![]() |
|
Ratings - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=22023) Pages:
1
2
|
Ratings - rickbaggie - 10-16-2021 Sam 6 - little to do and poor distribution tonight Bartley 6 - had a brain fade moment in the second half otherwise solid Ajayi 8 - thought it was his best game this year Clarke 7 - good showing and even showed some skill getting forward Furlong 6 - didn’t notice him much. Solid enough Townsend 8.5 MOM - constant attacking channel down the left. Best position Mowatt 6 - not his usual high intensity performance. Not 100% and withdrawn injured Livermore 6 - usual combative self Phillips 6 - had good moments but no real threat on goal Robinson 5 - disappointing after excellent international performances Grant 7 - anonymous first half but grew into game. Some tracking back efforts (particularly against Bela) was horrible to watch. Improved and higher rating due to excellent finish Molumby - 7 tidy and deputised well for Mowatt Hugill 6 usual threw himself about but very limited player Reach not on long enough Overall a yawn fest despite a very nice Grant goal RE: Ratings - BasingBaggie - 10-16-2021 If Phillips gets a 6, then everybody else should be at least 8 minimum. Would swap Clarke and Ajayi, Phillips 4 and whilst he won’t get much credit on this board Hugill once he settled did an awful lot to retain the ball up front and bring in the other players. Something sadly lacking in the first 50 minutes. RE: Ratings - Dumbo - 10-16-2021 Townsend the best best player on the park. Clarke was good. Molumby impressed. The rest were meh. A tough watch but 3 points. On to Swans… One thing I was impressed with though was how we managed the game after we scored. It was our best spell of the game. Especially in the 4 minutes of added time, we kept the ball in the corner for the entirety pretty much. The best seeing out of a game I can remember tbf. RE: Ratings - Fido - 10-16-2021 (10-16-2021, 06:50 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Townsend the best best player on the park. Clarke was good. Molumby impressed. The rest were meh. All of the above. Townsend rightly gets the plaudits but Clarke gave us much more stability and calm, allowed Townsend to get wide and supported him well down that flank. RE: Ratings - shadman - 10-16-2021 I'd join the shout out for Hugill too. Thought he did far better v B'ham last night. As well as making a nuisance of himself, actually held on to the ball sometimes. RE: Ratings - Lillwall's left foot - 10-16-2021 (10-16-2021, 07:18 AM)Fido Wrote:(10-16-2021, 06:50 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Townsend the best best player on the park. Clarke was good. Molumby impressed. The rest were meh. Agreed. Clarke a very important player for us. Looked a little rusty but calm and solid. Got done like a kipper by Chong once and immediately took him OUT of the game. Defender! RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 10-16-2021 MY biggest gripe last night was both Jake and Mowatt sat deep so all our football was infront of Blues working the ball wide to the ineffective (again) Furlong and excellent Townsend, as I've said before I'd love to see Phillips in for Furlong when we're at home against sides intending to defend, Furlong is currently offering no threat in the opposition's final third, either from open play or a throw in/corner One of the midfielders has to "break the lines" and support the forwards, this pulls Blues out of thier shape, we saw it earlier in the season with Mowatts goal v Sheff Utd being a great example, both of them last night refused to go anywhere near Blues 18 yard box and this makes us so predictable IMO Marks SJ 6 Good handling on Juke's shot in first half, little to do but one long throw headed away by Bartley 3 yards from our own goal in the first half was very poor, glued to his line when he should have come and punched away Furlong 5 Struggling with him currently and I'm a big fan, good in the air, good on the diagonals but that's it, poor delivery open play or set piece and we need a right footed Townsend on the other side carrying the same threat if we insist on playing with this formation Townsend 8* Makes a bit of a mockery of his prolonged stint at LCH these past few weeks, back where he belonged and the best player on the pitch by far Ajayi 7 Thought he was decent tonight, passed the ball better and seemed more confident on the ball Bartley 6 Solid enough, one mad 5 minutes again when he made a couple of errors in quick succession but won his share of headers Clarke 7 Excellent and can see how we missed him, natural balance with his left foot and excellent in the air Livermore 7 Borderline 6.5 but just thought he took the game by the scruff of the neck