs as yo-yo clubs going forward. If parachute payments go then all 6 are screwed.