in the 2nd half and tried to make things happen, was a lot braver on the ball and tried to get us at Blues Mowatt 5 Clearly not 100% and generally poor tonight, too many sideways passing and not breaking the lines Robinson 5 Finishing in the warm up was sensational, clearly full of confidence but no change out of Blues first half, surprised he was hooked but maybe running on empty and one eye on Swansea Wednesday Phillips 5 Improved late in the game but was poor for the first 75 minutes, didn't hold the ball up at all Grant 6 Terrible first half and arguably should have been one hooked but much improved 2nd half, even before goal, which he took exceptionally well Subs Hugill 6: Did what he does, different dimension, worked hard, no goal threat but put himself about Moloumby 7: Different dynamic when he came on, did what he does, runs around puts a foot in but liked the fact he looked forward at every opportunity, looked to pass and move and something glossed over is it was his break into the box which meant Gardener left the space for Grant to score the goal, without that run Grant doesn't get the shot away, what we lacked, midfielders moving into the box and creating space Reach 6 - Last few minutes Swansea play real high risk football from the back so I'm sure we will revert to the early season type on Wednesday and really press and harrass high up the pitch, echo comments from others I wouldn't mind up having a Plan B on the shape of the side, it doesn't have to be 3-4-3 all the time, somebody playing off the opposition 3 centre halves would help us massively, I can only see teams setting up as Blues did pretty much most weeks until we face the likes of Fulham, Bournemouth, Sheff Utd who back their own style over ours Cuzer RE: Ratings - Fido - 10-16-2021 The frustrating element is you have a dangerous attacking threat now with Townsend and yet no-one foresees they may have to get into the box at some stage. Phillips can only ever play wide right IMVHO and as Cuzervsays if that means him playing the RWB position then so be it. RE: Ratings - EastMidsBaggie - 10-16-2021 Cuzer Wrote:MY biggest gripe last night was both Jake and Mowatt sat deep so all our football was infront of Blues working the ball wide to the ineffective (again) Furlong and excellent Townsend, as I've said before I'd love to see Phillips in for Furlong when we're at home against sides intending to defend, Furlong is currently offering no threat in the opposition's final third, either from open play or a throw in/corner Pretty much how I saw it with Grant's bit of brilliance getting out of jail just as a very limited Blues side looked like they could nick it. But, for those we weren't there and didn't give up their afternoon/evening to travel 100 plus miles and be there, until that bit of magic it was appalling flat in there despite a near full house. It was mind numbingly boring basically and the much triumphed high press attacking style was now where to be seen like in many recent games. It left a game so devoid of quality, ideas, invention or skill that suited Blues down to the ground (not that much football was spent on the said ground!). again we managed to come down to the limited opposition and couldn't impose or better quality until the goal. So many players looked unable to play the way VI wants yet again - the likes of Furlong (started the season so well now almost a passenger), Robbo, Mowatt, Phiilips looking shadows of the quality we know they can produce. Add the shocking distribution from SJ and a team that generally seemed to over hit most passes and the ball became a hot potato leaving few positives up until the goal. But, luckily, this time (unlike Stoke, Derby, Millwall) there were a few positives in addition to the result as Townsend, Clarke, Molumby, Ajayi and ,late on, Livermore looked good and Grant now seems to be discovering the confidence to be a match winner. The goal immediately killed off Blues and, like the QPR, game we finished strongly and could have had more. Add in top of the league for a few hours at least and things were much brighter driving home through overnight road works than they dared look after 70 minutes ! RE: Ratings - TETLEY74 - 10-16-2021 (10-16-2021, 11:19 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:Bang on that East Mids.Cuzer Wrote:MY biggest gripe last night was both Jake and Mowatt sat deep so all our football was infront of Blues working the ball wide to the ineffective (again) Furlong and excellent Townsend, as I've said before I'd love to see Phillips in for Furlong when we're at home against sides intending to defend, Furlong is currently offering no threat in the opposition's final third, either from open play or a throw in/corner |